Create a gist now

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@BPScott /readme.md
Last active Jun 20, 2017

What would you like to do?
Github suggestion: Per-organization email overrides

This totally happened, y'all can stop +1ing this now. GitHub Blog post. Direct link to settings where you can set this.


#Per-organization / per-repo email overrides - A feature suggestion

Here the concepts "organization" and "user" are interchangeable, I'm talking about an entity that owns a repo, whether it is jQuery or John Resig. I'll stick to using organization as it best represents my original use-case.

##TL;DR

I want to get notifications from my work organization in my work email account, not my personal one. Github should provide an interface for this that isn't "setup forwarding in your personal email".

##The Situation

I use Github for personal projects and as part of a work organization. Currently Github sends all my notifications into a single inbox - my personal one.

##The Problem

I don't want everything to go to my personal email. I want notifications on my work projects to go to my work email and notifications on my personal projects to go to my personal email. Optionally repeat for any other hypothetical organization I might be a member of / user or repo I interact with.

##The Workaround

I can setup forwarding rules in my personal email based off the List-ID header (As told to the masses in this blog post, under "Filter Notifications by Repository or User" but this feels clunky, as though it should be managed as part of Github.

##The Solution

Create an option that allows me to override the email that my notifications should be sent to on a per organization / repo basis.

Github already knows what organization and repo a notification relates to as it sets the List-ID header, changing the from header based off these details that are already exposed should be pretty simple. I already specify the emails addresses I use at https://github.com/account/email. Perhaps an option on there for "receives notifications from: default | organization | organization/repo". Later per-email address notification settings could be added on https://github.com/account/notifications.

##Thoughts?

jkrall commented Dec 26, 2011

+1

thizzle commented Jan 17, 2012

+1

Huge +1 emblazoned in fire

aantix commented Feb 6, 2012

+1

+1

hishma commented Feb 12, 2012

+1

+1

mkhq commented Feb 23, 2012

+1

dohse commented Feb 23, 2012

+1

arfrank commented Feb 27, 2012

+1

robcowie commented Mar 5, 2012

+1

nvkelso commented Mar 11, 2012

+1

+1

eliotb commented Mar 16, 2012

+1

bgipsy commented Mar 19, 2012

+1

eliotb commented Mar 21, 2012

BTW I submitted a support request pointing at this gist, got this response 2012-03-17

From: Tekkub (GitHub Staff)
Subject: [Contact] per org and per repo email notificatin preferences
Thanks for the feedback. I've added your suggestion to the Feature Request Listβ„’ for the team to see.

Please oh please.

+1 for sure!

πŸ‘

+1

tomash commented Mar 26, 2012

+1
pretty please, github team

mackuba commented Mar 26, 2012

+1

+1

I've got a raging +1 for this.

rick commented Mar 26, 2012

meh ;-)

caius commented Mar 26, 2012

πŸ‘

gwaldo commented Mar 26, 2012

This. A Thousand times, This.

πŸ‘

I've wanted this many, many times.

rhyss commented Mar 26, 2012

+1

remi commented Mar 26, 2012

+1

+9001

+1

+1. I've asked for this before & would love to have it.

+1

Tsubomi commented Mar 30, 2012

+1

mithin commented Apr 2, 2012

+1 Need this badly.

Yes

marijn commented Apr 4, 2012

πŸ‘

sole commented Apr 4, 2012

+10!

pguelpa commented Apr 4, 2012

+1

+1

bergman commented Apr 10, 2012

+1

ansman commented Apr 10, 2012

+1

+1 for unsubscribing to new comments on a gist you previously commented on, AMIRIGHT?

marijn commented Apr 10, 2012

peralmq commented Apr 10, 2012

+1

The irony is, @blowmage's comment is just gas on the fire.

+1

riquito commented Apr 19, 2012

+1

ivanz commented Apr 20, 2012

+100000000000.

+1

+1

+1

kn0ll commented Apr 25, 2012

+1

brdw commented Apr 25, 2012

+1

@blowmage Here's how to unsubscribe from comments on a gist: https://github.com/settings/notifications

@fromonesrc That turns off ALL gist notifications. When there's comments on a commit, there's a link that says "turn off notifications for this commit". That's what we want for gists.

asm commented May 8, 2012

+1

davidjb commented May 9, 2012

+1, at very least per-organisation settings

  • a lot.

+1
I just want to be able to disable all emails from a particular Organization that I am in.

rojoca commented May 11, 2012

+1

marijn commented May 11, 2012

Is anyone from @github aware of this Feature Request?

marijn commented May 11, 2012

And we really need a way to unfollow comments on individual gists.

eliotb commented May 11, 2012

@marijn see my comment on March 21. But no harm in submitting a support request yourself...

iawgens commented May 14, 2012

+1

+1

rhardih commented May 30, 2012

+1

chrisb commented May 31, 2012

+1

bobstir commented May 31, 2012

+1

+1

jbaugh commented May 31, 2012

+1

jgh- commented Jun 4, 2012

+1

ArtS commented Jun 8, 2012

+100500

ArtS commented Jun 14, 2012

Now, how do I unsubscribe from this?

ArtS commented Jun 14, 2012

To unsubscribe:

https://github.com/settings/notifications
un-tick "comments in gists after me"

Again, as has been said before on this page, that turns of ALL of them. We need a way to turn them off for just this gist, like you can for commits.

πŸ‘

πŸ‘ πŸ‘ πŸ‘ πŸ‘

dlee commented Jun 19, 2012

πŸ‘

+1 from me and 50+ Zendesk engineers

skalee commented Jun 22, 2012

+1

brdw commented Jun 22, 2012

breno commented Jun 28, 2012

+1

+1

tyom commented Jul 3, 2012

Yes please!

NARKOZ commented Jul 6, 2012

People who belong to organizations do things, not organizations.Β 

kn0ll commented Jul 6, 2012

bump

torjue commented Jul 9, 2012

+1

nicomen commented Jul 9, 2012

+1

marijn commented Jul 10, 2012

@github has about one 100 employees. Let's mention them all in here, someone has to think this is worth their time...

@kneath, @holman, @defunkt

@marijn Both the requests for a per-organization/per-repo email override and disabling notifications for an individual gist have already been submitted to GitHub and are in Feature Request Listβ„’. I don't have the ticket numbers for them in their Tender instance however.

That said, at the rate GitHub is hiring chances are very good that someone who commented on this gist is going to be hired soon, so we just need to be patient. :)

akavlie commented Jul 11, 2012

+1 -- found this via a Google search to see if this is possible.

+1

jimdanz commented Jul 17, 2012

+1, same comment as akaville -- Googled for this feature and wound up on this page.

+1 -- found this via a Google search to see if this is possible.

deleet commented Jul 20, 2012

+1

Make the puppy happy and implement this.

hans-tt commented Jul 21, 2012

+1

base698 commented Jul 27, 2012

+1

freeeve commented Jul 29, 2012

+1

+1

RaVbaker commented Aug 6, 2012

+1

jimdanz commented Aug 6, 2012

And we win! See "Per organization email routing" on https://github.com/blog/1204-notifications .

Thanks github!

blowmage commented Aug 6, 2012

GitHub released this functionality today. See the blog post about the new notification features, including "Per organization email routing".

https://github.com/blog/1204-notifications-stars

You can set your email routing per organization here:

https://github.com/settings/notifications

Please stop "+1" commenting on this gist.

GitHub listened and gave us this feature. Now if we could control gist notifications similar to thread notifications... ;)

cwarden commented Sep 11, 2012

Now we need a way of setting the email address that's used for the Author and Committer when merging pull requests through the web interface.

+1 on what @cwarden says. We need that.

fabrejc commented Jan 30, 2013

+1

+1 for @cwarden's suggestion.

Help! How do I unsubscribe do emails about an organisation? (Without leaving the organisation). Blowmage's page wasn't any use - it just has a drop down box with my email address in it - no way to unsubscribe.

Help! How do I unsubscribe do emails about an organisation? (Without leaving the organisation). Blowmage's page wasn't any use - it just has a drop down box with my email address in it - no way to unsubscribe.

shivawu commented Apr 7, 2013

+1
I really don't understand why github doesn't have this option

Github has this option now:
Go to Edit your profile -> Emails. Add your organization email and verify it. Go to notification center tab. Select email for the organization.

swrobel commented May 2, 2013

Just set this up, it works!

Works!

Thank you, @createman

Another thank you to @createman.

miketwo commented Sep 12, 2013

Awesome! Thanks!

Schweet.

theneva commented Oct 15, 2013

This made me so very happy. Thank you!

rdp commented Dec 18, 2013

now if it only had an option to email no one for certain organizations we're only loosely tied to...(update, this is possible by "unwatching" the repo's, so I guess what I want is the option to not automatically watch an org's repo's...)

oleks commented Jan 30, 2014

+1

tachiba commented Feb 21, 2014

+1

spadin commented Feb 26, 2014

+1

marctrem commented Apr 4, 2014

+1

+1

drusepth commented Jul 8, 2014

+1

+1

Vic-L commented Jul 23, 2014

+1

+1

+1

Thanks createman!

createman commented on Apr 25, 2013
Github has this option now:
Go to Edit your profile -> Emails. Add your organization email and verify it. Go to notification center tab. Select email for the organization.

