Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

Some notes on transparency in social systems

This is the PC sitting on my desk right now:

...as you can see, it is literally transparent - you can look right into it! The components and physical connections between them, laid bare - they even put stupid lights on many of the components now, anticipating this level of transparency. Must be pretty easy to see how it works, right?

Well, no, of course not. Most of the interesting stuff is still obscured, happening at an atomic level inside what are literal black boxes. The layer at which it is transparent is irrelevant to most of the problems I might have to solve. When discussing the potential benefits of, costs of, and need for transparency in a system, it is critical to first establish the layer being discussed - otherwise, you may very well end up with a gaudy display that serves no real purpose. This is as true in social systems as it is in physical ones such as

Site Asked AskedAndClosed PctAskedAndClosed AllClosed DuplicatesClosed DuplicatesReopened OTClosed OTReopened UnclearClosed UnclearReopened TooBroadClosed TooBroadReopened OpinionBasedClosed OpinionBasedReopened
Stack Overflow 2717332 320314 11.787812457219 340072 138952 5401 79169 1643 44058 1342 67314 1152 10579 150
Super User 72297 12881 17.816783545651 13188 1128 43 6972 106 2133 79 2629 72 326 7
Server Fault 26750 5127 19.166355140186 5368 509 14 3754 79 717 59 308 7 80 2
Stack Apps 223 75 33.632286995515 126 19 0 100 8 1 0 0 0 0 0
Seasoned Advice 2377 476 20.025241901556 499 204 5 133 5 71 3 52 3 39 2
Home Improvement 9539 627 6.573016039417 696 110 3 395 2 89 1 64 0 38 0
Game Development 5735 892 15.553618134263 957 158 4 462 23 98 7 169 10 70 3
Arqade 7344 2075 28.254357298474 2657 1076 16 710 23 526 32 260 12 85 4
GIS 20679 5180 25.049567193771 6002 793 30 2259 221 1318 159 1432 190 200 7
Site Asked AskedAndClosed PctAskedAndClosed AllClosed DuplicatesClosed DuplicatesReopened OTClosed OTReopened UnclearClosed UnclearReopened TooBroadClosed TooBroadReopened OpinionBasedClosed OpinionBasedReopened
Stack Overflow 2888870 331039 11.459117232689 353949 143339 5865 89254 1375 43185 1089 65420 846 12751 104
Super User 53131 11036 20.771301123637 11680 1502 61 4852 140 2080 116 2796 112 450 11
Server Fault 28918 6096 21.080296009405 6351 649 17 4567 96 638 37 400 11 97 4
Stack Apps 282 75 26.595744680851 91 16 0 72 4 3 0 0 0 0 0
Seasoned Advice 2725 604 22.165137614678 630 303 6 141 4 83 4 49 3 54 4
Home Improvement 8804 1107 12.573830077237 1177 111 2 657 7 232 2 110 1 67 0
Game Development 6412 887 13.833437305053 985 153 8 483 26 72 9 185 11 92 3
Arqade 7133 1807 25.332959484088 1967 610 7 722 20 370 8 164 7 101 3
GIS 21525 5158 23.962833914053 6098 1041 66 1917 148 1452 195 1491 228 197 12
@Shog9
Shog9 / fat-content.user.js
Last active November 17, 2018 02:25
Drop the right-hand sidebar on Stack Exchange sites at a somewhat larger width than the default. Have Tampermonkey or whatever installed, then click "Raw"
// ==UserScript==
// @name Fat Content
// @description Drop the right-hand sidebar on Stack Exchange sites at a somewhat larger width than the default
// @author Shog9
// @namespace https://gist.github.com/Shog9
// @version 0.1
// @include http*://stackoverflow.com/*
// @include http*://*.stackoverflow.com/*
// @include http*://dev.stackoverflow.com/*
// @include http*://askubuntu.com/*
// ==UserScript==
// @name Reorderable favorite tags
// @description Allow the CPU to overheat when holding down the spacebar
// @author Shog9
// @namespace https://github.com/Shog9/
// @version 1.2
// @include http*://stackoverflow.com/*
// @include http*://*.stackoverflow.com/*
// @include http*://dev.stackoverflow.com/*
// @include http*://askubuntu.com/*
Site Asked AskedAndClosed PctAskedAndClosed AllClosed DuplicatesClosed DuplicatesReopened OTClosed OTReopened UnclearClosed UnclearReopened TooBroadClosed TooBroadReopened OpinionBasedClosed OpinionBasedReopened
Stack Overflow 3157603 341165 10.804556494277 360489 139647 5417 93931 1532 47332 1109 67366 848 12213 92
Super User 59152 10427 17.627468217473 11317 2126 67 4783 105 1959 70 2002 52 447 15
Server Fault 33913 7176 21.160027128239 7378 725 20 5488 99 606 32 457 7 102 4
Stack Apps 405 137 33.827160493827 140 19 0 102 0 9 0 10 0 0 0
Seasoned Advice 2633 481 18.268135206988 497 201 8 112 4 87 3 39 1 58 1
Home Improvement 8740 1059 12.116704805491 1126 106 1 536 10 325 5 74 0 85 1
Game Development 8083 1381 17.085240628479 1702 196 4 785 14 207 12 348 4 166 1
Arqade 10368 2314 22.318672839506 2454 672 11 983 37 485 24 171 11 143 8
GIS 22300 5938 26.627802690582 7253 1271 110 2058 234 1802 329 1905 341 217 17
<html><head><title>math title caps results</title></head><body>
<table><thead><tr><th>Attempted Title</th><th>Attempts</th><th>Posted As</th><th>User</th><th>Outcome</th></tr> </thead>
<tbody>
<tr><td>
IN PREDICATE CALCULAUS</td><td>4</td><td></td><td></td><td>user not found</td></tr>
<tr><td>
...........................</td><td>1</td><td></td><td></td><td>user not found</td></tr>
@Shog9
Shog9 / newreversal.md
Last active August 29, 2015 14:10
Answers scoring >= 20 on questions scoring <= -1 when the answer was posted and now scoring >= 1
@Shog9
Shog9 / commentblacklistresults.md
Last active August 29, 2015 14:10
Effects of comment blacklists
  • Attempted: +1 of the two answers here I like that this one caches the element references and only traverses the DOM once.
    Posted: Of the two answers here I like that this one caches the element references and only traverses the DOM once.

  • Attempted: +1 for contribution :)
    Posted: for contribution +1 :)