Since 1979, there had been a wine shop in the basement of the 311 East Market Street apartment building in downtown Charlottesville, Virginia. When Siân Richards and Thadd McQuade purchased the store in 2018, the two were already fixtures of the iconic wine shop. McQuade started working there in 1990 and Richards in 2006. Aside from a slight name change, cleaning, and rearranging the shelves, the new owners kept Market Street Wine pretty much the same as it had been for the previous 39 years.
The next four exciting years brought a multitude of new directions: By the summer of 2022, the owners saw the tastes of wine store customers, the ways they purchased wine, the price points for both wine drinkers and producers, and supply chains shifting. For instance, natural wines had become more popular, as had rosé and sparkling wines. The COVID-19 pandemic had impacted purchasing behavior as well as supply. As Richards thought about these factors, she wondered if there were alternatives and new options they should explore. What would customers be open to trying? Should they be “extending” their wine aisle?
- The importance of maintaining a business's legacy while implementing minor updates for freshness and efficiency.
- People are purchasing differently and the Supply chains have shifted
The beloved basement shop on the corner fit with the building’s character dating back to the early 1900s. The wood door with the weighted bell, hundreds of wine labels adorning walls, well-worn wood floors, and rustic shelves made it feel like you were walking into a cellar from the past. Perhaps since opening, all were invited to Friday night tastings renown for fun and interesting wines. In addition to wine, the store sold craft beer and a small selection of food items such as cheese and charcuterie, many local, to pair with libation choices. As Charlottesville’s oldest wine store, it was a destination for tourists, townies, and gownies. With minimal marketing advertisements on the local radio station WNIA and a limited online presence (web and some social media such as Facebook), word of mouth was likely the shop’s most prevalent source of new customers.
- The store's atmosphere and product selection contributed significantly to its identity and appeal.
- Leveraging local products and minimal marketing to maintain a strong, loyal customer base.
Customers could make purchases from Market Street Wine through instore shopping, events, online ordering for pickup or delivery, and subscriptions. Subscribers had the store choose the wines, which could then be picked up or delivered; some subscribers even provided planned meal menus, and the store selected good wine pairings. “We had at least one customer who has been with the store for decades who said ‘I don’t know why I’ve been choosing my wine,’” Richard said. “‘It’s so much better now that I’m letting you guys pick it.’”
- Diversifying sales channels to include in-store, online, and subscription services.
- Offering personalized services such as wine selection for meals enhances customer satisfaction and loyalty.
Naturally, there was an uptick in pickup, delivery, and subscription services when the store was forced to close during the pandemic, and it became more of a warehouse.
The customer base at Market Street Wine had evolved since Richards and McQuade took over in 2018: There were the traditional Burgundy and Bordeaux lovers, the people who looked for an experience with a classic region, and those who wanted a relationship with small producers or were curious about organic wines. The bulk of the shop’s customers had generally been an age group between mid-40s to 50s but had shifted to the 30s and 40s age groups. Their variation in wine knowledge fell into three groups. First, those who were already wine knowledgeable and enthusiasts. “They might collect products because of the producer and fancy or obscure wines,” Richards said. Second, customers who were curious and not necessarily widely informed. “They don’t seem to collect information around buying wine because it’s the famous Bordeaux region or first growth,” Richards said. “They want to hear the story behind the wine they are buying—they like to hear that when the person who first bought the property painted the door red.” And third, those who tended to come into the shop to grab something and may have an interest in a line but not necessarily people who were collecting from specific producers. “They like wine, have less preconceived ideas about it, and have a willingness or desire to try something.” To satisfy the varied clientele, the owners described Market Street Wine on the store’s website as follows:
We sell the best of what is local as well as exceptional products from around the world. We draw heavily from small producers, quality craft breweries, natural and organic vineyards, and wineries of established excellence. We are experienced in tracking down the off-beat and the hard-to-find, and we particularly love finding products with unique stories. Whether you are looking for a natural wine from a small producer, the perfect beer for a meal with friends, or to add to your private wine-library, we have what you need.
- The pandemic accelerated the shift towards pickup, delivery, and subscription services.
- The customer demographic has shifted to a younger age group, indicating changing preferences and opportunities for market expansion.
- Emphasizing a diverse and carefully curated selection appeals to a broad range of customers.
- Highlighting the story behind products can enhance customer engagement and loyalty.
