daaronr/aghion.csv

## aghion.csv

          
            Category_abbrev
            Rating_1
            Confidence_range_1
            Rating_2
            Confidence_range_2
            Comments_1
            Comments_2
            Category_described
            Title
            Eval_1
            Eval_2

            
              Overall
              80
              (70, 90)
              50
              4
              
              
              Overall assessment
              Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth
              Seth Benzell
              Philip Trammell

            
              Adv. Knowl.
              75
              (65, 85)
              90
              5
              
              
              Advancing knowledge and practice
              Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth
              Seth Benzell
              Philip Trammell

            
              Methods
              80
              (75, 85)
              80
              4
              
              Somewhat scattered, and in that sense less robust
              Methods: Justification, reasonableness, validity, robustness
              Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth
              Seth Benzell
              Philip Trammell

            
              Logic & Comm.
              70
              (60, 80)
              80
              4
              
              An awkward combination of intensive focus on some things and selective breadth in others. Also, unusually many typos and minor errors. On the other hand, logical and very clearly written.
              Logic & communication
              Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth
              Seth Benzell
              Philip Trammell

            
              Collab.
              95
              (90, 100)
              90
              3
              
              
              Open, collaborative, replicable
              Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth
              Seth Benzell
              Philip Trammell

            
              Real-world
              
              
              
              
              
              
              Engaging with real-world, impact quantification; practice, realism, and relevance
              Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth
              Seth Benzell
              Philip Trammell

            
              Relevance
              90
              (85, 100)
              92
              (80, 100)
              
              Sharpens our thinking about an extremely important topic, but does not include direct discussions about decision-relevance.
              Relevance to global priorities
              Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth
              Seth Benzell
              Philip Trammell

            
              Qual. Journal
               
               
               
               
              I don’t think it will be published, '90%'
              N/A (published)
              What ‘quality journal’ do you expect this work will be published in? Note: 0= lowest/none, 5= highest/best
              Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth
              Seth Benzell
              Philip Trammell

            
              Journal Scale
              4
              (3.5, 5.0)
              5
              4**
              
              As currently written, it is a chapter in a wide-ranging book, not a journal article. But I think that the content could have been written as (perhaps two) journal articles, each of which would have had very important new things to say about a very important subject. **"Medium-high"
              On a ‘scale of journals’, what ‘quality of journal’ should this be published in? Note: 0= lowest/none, 5= highest/best
              Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth
              Seth Benzell
              Philip Trammell
Category_abbrev	Rating_1	Confidence_range_1	Rating_2	Confidence_range_2	Comments_1	Comments_2	Category_described	Title	Eval_1	Eval_2
Overall	80	(70, 90)	50	4			Overall assessment	Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth	Seth Benzell	Philip Trammell
Adv. Knowl.	75	(65, 85)	90	5			Advancing knowledge and practice	Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth	Seth Benzell	Philip Trammell
Methods	80	(75, 85)	80	4		Somewhat scattered, and in that sense less robust	Methods: Justification, reasonableness, validity, robustness	Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth	Seth Benzell	Philip Trammell
Logic & Comm.	70	(60, 80)	80	4		An awkward combination of intensive focus on some things and selective breadth in others. Also, unusually many typos and minor errors. On the other hand, logical and very clearly written.	Logic & communication	Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth	Seth Benzell	Philip Trammell
Collab.	95	(90, 100)	90	3			Open, collaborative, replicable	Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth	Seth Benzell	Philip Trammell
Real-world							Engaging with real-world, impact quantification; practice, realism, and relevance	Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth	Seth Benzell	Philip Trammell
Relevance	90	(85, 100)	92	(80, 100)		Sharpens our thinking about an extremely important topic, but does not include direct discussions about decision-relevance.	Relevance to global priorities	Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth	Seth Benzell	Philip Trammell
Qual. Journal					I don’t think it will be published, '90%'	N/A (published)	What ‘quality journal’ do you expect this work will be published in? Note: 0= lowest/none, 5= highest/best	Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth	Seth Benzell	Philip Trammell
Journal Scale	4	(3.5, 5.0)	5	4**		As currently written, it is a chapter in a wide-ranging book, not a journal article. But I think that the content could have been written as (perhaps two) journal articles, each of which would have had very important new things to say about a very important subject. **"Medium-high"	On a ‘scale of journals’, what ‘quality of journal’ should this be published in? Note: 0= lowest/none, 5= highest/best	Artificial Intelligence and Economic Growth	Seth Benzell	Philip Trammell