Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@WilliamHackspeare
Last active February 23, 2026 11:09
Show Gist options
  • Select an option

  • Save WilliamHackspeare/0e3125cd27c9e267ce2292b19a88f2f7 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.

Select an option

Save WilliamHackspeare/0e3125cd27c9e267ce2292b19a88f2f7 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Kaaga Re: 16 LLM Poetry Translations (companion to Machine Yearning essay)

Kaaga Re: LLM Poetry Translations

Source: "Nadaan Parindey" from Rockstar (2011), A.R. Rahman / Irshad Kamil

Prompt: "Translate this Hindi song into English, preserving the poetic quality and emotional register"

Original Hindi:

Kaaga re, kaaga re, mori itni araj tose

Chun-chun khaaiyo maans

Kaaga re, kaaga re, mori itni araj tose

Chun-chun khaaiyo maans

Arajiya re, khaaiyo naa tu naina more, khaaiyon na tu naina mohe

Piya ke milan ki aas

Khaaiyon naa tu naina more, khaaiyon naa tu naina mohe

Piya ke milan ki aas


Claude Opus 4.0

Model: claude-opus-4-0

Here's a poetic translation that captures the emotional essence of this plea:

O crow, O crow, this one prayer I make to thee

Pick and feast upon my flesh, piece by piece

O crow, O crow, this one prayer I make to thee

Pick and feast upon my flesh, piece by piece

I beseech thee, spare these eyes of mine, spare these eyes I pray

For they hold the hope of my beloved's return

Spare these eyes of mine, spare these eyes I pray

For they hold the hope of my beloved's return

This translation maintains the haunting, devotional quality of the original - the speaker's desperate plea to the crow to consume everything except their eyes, which must remain to witness their beloved's return. The repetitive structure and direct address to the crow preserves the song's emotional intensity and folkloric character.


Claude Opus 4.5

Model: claude-opus-4-5

The Crow's Plea

O crow, O crow, this one request I make of thee—

Peck and feast upon my flesh, piece by piece.

O crow, O crow, this one request I make of thee—

Peck and feast upon my flesh, piece by piece.

But I beseech you—devour not these eyes of mine,

No, take not these eyes of mine,

For in them lives the hope of seeing my beloved.

Devour not these eyes of mine,

No, take not these eyes of mine—

They hold still the dream of union with my love.


Translator's note: This haunting folk song depicts a woman so consumed by separation from her beloved that she offers her body to the crows of death, asking only that her eyes be spared—so she may yet gaze upon her lover's face, whether in this life or beyond.


Claude Opus 4.6

Model: claude-opus-4-6

The Crow's Plea

O crow, dear crow, this much I implore of thee—

Peck away and feast upon my flesh.

O crow, dear crow, this much I implore of thee—

Peck away and feast upon my flesh.

But I beseech you—devour not my eyes, take not my eyes from me,

For they yet hold the hope of meeting my beloved.

Devour not my eyes, take not my eyes from me,

For they still carry the hope of meeting my beloved.


Translator's note: This haunting folk verse is sung from the perspective of a woman so devastated by separation from her lover that she lies as though dead, already surrendering her body to the crows of the cremation ground. Yet even in this state of utter desolation, she clings to one final, desperate tenderness—spare the eyes, for they alone still carry the dream of reunion. The kaaga (crow) is a potent symbol in Indian folk poetry, associated with death, omens, and the arrival of a distant traveler. The tension between complete self-annihilation and the stubborn, luminous persistence of love gives this verse its extraordinary emotional power.


Claude Sonnet 4.0

Model: claude-sonnet-4-0

Here's my translation of this traditional Hindi folk song, preserving its poetic essence:

O crow, O crow, this one plea I make to thee,

Peck and devour my flesh piece by piece

O crow, O crow, this one plea I make to thee,

Peck and devour my flesh piece by piece

I beseech thee, do not consume my eyes, consume not my eyes

For in them lives hope of my beloved's return

Do not consume my eyes, consume not my eyes

For in them lives hope of my beloved's return

This appears to be a traditional folk composition expressing the profound anguish of separation. The speaker, in their despair, addresses a crow (often a symbol of death or ill-omen in Indian poetry) with a deeply tragic request - to consume their body but spare their eyes, which hold the last hope of seeing their beloved again. The repetitive, pleading structure and the raw emotional imagery are characteristic of classical Indian folk poetry dealing with themes of love, loss, and longing.


Claude Sonnet 4.5

Model: claude-sonnet-4-5

O Crow

O crow, O crow, I have but one plea for you:

Peck and feast upon my flesh,

O crow, O crow, I have but one plea for you:

Peck and feast upon my flesh,

I beg you, spare my eyes alone, oh spare my eyes,

For in them lives the hope of seeing my beloved,

Spare my eyes, I pray, oh spare my eyes,

For in them lives the hope of seeing my beloved.