Since prohibition ended in 1933, Virginia regulations made mandatory the use of wholesale distributors to purchase wine for retail. Manufacturers and wholesalers were not allowed to sell directly to consumers. The three-tier system separated manufacturers (distillers, brewers, and vintners), wholesalers (distributors), and retailers each requiring a Virginia ABC-issued license to operate. Retailers had to purchase through licensed distributors. Small Virginia-based wineries were allowed to distribute 3,000 cases annually to stores and restaurants through the state of Virginia’s agriculture department. The revenue from Virginia’s state-controlled sales and taxes reached $616.4 million in 2021. Richards explained the purchasing:
If we want to do business with a certain winery or importer and represent their whole book in this state, they have to apply for the rights to all of those lines in the state. There are certain restrictions around labeling. Once they get the rights to operate in Virginia, they open their warehouse and send their reps out to sell wines to the endpoint which would be restaurants and retailers.
A lot of our reps come weekly with a selection of wines, sometimes bringing along a representative or the winemaker from a winery. We taste the wine and make sure it represents good value. If we can’t taste it—because distributors may only be allocated three bottles or something—and we feel the rep is really consistent and tells us they have tased it and it was great, we will buy it.
We like to have the mix we want for the store right now and then things will shift—this also is the collective unconscious I guess so you’ll go through phases, where you have the price mix you want, make sure that there’s roughly this percentage of the store represented by $20 or less, so that it feels like an accessible place for people to shop. We want to make sure we have some nicer stuff, so things will shift over the weeks and months, and then you start to realize that maybe Spain is a little low on white wines, and we only have one over the price of $30 on the shelf. So now, I need to pay attention and might even say to the reps, “Hey, this is what we’re looking for right now.” Or if in California I’m missing the $50 wines so [I’ll] tell the rep we are looking for something from the USA for this price point.
- Understanding and working within state regulations and the three-tier system is crucial for stocking shelves and offering a diverse selection.
- Regular interactions with representatives and winemakers enhance the ability to source wines that represent good value, even when direct tasting is not possible.
- Continuously adjusting the inventory mix based on customer preferences, price points, and geographic diversity ensures the store remains relevant and accessible to a wide customer base.
- Proactively communicating needs and gaps to distributors allows for more targeted and efficient restocking efforts.
Wine trends came and went, and the art or science of riding the top or hitting the bottom of the wave was something Richards and McQuade knew not to predict or at least do with great care and a healthy dose of skepticism. When Richards first started working at Market Street Wine, selections with high alcohol levels were particularly favored over those with less. Then a movement, especially within California, called “In Pursuit of Balance” pushed American consumers to consider lower alcohol levels—lighter wines which meant picking grapes earlier than for more heartier wines. While rosé wines were once less desired, they recently had a sharp increase in popularity, especially those from Provence, France. Wine drinkers in the United States tended to favor rosés based on color and preferred for the wine to be more of the Provençal style no matter where it was from. Wine sales of rosé grew 118% in five years (to compare, still wine grew at 1.5% during the same time period). That interest came to a quick stop in 2021 when a widely respected industry report shared there was a −0.30 % growth rate; some experts attributed this sudden decline to a maturing market and suggested focusing on a few high-quality labels so as not to muddy the water with too many options. While cold-climate markets saw a seasonality to rosé sales, in warmer climates rosé was sold all through the year. “We’ve been seeing a lot of rosé,” said Will Curley of another popular Charlottesville store, the Wine Guild, in late spring 2022.
Another shift among wine popularity Richards saw was that Bordeaux enthusiasts were reaching toward “Burgundy, Barolo, Champagne, Brunello, Rhône, and California,” which would never have been considered years earlier. As the Financial Times’ wine correspondent wrote: “While I’ve been tasting samples of the embryonic 2020s, drawn from casks all over Bordeaux, my inbox has been littered with emails from their producers explaining how they have completely revolutionised their approaches.” There was also a trend to blur stylistic categories between wine types that was predicted to continue in 2022.
Another shift saw a leaning toward sustainably produced wines among some age groups of wine drinkers in the United States. Yet as Richards pointed out, the terminology of what sustainable meant presented some difficulty. As one industry insider said, “How can you preach sustainability and environmental protection, and not preach local?” Richards noted, “There’re certainly a lot of people that if we have information about that, and some story to tell about most of the lines, they’ll definitely consider that a huge bonus.” This pattern also lent itself to an interest in natural wines. Whether due to health-related allergies or the desire to opt for natural ingredients in food and beverages, there was a growing market for natural wines. “The natural line became a huge trend, slightly ahead of organic wines and sparkling wines,” Richards said. Curley concurred: natural wines were having their moment. Millennials all over the United States were turning organic, sustainable, biodynamic, and natural into more than statistically insignificant buzzwords, persistently asking for such wines to make sure they spent their money where it counted. But according to Curley, even the natural category was vague: Were these wines lower on sulfates, did they use indigenous yeast, or was it something else?
