Abstracting logic from controllers using managers

BadController.php

<?php
class BadController
{
	public function update($brand)
	{
		$rules = array(
			'title' => 'required|min:3'
		);

		$validator = Validator::make(Input::all(), $rules);

		if ($validator->passes()) {
			$brand->title            = Input::get('title');
			$brand->meta_title       = Input::get('meta-title');
			$brand->meta_description = Input::get('meta-description');
			$brand->meta_keywords    = Input::get('meta-keywords');
			$brand->logo             = Input::file('logo');
			$brand->checked          = Input::get('checked');
			$brand->body             = Input::get('body');

			if ($brand->save()) {
				$areas = Input::get('areas');

				if (is_array($areas)) {
					$brand->areas()->sync($areas);
				}

				return Redirect::to('admin/brands')
					->with('success', Lang::get('admin/brands/messages.update.success'));
			}

			return Redirect::to('admin/brands/' . $brand->id . '/edit')
				->with('error', Lang::get('admin/brands/messages.update.error'));
		}

		return Redirect::to('admin/brands/' . $brand->id . '/edit')
			->withInput()->withErrors($validator);
	}
}

GoodController.php

<?php
class GoodController
{
	protected $brandManager;

	public function __construct(BrandManager $brandManager)
	{
		$this->brandManager = $brandManager;
	}

	public function update(BrandModel $brand)
	{
		if (!$this->brandManager->update($brand, Input::all())) {
			return Redirect::to('admin/brands/' . $brand->id . '/edit')
				->withInput()->withErrors($this->brandManager->getErrors());
		}

		return Redirect::to('admin/brands')
			->with('success', Lang::get('admin/brands/messages.update.success'));
	}
}

class BrandManager
{
	public function update(BrandModel $brand, array $data)
	{
		$rules = array(
			'title' => 'required|min:3'
		);

		$validator = Validator::make($data, $rules);

		if (!$validator->passes()) {
			$this->errors = $validator;
			return false;
		}

		$brand->title            = array_get($data, 'title');
		$brand->meta_title       = array_get($data, 'meta-title');
		$brand->meta_description = array_get($data, 'meta-description');
		$brand->meta_keywords    = array_get($data, 'meta-keywords');
		$brand->logo             = array_get($data, 'logo');
		$brand->checked          = array_get($data, 'checked');
		$brand->body             = array_get($data, 'body');

		$brand->save();

		if (isset($data['areas']) && is_array($data['areas'])) {
			$brand->areas()->sync($data['areas']);
		}

		return true;
	}

	public function getErrors()
	{
		return $this->errors;
	}
}