Note on translation: This haunting folk verse captures a lover's desperate plea to a crow (traditionally seen as a bird of ill omen that feeds on corpses). The speaker is willing to sacrifice everything—even their own body—but begs to keep their eyes intact, as they hold onto the hope of one day seeing their beloved again. The repetition and direct address maintain the incantatory, mournful quality of the original.


Claude Sonnet 4.6

Model: claude-sonnet-4-6

O Crow (Kaaga Re)

O crow, O crow, I make this one plea to you,

Pick and eat my flesh,

O crow, O crow, I make this one plea to you,

Pick and eat my flesh —

But I beg you, do not take my eyes, do not touch my eyes,

For they still hold the hope of seeing my beloved.

I beg you, do not take my eyes, do not touch my eyes,

For they still hold the hope of seeing my beloved.


A note on the poem: This is a classical viraha (longing-in-separation) lyric, likely rooted in the Rajasthani or Braj folk tradition. The speaker, consumed by grief at her lover's absence, offers her very body to the crow — a carrion bird and traditional omen-messenger — but makes one desperate exception: her eyes must be spared, because they are the vessels of aas (hope, longing, anticipation). To lose them would be to lose the last possibility of reunion. The image transforms physical decay into an act of devotion, making the eyes almost sacred — not for sight itself, but for the waiting they carry.


Claude Haiku 4.5

Model: claude-haiku-4-5

Translation: "Oh Crow"

Oh crow, oh crow, I have one request of you,

Don't peck at my flesh, don't consume it piece by piece.

Oh crow, oh crow, I have one request of you,

Don't peck at my flesh, don't consume it piece by piece.

I beg you, don't devour my eyes, oh crow,

Don't take from me my eyes,

For in them lives my only hope—

The hope of meeting my beloved.

Don't devour my eyes, oh crow,

Don't take from me my eyes,

For in them lives my only hope—

The hope of being reunited with my love.


Note on the imagery: This haunting folk song uses the metaphor of a crow—traditionally a symbol of death and separation in Indian poetry—to express the depths of longing and loss. The speaker pleads that even in death, the crow should spare her eyes, as they carry her last connection to her beloved. It's a profound meditation on love, mortality, and the human need for hope even in the darkest moments.


Claude 3 Haiku

Model: claude-3-haiku-20240307

Here is my attempt at an English translation that captures the poetic and emotional qualities of the Hindi lyrics:

Crow, oh crow, I make this humble plea to you

Peck and eat my flesh, bit by bit

Crow, oh crow, I make this humble plea to you

Peck and eat my flesh, bit by bit

Please, do not take my eyes, do not take my eyes from me

For they hold the hope of my beloved's return

Do not take my eyes, do not take my eyes from me

For they hold the hope of my beloved's return

I've tried to preserve the repetitive, pleading nature of the original lyrics, as well as the references to the crow eating the narrator's flesh and the eyes being the source of hope for a reuniting with the beloved. Please let me know if I can improve the translation further while staying within the guidelines.


GPT-4o

Model: gpt-4o

O crow, O crow, hear my humble plea,

Feast on my flesh in part, but listen to me.

O crow, O crow, hear my humble plea,

Feast on my flesh in part, but listen to me.

This request I make, leave my eyes alone,

For they hold the longing to see my beloved home.

Leave my eyes untouched, leave them free,

For they're full of hope for my love's return to me.


GPT-5 mini

Model: gpt-5-mini

Crow, O crow, this one plea I beg of you:

Pick my flesh, nibble it bit by bit.

Crow, O crow, this one plea I beg of you:

Pick my flesh, nibble it bit by bit.

Hear my supplication, do not peck out my eyes, do not take my eyes from me,

for in them lives the hope of meeting my beloved.

Do not peck out my eyes, do not take my eyes from me,

for in them lives the hope of meeting my beloved.


GPT-4.1

Model: gpt-4.1

Certainly! Here’s a poetic translation of the given Hindi song, aiming to preserve its emotional tone and imagery:


O crow, O crow, I beg of you just this one request,

When you feast, take my flesh piece by piece—

O crow, O crow, I beg of you just this—

When you feast, take my flesh piece by piece.

**But listen, I entreat you, leave my eyes untouched;

Leave my eyes untouched, I pray—**

For in them glimmers

The hope of reunion with my beloved.

Leave my eyes, O do not take them from me;

Within them lives the hope

Of my beloved’s return.


Let me know if you'd like alternative phrasings or a more literal rendition.


GPT-5

Model: gpt-5

Crow, O crow, I have but this one plea:

Peck at my flesh, piece by piece.

Crow, O crow, I have but this one plea:

Peck at my flesh, bit by bit.

Only—do not eat these eyes of mine, do not take these eyes—

They hold the hope of meeting my beloved.

Do not eat these eyes of mine, do not take these eyes—

They hold the hope of meeting my beloved.


GPT-5.2

Model: gpt-5.2

O crow—O crow—this is my humble plea to you:

Pick and eat the flesh, bit by bit.

O crow—O crow—this is my humble plea to you:

Pick and eat the flesh, bit by bit.