And then the COVID-19 global pandemic quickly became the most unpredictable trend maker of all. For example, celebrants were used to toasting special occasions with Champagne. Many hoped that the supply chain issues involved in importing the French-produced sparkling wine would be short lived, but disappointment came when industry insiders predicted the shortages would continue for several years. During the initial stages of its limited supply, some in the industry saw purchases of US-produced prosecco and sparkling wine increase as substitutes. In addition, sparkling wines were becoming less of a holiday specialty and more of an everyday staple in the United States. The value-driven options—American sparkling wines among them—were becoming more popular during the pandemic, bringing new energy to the domestic production. Consequently, the sparkling wine category grew 13% among US drinkers in 2020.
As the supply chain disruption continued, opportunities opened for wines from lesser-known regions than the traditional European and Californian to fill the gap. Among them were not only the rather well-known Washington, Oregon, and New York, one of the biggest success stories in domestic wine over the last decade, particularly Finger Lakes. Interest in more local food and drinks saw curiosity about wines from Idaho, Colorado, Ohio, and Virginia as well. While the pandemic opened more doors for local wines, many Charlottesville wine consumers still preferred Old World options as they perceived them as better value. “They’re very high ‘wine IQ’ drinkers and they’re less willing to spend on an expensive Californian wine than on an Italian or French one,” said Curley. “There is a certain stigma about Californian wines.”
- Recognizing and adapting to shifts in consumer preferences, such as the rise and fall of rosé popularity, is crucial for maintaining relevance.
- Sustainability and natural wine trends reflect a growing consumer desire for products that align with their values.
- The COVID-19 pandemic underscored the importance of flexibility and the ability to pivot in response to supply chain challenges.
- There is an opportunity to introduce consumers to wines from emerging regions, which can also serve as a differentiator in a competitive market.
Apart from the impact of the pandemic on supply chains, the method of purchasing wines changed. “We started using our e-commerce platform,” Richards said. “We didn’t before.” The pandemic service model changed from retail brick and mortar to more “warehouse” stocking of shelves and floor space. “Storage space was less of an issue,” Richards said. “We were able to take advantage of volume discounts with larger drops.” Wine industry experts warned, however, that retailers needed to become creative in order to retain any clientele they acquired during the pandemic’s online-only shopping.
- The shift to e-commerce and a more warehouse-oriented model opened new avenues for volume discounts and inventory management.
- Creativity and innovation in online retail are essential for retaining customers acquired through digital channels during the pandemic.
The digital engagement opened the door to collecting more data around customer behavior and customization of offerings. Millennials were buying more wine than any other age cohort in the United States, but they were not interested in grand pronouncements or deep ruminations. “They aren’t reading Robert Parker, that’s for sure,” one wine marketer explained. “People in general are spending more time looking at influencers on Instagram, and the brands we work with get more traction in partnerships with social media personalities and through more personalized outreach.” “There are always Instagram darlings you know someone will want,” Richards said.
- Leveraging digital engagement and social media can provide valuable insights into customer preferences and behaviors.
- Collaborations with influencers and personalized marketing strategies are effective in reaching and engaging the millennial demographic.
The last four years had indeed been a whirlwind. There was renewed activity around sustainability and natural wines. Attention to varieties of grape mixes in both white and red wines was on the rise. The varying interest in rosé wines seemed to be rekindled. Changes to the supply chain impacted wine availability globally and prices were going up; however, during the COVID-19 pandemic, consumers had an interest in lower-priced wines.
- The importance of staying agile and responsive to rapidly changing market conditions and consumer preferences.
- Sustainability, natural wines, and affordability are key factors influencing consumer choices.
Millennials seemed to be the driving force behind some of these trends across the United States. They ordered more adventurously, interested in unusual sparkling wines and wine blends. They ushered the rosé renaissance. They were more interested in learning about the farming practices of the wine growers than previous generations because they also wanted authenticity in their wines—a connection, a story. The difficult mix of combining authenticity and novelty was what seemed to be the recipe for success with this customer group.
- Millennials' adventurous tastes and desire for authenticity and storytelling in wine selection highlight the need for businesses to adapt their product offerings and marketing strategies.
- Engaging storytelling and transparency about sourcing and production practices can attract and retain millennial customers.
With classic wines such as the traditional French and Italian labels being more difficult to obtain, what alternatives might consumers be open to trying? Were there wine-producing regions more easily available in the United States that wine drinkers might be interested in? Could Richards find good ones that hit the popular price point of under $20? Did they need to think about additional strategies to entice millennials? What other wine trends would it be beneficial to consider?
- Exploring and promoting wines from emerging regions can meet consumer demand and circumvent supply chain issues.
- Pricing strategies and value propositions are crucial in attracting price-sensitive consumers, including millennials.
