SkatingScores/ijs_scoring_errors.csv

## ijs_scoring_errors.csv

          
            Season
            Event
            Discipline
            Segment
            Nat
            Skater/Team
            Fixed
            Type
            Item
            Expected Value
            Awarded Value
            Description
            URL
            Tweet

            
              2004-05
              GPFRA
              Ladies
              FS
              🇮🇹
              Valentina Marchei
              No
              GOE Total
              2Lo
              0.00
              0.10
              The high mark (1) was not dropped?
              https://skatingscores.com/2005/gpfra/ladies/long/ita_valentina_marchei/element/14

            
              2004-05
              EC
              Pairs
              SP
              🇺🇦
              Tatiana VOLOSOZHAR/Stanislav MOROZOV
              No
              GOE Total
              SpSt2
              0.00
              0.07
              The high mark (1) was not dropped?
              https://skatingscores.com/0405/ec/pairs/short/ukr_tatiana_volosozhar_stanislav_morozov/element/7

            
              2004-05
              EC
              Pairs
              SP
              🇫🇷
              Marylin PLA/Yannick BONHEUR
              No
              GOE Total
              3T
              -2.00
              -2.14
              The low mark (-3) was not dropped?
              https://skatingscores.com/2005/ec/pairs/short/fra_marylin_pla_yannick_bonheur/element/1

            
              2007-08
              JGPEST
              ALL
              ALL
              
              ALL
              No
              PCS/GOE Total
              
              
              
              No High and Low marks were dropped across the entire event
              https://skatingscores.com/2008/jgpest/

            
              2012-13
              JGPCRO
              Dance
              SD
              🇨🇦
              Melinda Meng/Andrew Meng
              No
              GOE Total
              2BL4+kpYYY
              0.07
              0.14
              Either the High GOE Mark was not dropped or +1 GOE was erroneously awarded 1.0 instead of 0.5. Unclear which. Odd that other elements in segment scored correctly.
              https://skatingscores.com/1213/jgpcro/short/can_melinda_meng_andrew_meng/element/1
              https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1265092798140887041

            
              2012-13
              JGPTUR
              Dance
              SD
              🇹🇷
              Cagla Demirsal/Berk Akalin
              No
              GOE Total
              2BL4+kpYYY
              -0.07
              0.07
              A negative GOE mark was erroneously calculated as a positive GOE mark.
              https://skatingscores.com/1213/jgptur/short/tur_cagla_demirsal_berk_akalin/element/4
              https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1272938600032866306

            
              2012-13
              CSLAT
              Ladies
              FS
              🇹🇼
              Crystal Kiang
              No
              GOE Total
              3S<<+2Lo<
              -0.90
              -0.60
              GOE was determinded by the 3S<< instead of the 2Lo<
              https://skatingscores.com/2013/cslat/ladies/long/tpe_crystal_kiang/element/7

            
              2012-13
              INTFRA
              Ladies
              FS
              🇭🇺
              Chelea Rose Chiappa
              No
              GOE Total
              3S<<+2Lo<
              -0.84
              -0.56
              GOE was determinded by the 3S<< instead of the 2Lo<
              https://skatingscores.com/2013/intfra/ladies/short/hun_chelea_rose_chiappa/element/4

            
              2017-18
              GPJPN
              Pairs
              FS
              🇯🇵
              Sumire Suto/Francis Boudreauaudet
              No
              Base Value
              5ALi4
              7.50
              8.50
              Element erroneously given 2nd-half 1/10th bonus in a season where bonus points were not awarded for Pairs elements. Odd that other elements in segment scored correctly.
              https://skatingscores.com/1718/gpjpn/long/jpn_sumire_suto_francis_boudreauaudet/element/9
              https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1154177099403579394

            
              2018-19
              JGPSVK
              Dance
              RD
              
              ALL
              Yes
              GOE Total
              1AT & 2AT
              
              
              GOE awarded to every 1AT & 2AT Pattern Dance element in the Rhythm Dance. Apparently fixed 3 weeks later (not clear if it was because I reported it). Revised Protocols were published by ISU.
              https://skatingscores.com/1819/jgpsvk/dance/short/
              https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1036718159745740802