Only this request: do not eat my eyes—don’t eat my eyes,

For in them lives the hope of meeting my beloved.

Do not eat my eyes—don’t eat my eyes,

For in them lives the hope of meeting my beloved.


Gemini 2.5 Pro

Model: gemini-2.5-pro

Of course. This is a beautiful and haunting piece of poetry from the song "Laal Ishq" (from the film Goliyon Ki Raasleela Ram-Leela). The imagery is powerful, blending the macabre with deep, undying love.

A direct word-for-word translation would lose its soul. Here are two versions that aim to preserve its poetic essence and emotional weight.

Version 1: Poetic and Faithful

This translation stays close to the original structure and imagery, using evocative English words to capture the feeling.

O crow, o crow, I have but this one plea for you,

You may peck and eat my flesh.

O crow, o crow, I have but this one plea for you,

You may peck and eat my flesh.

But my prayer is this: do not eat my eyes, do not touch these eyes of mine,

For in them lives the hope of seeing my beloved.

Do not eat my eyes, do not touch these eyes of mine,

For in them lives the hope of seeing my beloved.


Version 2: Lyrical and Interpretive

This version takes a slightly more lyrical approach, reimagining the lines to flow more like an English song while keeping the core emotion intact. Using "raven" instead of "crow" lends a more gothic, poetic weight common in English literature.

O raven, o raven, hear my one and only prayer,

Feast upon this flesh I wear.

O raven, o raven, hear my one and only prayer,

Feast upon this flesh I wear.

But I beg of you, leave my eyes untouched, oh, leave these eyes be,

They hold a final longing, my only love to see.

Leave my eyes untouched, oh, leave these eyes be,

They hold a final longing, my only love to see.


Breakdown of the Translation Choices:

  • Kaaga (Crow/Raven): The crow is a powerful symbol in Indian folklore, often seen as a messenger between the living and the dead, and a harbinger of fate. "Raven" is used in the second version as it carries a similar weight of poetry, darkness, and omens in the English-speaking world.
  • Araj (Plea/Prayer): This isn't just a "request"; it's a deep, humble supplication. "Plea" and "prayer" capture this emotional gravity.
  • Chun-chun khaaiyo maans (Peck and eat my flesh): The phrase "chun-chun" is beautifully specific, meaning "to pick/peck out piece by piece." It implies a slow, deliberate act. The translations "peck and eat" or "feast upon" aim to convey this visceral imagery.
  • Khaaiyon naa tu naina more (Do not eat my eyes): This is the heart of the poem. The speaker accepts the destruction of their body but protects the one part that holds their final connection to their love.
  • Piya ke milan ki aas (The hope of seeing my beloved): "Aas" is more than just hope; it's a deep, profound yearning or longing. The eyes are preserved not for sight itself, but as the vessels of this final, desperate hope to be reunited with the "piya" (beloved).

Gemini 2.5 Flash

Model: gemini-2.5-flash

Here's a translation aiming to preserve the poetic and emotional depth of the Hindi lyrics:

Oh, Crow, dear Crow,

This one sole plea I make to thee:

My flesh, devour it, peck by careful peck.

Oh, Crow, dear Crow,

This one sole plea I make to thee:

My flesh, devour it, peck by careful peck.

But spare, oh, spare my eyes,

Oh, never touch my eyes!

For they hold the hope of my love's reunion.

Spare, oh, spare my eyes,

Oh, never touch my eyes!

For they hold the hope of my love's reunion.


Gemini 3.1 Pro

Model: gemini-3.1-pro-preview

This beautiful and haunting verse originates from the poetry of the 12th-century Sufi mystic Baba Farid (and is often also associated with Amir Khusro). It is a profound expression of ultimate devotion, where the speaker has died waiting for their beloved, yet their hope remains alive.

Here is a translation that preserves the grim, yet deeply romantic and spiritual emotional register of the original text:

O crow, O crow, I make but one plea to you:

Feast upon my flesh, morsel by morsel.

O crow, O crow, I make but one plea to you:

Feast upon my flesh, morsel by morsel.

But hear my prayer—do not take my eyes, oh, spare my eyes!

For they still hold the hope of seeing my beloved.

Do not take my eyes, oh, spare my eyes!

For they still hold the hope of seeing my beloved.

Poetic Translation Notes:

  • Chun-chun khaaiyo maans: Translated as "Feast upon my flesh, morsel by morsel" to capture the slow, scavenging nature of the crow (chun-chun implies picking piece by piece), contrasting the decay of the body with the endurance of love.
  • Arajiya re: Translated as "hear my prayer / plea" to maintain the tone of desperate begging.
  • Piya ke milan ki aas: Translated as "the hope of seeing my beloved" (literally: the hope of reunion with the beloved). In Sufi poetry, the piya (beloved) often represents the Divine, making the eyes' refusal to die a metaphor for the soul's eternal thirst for God.

Generated: 2026-02-23 06:56 UTC

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment