My comment on http://www.nomorejavascript.com/ was deleted. So much for a fair and balanced discussion.
I think the idea is noble, but the people behind the idea are clearly inept.
One big reason JavaScript will be hard to replace is that it's been through years of battle testing and it's security holes have mostly been patched. You would have to start this process from scratch with a new language, which in itself is a good reason not to bother.
Here are my comments in reponse to their arguments for a new language:
- Camel casing is not a language feature. You can use underscores in your variable names if you want.
- node.js is not a library, it's a JavaScript runtime.