A syllogistic condensation of questions and ideas raised by nostalgebraist
Source: nostalgebraist, “Models may behave differently in graded episodes: a tirade”
This is a reconstruction, not a transcript; the wording and formalization are ours.
This extracts and compresses interesting questions and propositions raised by the post into explicit premises and conclusions. The purpose is not to judge whether these propositions are true, nor to characterize how strongly nostalgebraist believes each of them. Some are hypotheses entertained in the post, some are arguments or implications developed there, and some are our attempts to make the questions it raises maximally explicit. The standard for inclusion is: is this an interesting idea that the post puts on the table?