Last active
November 26, 2023 11:35
-
-
Save Hermann-SW/76e7cf8545c5e8b0332faeaad878e08f to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Kunerth's algorithm from 1878, for determining modular sqrt
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
assert(b,s)=if(!(b), error(Str(s))); | |
m=eval(getenv("m")); | |
b=m.mod; | |
c=lift(m); | |
if(ispseudoprime(c),s=sqrt(Mod(-b,c)),issquare(Mod(b,-c),&s)); | |
V=r=lift(s);; | |
print("V=",r); | |
e=simplify(((c*z+r)^2+b)/c); | |
f=1; | |
w=polcoeff(e,0); | |
if(type(w)!="t_INT"||w<0,e=simplify(((c*z+r)^2-b)/c);f=-1;w=polcoeff(e,0)); | |
print("e=",e); | |
print("f=",f); | |
assert(issquare(w,&W)); | |
print("W=",W); | |
beta=-(V\W); | |
alpha=W*(V+W*beta); | |
print("alpha=",alpha); | |
print("beta=",beta); | |
xx=alpha^2*x^2+(2*alpha*beta-f*b)*x+(beta^2-c); | |
print("xx=",xx); | |
nfr=nfroots(,xx); | |
print("nfr=",nfr); | |
{ | |
foreach(nfr,X, | |
Y=Mod(alpha*X+beta,b); | |
if(lift(Y^2)==c, | |
print("X=",X); | |
print("Y=",Y); | |
print("Y^2=",Y^2))); | |
} | |
print("all asserts OK"); | |
write("/dev/stderr", "\nb=m.mod; c=lift(m); V=r=lift(\"sqrt\"(Mod(-b,c)));"); | |
write("/dev/stderr", "e=simplify(((c*z+r)^2±b)/c); f=±1; W=sqrt(polcoeff(e,0));"); | |
write("/dev/stderr", "beta=-(V\\W); alpha=W*(V+W*beta);"); | |
write("/dev/stderr", "xx=alpha^2*x^2+(2*alpha*beta-f*b)*x+(beta^2-c); nfr=nfroots(,xx);"); | |
write("/dev/stderr", "\n∀X∈nfr: Y=Mod(alpha*X+beta,b);"); |
Here is a new example calculation.
f=-1 is forced for getting a t_INT constant term of e, by subtracting b in simplify() instead of adding.
Modified f value influences computation of xx:
$ m="Mod(60,5*17)" gp -q < Kunerth.gp
V=25
e=60*z^2 + 50*z + 9
f=-1
W=3
alpha=3
beta=-8
xx=[x + 4, 1; 9*x + 1, 1]
X=-4
Y=Mod(65, 85)
Y^2=Mod(60, 85)
X=-1/9
Y=Mod(20, 85)
Y^2=Mod(60, 85)
all asserts OK
b=m.mod; c=lift(m); V=r=lift("sqrt"(Mod(-b,c)));
e=simplify(((c*z+r)^2±b)/c); f=±1; W=sqrt(polcoeff(e,0));
beta=-(V\W); alpha=W*(V+W*beta);
xx=factor(alpha^2*x^2+(2*alpha*beta-f*b)*x+(beta^2-c));
i∈{1,2}: X=-polcoeff(xx[i,1],0])/polcoeff(xx[i,1],1); Y=Mod(alpha*X+beta,b);
$
Constant term of e was square 9, 5*17-60=25 was square as well.
Here is another square difference resulting in square constant of e and results:
$ m="Mod(13*17-7^2,13*17)" gp -q < Kunerth.gp 2>/dev/null
V=93
e=172*z^2 + 186*z + 49
f=-1
W=7
alpha=14
beta=-13
xx=[4*x - 3, 1; 49*x + 1, 1]
X=3/4
Y=Mod(108, 221)
Y^2=Mod(172, 221)
X=-1/49
Y=Mod(113, 221)
Y^2=Mod(172, 221)
all asserts OK
$
Bill Allombert made me aware that I can use nfroots(,P) to find the rational roots of P.
That simplified my code to determine the roots "by hand" significantly.
Diff for revisions 5 and 6 shows the changes, "nfroots()" made "factor()" call for xx unnecessary, and simplified code with foreach().
New variable nfr containing results of nfroots() call is printed as well:
$ m="Mod(60,85)" gp -q < Kunerth.gp
V=25
e=60*z^2 + 50*z + 9
f=-1
W=3
alpha=3
beta=-8
xx=9*x^2 + 37*x + 4
nfr=[-4, -1/9]~
X=-4
Y=Mod(65, 85)
Y^2=Mod(60, 85)
X=-1/9
Y=Mod(20, 85)
Y^2=Mod(60, 85)
all asserts OK
b=m.mod; c=lift(m); V=r=lift("sqrt"(Mod(-b,c)));
e=simplify(((c*z+r)^2±b)/c); f=±1; W=sqrt(polcoeff(e,0));
beta=-(V\W); alpha=W*(V+W*beta);
xx=alpha^2*x^2+(2*alpha*beta-f*b)*x+(beta^2-c); nfr=nfroots(,xx);
∀X∈nfr: Y=Mod(alpha*X+beta,b);
$
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Kunerth's algorithm is described here:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunerth%27s_algorithm
1$ ebook "Adolf Kunerth’s Modular Square Root Algorithm Explained: with examples in Mathematica":
https://www.amazon.com/Kunerths-Modular-Square-Algorithm-Explained-ebook/dp/B09K3TCQR1/ref=sr_1_1
German language pages 327-346 from 1878 in this comment:
https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/95443/how-to-compute-modular-square-roots-when-modulus-is-non-prime#comment9832085_252186
Adolf Kunerth, "Sitzungsberichte. Academie Der Wissenschaften" vol 78(2), 1878,
Kunerth.gp was created by porting Mathematica code fragments from the ebook to PARI/GP:
https://pari.math.u-bordeaux.fr/archives/pari-users-2311/msg00057.html
Example 2 from ebook (examples 3 and 4 from ebook in above posting).
The modulus 3872 is non-prime and does not get factored in calculating sqrt(353) (mod 3872).
Kunerth.gp is not a general modular square root determination algorithm.
Explanations after "all asserts OK" are sent to stderr; if you don't want them, append " 2>/dev/null".