- Continuous innovation and exploration of new trends are essential for staying competitive and appealing to a diverse customer base.
| Aspect | Specific Actions |
|---|---|
| Legacy Preservation | Maintained the historical ambiance of a wine cellar, keeping the store's character while updating for modern efficiency without losing its essence. |
| Diverse Sales Channels | Implemented a multi-channel sales strategy including in-store, online, delivery, and subscription services tailored to customers' preferences and meals. |
| Product Selection | Focused on a curated selection emphasizing local products, small producers, and natural wines, ensuring variety and uniqueness in offerings. |
| Customer Engagement | Utilized word of mouth effectively, supported by targeted marketing on local radio and social media platforms like Facebook to maintain customer loyalty. |
| Adaptability to Pandemic | Swiftly adapted to COVID-19 restrictions by enhancing e-commerce capabilities and shifting towards a more warehouse-oriented model for pickups and deliveries. |
| Responsiveness to Trends | Actively adjusted inventory based on changing consumer trends such as the rise in natural wines and shifting preferences in wine types (e.g., rosé). |
| Aspect | Specific Actions |
|---|---|
| Limited Online Presence | Relied heavily on traditional word of mouth and minimal social media engagement, potentially missing broader customer outreach and engagement opportunities. |
| Delayed E-commerce Adoption | Only started using the e-commerce platform in response to the pandemic, indicating a reactive rather than proactive approach to online sales. |
| Narrow Marketing Efforts | Limited marketing efforts primarily to local radio and some social media, potentially underutilizing digital marketing channels that could reach wider demographics. |
| Insufficient Data Utilization | Prior to the pandemic, there seemed to be a lack of emphasis on collecting and analyzing customer data for better personalization and targeting. |
| Slow Response to Millennial Preferences | While eventually recognizing the importance of millennial customers, initial strategies may not have been sufficiently focused on attracting this influential demographic early on. |
| Date/Timeframe | Relevant Numbers |
|---|---|
| Purchased in 2018 | - |
| Summer of 2022 | Noted shift in consumer preferences and supply chains |
| Since Opening (Early 1900s Building) | - |
| COVID-19 Pandemic (Starts Early 2020) | Increase in pickup, delivery, and subscription services |
| 1933 | End of Prohibition in Virginia |
| Allowed Annual Distribution | Small VA wineries can distribute 3,000 cases annually within the state |
| 2021 | Virginia’s state-controlled sales and taxes reached $616.4 million |
| Wine Sales of Rosé Growth (5 Years to 2021) | 118% growth compared to still wine at 1.5% |
| Decline in Rosé Growth Rate (2021) | −0.30 % |
| Sparkling Wine Category Growth (2020) | 13% among US drinkers |
| Age Group Shift | From mid-40s to 50s to 30s and 40s age groups since taking over in 2018 |
-
Adaptability to Market Changes and Consumer Preferences: The swift adaptation of Market Street Wine to the COVID-19 pandemic by enhancing its e-commerce platform showcases the importance of being flexible in response to external changes. Adapting inventory based on evolving consumer trends, such as the increased interest in natural wines and sparkling wines, is crucial for staying relevant ("The natural line became a huge trend...").
-
Deep Understanding of Customer Base: Recognizing the shift in their customer demographics and preferences enabled Market Street Wine to tailor their product offerings and services more effectively. Offering personalized services like selecting wines for specific meals significantly enhanced customer satisfaction and loyalty ("We had at least one customer who has been with the store for decades...").
-
Effective Use of Technology and Data-Driven Insights: Embracing technology for sales, inventory management, and marketing can extend reach and improve operational efficiency. The pandemic highlighted the value of leveraging digital platforms for data collection and analysis, enabling more personalized marketing strategies ("The digital engagement opened the door...").
-
Building Strong Relationships with Suppliers: Navigating Virginia's three-tier system required cultivating strong relationships with distributors to ensure a diverse and appealing product selection. This demonstrates how strategic supplier relationships can provide stability and flexibility in inventory management.
-
Investing in Staff Knowledge and Engagement: The expertise of the owners, gained from years of experience at Market Street Wine before purchasing it, played a crucial role in maintaining its reputation and cultivating a loyal customer base. Their deep knowledge allowed them to curate a selection that appealed to various customer preferences, illustrating the value of knowledgeable and passionate staff.
-
Leveraging Storytelling in Product Selection and Marketing: Customers increasingly seek authenticity and connection with the products they buy; sharing stories behind products can significantly boost engagement ("They want to hear the story behind the wine..."). This approach catered to customers' desire for authenticity.
-
Engagement with Local Community and Emphasis on Local Products: Supporting local producers not only contributed to sustainability efforts but also resonated well with customers interested in supporting local businesses. This helped maintain a strong, loyal customer base with minimal marketing efforts outside traditional word-of-mouth.
-
Navigating Regulatory Environments Efficiently: Understanding state regulations was vital for stocking shelves while offering a diverse selection within legal constraints, demonstrating the importance of regulatory compliance in business operations.