Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@dylansalim3
Created June 3, 2024 14:45
Show Gist options
  • Save dylansalim3/074f444175b7df2a3e54113c6798230d to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save dylansalim3/074f444175b7df2a3e54113c6798230d to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Comparison: Apache Beam vs. Apache Flink vs. Apache Spark vs. Apache Kafka

Comparison: Apache Beam vs. Apache Flink vs. Apache Spark vs. Apache Kafka

Apache Beam

Overview

  • Unified Model: Provides a unified programming model for both batch and stream processing.
  • Portability: Enables writing pipelines in multiple languages (Java, Python, Go) and executing them on various runners (Flink, Spark, Google Cloud Dataflow, etc.).
  • APIs and SDKs: Rich APIs for creating complex data processing tasks, supporting both bounded and unbounded data.

Use Cases

  • Suitable for projects requiring flexibility in choosing the underlying execution engine.
  • Ideal for developing pipelines that can be run on different environments without changing the code.

Apache Flink

Overview

  • Stream Processing: Excels at handling high-throughput, low-latency stream processing.
  • Stateful Computations: Robust support for stateful stream processing, event time processing, and windowing.
  • Scalability and Fault Tolerance: Designed for scalable, fault-tolerant stream processing applications.

Use Cases

  • Real-time analytics and monitoring.
  • Event-driven applications and complex event processing.
  • Applications requiring advanced state management and event time processing.

Apache Spark

Overview

  • Batch and Stream Processing: Provides APIs for both batch (using RDDs and DataFrames) and stream processing (using Spark Streaming).
  • Ease of Use: High-level APIs in Java, Scala, Python, and R. It supports SQL queries, machine learning (MLlib), graph processing (GraphX), and more.
  • Unified Engine: Can process data in-memory for fast computation and supports large-scale data processing.

Use Cases

  • Batch processing of large datasets.
  • Machine learning and advanced analytics.
  • Stream processing, but generally with higher latencies compared to Flink.

Apache Kafka

Overview

  • Message Broker: Distributed event streaming platform, primarily used as a messaging system.
  • Real-time Data Pipelines: Enables building real-time data pipelines and streaming applications.
  • Durability and Scalability: Ensures data durability and can scale to handle high-throughput data streams.

Use Cases

  • Messaging and event streaming.
  • Log aggregation and real-time analytics.
  • Building data pipelines for moving data between systems.

Comparative Analysis

Processing Model

  • Apache Beam: Unified model for batch and stream processing; requires an underlying execution engine.
  • Apache Flink: Primarily focused on stream processing with strong support for batch processing as well.
  • Apache Spark: Strong in batch processing with capabilities for stream processing (Structured Streaming).
  • Apache Kafka: Primarily a messaging system, but with Kafka Streams, it can perform stream processing.

Latency and Throughput

  • Apache Beam: Depends on the chosen runner; generally more flexible than performant.
  • Apache Flink: Low latency, high throughput, optimized for stream processing.
  • Apache Spark: In-memory processing for fast batch jobs; stream processing with moderate latency.
  • Apache Kafka: High throughput, designed for real-time data ingestion and event streaming.

State Management

  • Apache Beam: Limited state management; relies on the capabilities of the runner.
  • Apache Flink: Advanced state management, ideal for complex stream processing.
  • Apache Spark: Limited state management compared to Flink, primarily focused on micro-batch processing.
  • Apache Kafka: Stateless in nature; stateful stream processing via Kafka Streams, but not as advanced as Flink.

Ecosystem and Integration

  • Apache Beam: Integrates with multiple execution engines (Flink, Spark, Dataflow).
  • Apache Flink: Integrates with various data sources and sinks; part of the broader Apache ecosystem.
  • Apache Spark: Extensive ecosystem including MLlib, GraphX, and integration with Hadoop, Hive, etc.
  • Apache Kafka: Integrates well with numerous data systems; Confluent ecosystem enhances Kafka’s capabilities.

Summary

  • Apache Beam is best for flexibility and portability across different execution engines.
  • Apache Flink is ideal for real-time, low-latency stream processing and applications needing advanced state management.
  • Apache Spark is great for large-scale batch processing, machine learning, and graph processing, with good stream processing capabilities.
  • Apache Kafka excels as a messaging system and event streaming platform, often used in conjunction with other processing engines like Flink and Spark for comprehensive data processing solutions.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment