Last active
September 21, 2021 16:09
-
-
Save GeePawHill/9fa0b38eec2fa47876e4bf7c230cd951 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Exquisite re-framing of the Blind Men and the Elephant
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
The relationality of all experience contains challenges to our understanding of organizations that we have | |
barely begun to come to terms with. I can illustrate this by extending the metaphor of the blind men and | |
the elephant. In its conventional telling, each blind man had a grip on a different part of the beast, and | |
they were unable to agree on what it was really, really like, that is, as one of Kuhn's "fixed and neutral | |
experiences." But there is more, for the elephant isn't just standing there but instead ambles through the | |
forest and the veldt. The blind men are trying to understand the system as it evolves and as their experience | |
of it unfolds. The blind man clinging to a leg experiences an elliptical forward motion. He who has the | |
misfortune to have hold of the tail is jerked and whipped about in a random fashion. A few feet forward, his | |
colleague, in the crotch, is periodically flooded and/or pasted with output that seems to have nothing to do | |
with the beast's motion or with the feel of the surface clung to. At the front end, another observer rides | |
the probing trunk, jerked and whipped like the tail man but, it seems to him, in a somehow "purposeful" manner. | |
Clinging high up on the massive haunch is another perceiver, subjected to none of the motions or indignities | |
of his fellows and wondering what their gasps and protestations are all about. And the observer who is astride | |
the massive neck, an accidental mahout, finds that the flexings and shifting of his ours body seem to correlate | |
with the gait and momentum of the beast. This leads him to think he is steering it and thus is uniquely | |
qualified to say what it really, really is. | |
And we with sight-what of us? Is sight in the metaphor an analogue to science in real life? Is our experience | |
different from each blind man's? Yes. Does it replace each blind man's? No. Are we the captives of our standpoint | |
fully as much as each blind man? Yes. | |
Peter B. Vaill. Spirited Leading and Learning: Process Wisdom for a New Age (J-B US non-Franchise Leadership) (Kindle Locations 192-203). Kindle Edition. |
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment