presenter_extension.php

<?php

use Nette\Application\UI\Presenter;
use Nette\DI\CompilerExtension;



/**
 * Auto register presenters as services
 * @author Martin Bažík <martin@bazo.sk>
 */
class PresenterExtension extends CompilerExtension
{

	private $defaults = [
		'robotLoaderVarName' => 'robotLoader'
	];


	public function loadConfiguration()
	{
		$config = $this->getConfig($this->defaults);
		$builder = $this->getContainerBuilder();

		$robotLoaderVarName = $config['robotLoaderVarName'];
		global $$robotLoaderVarName;

		$classes = $$robotLoaderVarName->getIndexedClasses();
		foreach ($classes as $class => $file) {
			$r = new ReflectionClass($class);
			if (!$r->isAbstract() and $r->isSubclassOf(Presenter::class)) {
				$defName = str_replace('\\', '_', $r->getName());
				$builder
						->addDefinition($defName)
						->setClass($class)
						->setAutowired(FALSE)
				;
			}
		}
	}


}

Fuck, in 2.1 (which I'm using on damejidlo), this line is in the else condition branch.

The whole point of this is to not have dynamic injects, but have them compiled in the container. So I guess that in 2.2, the PresenterFactory must be hacked.

@bazo looks promising nette/application@a0333bd

@bazo Just pushing the boundaries :) Thanks for starting discussion with some specific code.

The component issue can be also solved via own BaseControl with empty __construct.

Thanks @fprochazka for extension, gonna test it soon.

@TomasVotruba in 2.2, there is addExcludedClasses http://phpfashion.com/pet-duvodu-upgradovat-na-nette-2-2-3

Thanks both. With addExcludedClasses and setAutowired(FALSE) everything seems to work fine.

I've got more time for testing now and had problem:

1. with inject as you wrote Filip
2. and autowired property in trait. Had to made it public to make it work.

I really don't understand the output of your discussion with David. Could you sum up pls?