            
              2018-19
              BOSCUP
              Dance
              FD
              
              ALL
              NO
              PCS Total
              
              
              
              All FD PCS Totals are wrong. Looks like they printed the PCS total for Team 1 on the protocol for Team 2. Team 2's on Team 3's protocol. etc. Off by one.
              https://skatingscores.com/1819/boscup/dance/long/

            
              2018-19
              WJC
              Men
              FS
              🇰🇷
              Younghyun Cha
              Yes
              Base Value
              3Lz+2A+SEQ
              7.36
              9.20
              0.8 factor erroneously not applied to +SEQ jump's notated BV. Strangely the Element's Total Score was nevertheless correctly awarded. Fixed after I brought it to the ISU's attention.
              https://skatingscores.com/1819/wjc/long/kor_younghyun_cha/element/7
              https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1104135342402256896

            
              2018-19
              WJC
              Men
              FS
              🇮🇹
              Gabriele Frangipani
              Yes
              Base Value
              1A+1Eu+SEQ+2S*
              1.41
              1.76
              Same as above. 0.8 factor erroneously not applied to +SEQ jump's notated BV. Strangely the Element's Total Score was nevertheless correctly awarded. Fixed after I brought it to the ISU's attention.
              https://skatingscores.com/1819/wjc/long/ita_gabriele_frangipani/element/7
              https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1104135342402256896

            
              2019-20
              GPUSA
              Dance
              RD
              
              ALL
              Yes
              GOE Total
              PStL+PStM
              
              
              GOE erroneously only awarded for one half of all Partial Step elements performed by all teams in the Rhythm Dance. Fixed after I immediately brought it to the ISU's attention. ISU published revised Protocols.
              https://skatingscores.com/1920/gpusa/dance/short/
              https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1185412494526951424

            
              2019-20
              NATJPN
              Men
              FS
              🇯🇵
              Daisuke Takahashi
              No
              Base Value
              3F<+REP x
              3.26
              3.27
              It appears the JSF is applying the `Bonus` & `+REP` factors in the wrong order.
              https://skatingscores.com/1920/natjpn/men/long/
              https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1283542812781420546

            
              2020-21
              GPJPN
              Ladies
              FS
              🇯🇵
              Marin Honda
              No
              Base Value
              2A<+1Eu*+2S*+REP x
              2.03
              2.04
              It appears the JSF is applying the `Bonus` & `+REP` factors in the wrong order.
              https://skatingscores.com/2021/natjpn/ladies/long/
              https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1332696404981133312
Season	Event	Discipline	Segment	Nat	Skater/Team	Fixed	Type	Item	Expected Value	Awarded Value	Description	URL	Tweet
2004-05	GPFRA	Ladies	FS	🇮🇹	Valentina Marchei	No	GOE Total	2Lo	0.00	0.10	The high mark (1) was not dropped?	https://skatingscores.com/2005/gpfra/ladies/long/ita_valentina_marchei/element/14
2004-05	EC	Pairs	SP	🇺🇦	Tatiana VOLOSOZHAR/Stanislav MOROZOV	No	GOE Total	SpSt2	0.00	0.07	The high mark (1) was not dropped?	https://skatingscores.com/0405/ec/pairs/short/ukr_tatiana_volosozhar_stanislav_morozov/element/7
2004-05	EC	Pairs	SP	🇫🇷	Marylin PLA/Yannick BONHEUR	No	GOE Total	3T	-2.00	-2.14	The low mark (-3) was not dropped?	https://skatingscores.com/2005/ec/pairs/short/fra_marylin_pla_yannick_bonheur/element/1
2007-08	JGPEST	ALL	ALL		ALL	No	PCS/GOE Total				No High and Low marks were dropped across the entire event	https://skatingscores.com/2008/jgpest/
2012-13	JGPCRO	Dance	SD	🇨🇦	Melinda Meng/Andrew Meng	No	GOE Total	2BL4+kpYYY	0.07	0.14	Either the High GOE Mark was not dropped or +1 GOE was erroneously awarded 1.0 instead of 0.5. Unclear which. Odd that other elements in segment scored correctly.	https://skatingscores.com/1213/jgpcro/short/can_melinda_meng_andrew_meng/element/1	https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1265092798140887041
2012-13	JGPTUR	Dance	SD	🇹🇷	Cagla Demirsal/Berk Akalin	No	GOE Total	2BL4+kpYYY	-0.07	0.07	A negative GOE mark was erroneously calculated as a positive GOE mark.	https://skatingscores.com/1213/jgptur/short/tur_cagla_demirsal_berk_akalin/element/4	https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1272938600032866306
2012-13	CSLAT	Ladies	FS	🇹🇼	Crystal Kiang	No	GOE Total	3S<<+2Lo<	-0.90	-0.60	GOE was determinded by the 3S<< instead of the 2Lo<	https://skatingscores.com/2013/cslat/ladies/long/tpe_crystal_kiang/element/7
2012-13	INTFRA	Ladies	FS	🇭🇺	Chelea Rose Chiappa	No	GOE Total	3S<<+2Lo<	-0.84	-0.56	GOE was determinded by the 3S<< instead of the 2Lo<	https://skatingscores.com/2013/intfra/ladies/short/hun_chelea_rose_chiappa/element/4
2017-18	GPJPN	Pairs	FS	🇯🇵	Sumire Suto/Francis Boudreauaudet	No	Base Value	5ALi4	7.50	8.50	Element erroneously given 2nd-half 1/10th bonus in a season where bonus points were not awarded for Pairs elements. Odd that other elements in segment scored correctly.	https://skatingscores.com/1718/gpjpn/long/jpn_sumire_suto_francis_boudreauaudet/element/9	https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1154177099403579394
2018-19	JGPSVK	Dance	RD		ALL	Yes	GOE Total	1AT & 2AT			GOE awarded to every 1AT & 2AT Pattern Dance element in the Rhythm Dance. Apparently fixed 3 weeks later (not clear if it was because I reported it). Revised Protocols were published by ISU.	https://skatingscores.com/1819/jgpsvk/dance/short/	https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1036718159745740802
2018-19	BOSCUP	Dance	FD		ALL	NO	PCS Total				All FD PCS Totals are wrong. Looks like they printed the PCS total for Team 1 on the protocol for Team 2. Team 2's on Team 3's protocol. etc. Off by one.	https://skatingscores.com/1819/boscup/dance/long/
2018-19	WJC	Men	FS	🇰🇷	Younghyun Cha	Yes	Base Value	3Lz+2A+SEQ	7.36	9.20	0.8 factor erroneously not applied to +SEQ jump's notated BV. Strangely the Element's Total Score was nevertheless correctly awarded. Fixed after I brought it to the ISU's attention.	https://skatingscores.com/1819/wjc/long/kor_younghyun_cha/element/7	https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1104135342402256896
2018-19	WJC	Men	FS	🇮🇹	Gabriele Frangipani	Yes	Base Value	1A+1Eu+SEQ+2S*	1.41	1.76	Same as above. 0.8 factor erroneously not applied to +SEQ jump's notated BV. Strangely the Element's Total Score was nevertheless correctly awarded. Fixed after I brought it to the ISU's attention.	https://skatingscores.com/1819/wjc/long/ita_gabriele_frangipani/element/7	https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1104135342402256896
2019-20	GPUSA	Dance	RD		ALL	Yes	GOE Total	PStL+PStM			GOE erroneously only awarded for one half of all Partial Step elements performed by all teams in the Rhythm Dance. Fixed after I immediately brought it to the ISU's attention. ISU published revised Protocols.	https://skatingscores.com/1920/gpusa/dance/short/	https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1185412494526951424
2019-20	NATJPN	Men	FS	🇯🇵	Daisuke Takahashi	No	Base Value	3F<+REP x	3.26	3.27	It appears the JSF is applying the `Bonus` & `+REP` factors in the wrong order.	https://skatingscores.com/1920/natjpn/men/long/	https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1283542812781420546
2020-21	GPJPN	Ladies	FS	🇯🇵	Marin Honda	No	Base Value	2A<+1Eu+2S+REP x	2.03	2.04	It appears the JSF is applying the `Bonus` & `+REP` factors in the wrong order.	https://skatingscores.com/2021/natjpn/ladies/long/	https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1332696404981133312