Astone commented Aug 12, 2014

+1

cxmcc commented Aug 20, 2014

+1

πŸ‘

πŸ‘

πŸ‘

sflint commented Oct 16, 2014

+10000

suan commented Oct 16, 2014

Per @thedarkwinter there's a way to do this now

+1

+1

jonyer commented Nov 17, 2014

+1

vartagg commented Nov 27, 2014

+1

igr commented Dec 1, 2014

+1.01

+1

agconti commented Dec 21, 2014

+1

kianlavi commented Jan 6, 2015

+1

haarabi commented Jan 10, 2015

+1

jasonxp commented Feb 18, 2015

This has been implemented. See Notification email/Custom routing here: https://github.com/settings/notifications

plopesc commented Mar 18, 2015

+1

I confused myself for a short while, so adding a note for future clarity. Despite the words "Here the concepts "organization" and "user" are interchangeable, I'm talking about an entity that owns a repo, whether it is jQuery or John Resig." the feature that was added only permits you to route emails based on entities that you are a part of. If you are part of an organisation you can route emails, if you just watch their repositories you cannot. Obviously, I cannot be another person either.

I had wanted to split the notifications for my work related lurking and my personal lurking to go to two separate accounts. That is not how the new feature functions. My options are:

  1. Ask to join the organisation's relating to my work, so that I can send notifications for them to my word address.
  2. Setup my personal email to forward certain notification emails on to my work email.

I am not sure that keeping up to date on the activities of a repo is enough justification for me to ask to join an organisation. I am not likely to get permitted much time from my work to spend actively contributing to the projects. All I need is to follow developments, check for interoperability with our stuff and note the odd bug.

+100

liopic commented Jun 19, 2015

+1

Thanks for implementing.

πŸ‘

lameyer commented Jul 21, 2015

+1

jspiro commented Jul 22, 2015

+1

aboutlo commented Aug 4, 2015

+1

+1

wrigby commented Sep 18, 2015

+1

+1

153957 commented Oct 11, 2015

+1

jishaal commented Oct 14, 2015

+1

+1 what @cwarden said - I want my mergers from github's web interface to use my work email!

lithid commented Dec 8, 2015

πŸ‘

+1 on what @cwarden said: I want to use my work email when using github's web interface to merge PRs in my organization's repos.

Is there a separate issue written up for that?

+1

eflee commented Jan 4, 2016

+1

angellaa commented Jan 8, 2016

πŸ‘ I would love this please

aaani commented Jan 8, 2016

+1

To all of you, who is still printing out plus ones: guys, read the comments first! The ISSUE IS FIXED now, as createman rightfully pointed out on Apr 25, 2013!

@innokenty. Many of the +1s above are for something that is not present. The ability to choose your email that's used as the commiter email when merging pull-requests. If my personal email is my primary email then whenever I merge a pull-request for work it will show up in the git log as the commiter for the merge-commit.

seglberg commented Mar 9, 2016

πŸ‘ for being able to set the email used for merging pull-requests. Like others have commented, my personal email is used when I merge in PRs for my organization, which is less than ideal.

+1 setting email per org, for merging pull-requests, etc, would be very useful (and isn't possible today)

Here is an issue about it, in a pseudo 'issue tracker' for Github itself, feel free to add a comment or +1 over there: isaacs/github#95

benoror commented May 3, 2016

+1 πŸ‘

VladUreche commented May 3, 2016 edited

EDIT: Please don't add your +1, it's implemented: https://gist.github.com/BPScott/1366790#gistcomment-392121

jonhy81 commented May 26, 2016

+1

+1 for Email override for pull requests. I just merged a PR on my company repo which used my personal email for the commit..

perlun commented Aug 15, 2016

Please create a new gist for the new functionality. Having a flood of +1 both for the original feature and a lot of +1 after it was implemented is really confusing. Yes, I know you are asking for another function, but it's not strictly the same. So please stop hijacking this gist for another (related) feature request. πŸ˜›

pantosh commented Sep 9, 2016

+1

πŸ‘

cmey commented Oct 27, 2016

+1

selbyk commented Nov 9, 2016

+1

cdupont commented Nov 23, 2016

+1

Any thoughts on per repository email notifications. For example, contributing to a client repo representing my organisation.

nei commented Dec 23, 2016

+1

dezman commented Dec 28, 2016

yaaaaas

TheYurry commented Jan 3, 2017

+1

midwire commented Jan 19, 2017

+1 please

avidit commented Jan 31, 2017

+1

talsafran commented Feb 4, 2017 edited

+1 please! Super important for OSS contributors, freelancers, nomads, etc :)

+1

sryze commented Mar 2, 2017

πŸ‘

+1

+1

+1

+1

+2

dlyash commented Jun 20, 2017

It looks like it's implemented for notifications only.

The primary address is still used when merging pull requests withing an organization :(

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment