Weight Matrix using RDF

diagram-software.ttl

@prefix wm: <http://vocab-ld.org/vocab/weighted-matrix#> .
@prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .

_:intuitive
    rdfs:label "Is the interface intuitive?" ;
    wm:importance wm:veryHighImportance ;
    a wm:Requirement .


_:isPretty
    rdfs:label "Are the diagrams pretty by default?" ;
    wm:importance wm:veryHighImportance ;
    a wm:Requirement .

_:onlineColab
    rdfs:label "Is online colab possible?" ;
    rdfs:comment "3 = chat & interactive" ;
    wm:importance wm:mediumImportance ;
    a wm:Requirement .


_:uml
    rdfs:label "Is UML natively supported?" ;
    rdfs:comment "3 = UML can be exported natively" ;
    wm:importance wm:veryLowImportance ;
    a wm:Requirement .


_:graph
    rdfs:label "Are graphs natively supported?" ;
    wm:importance wm:veryHighImportance ;
    rdfs:comment "1 = nodes can connect" ;
    a wm:Requirement .


_:flowchart
    rdfs:label "Are flowcharts natively supported?" ;
    wm:importance wm:mediumImportance ;
    a wm:Requirement .

_:sequence-diagram
    rdfs:label "Are sequence-diagram natively supported?" ;
    wm:importance wm:mediumImportance ;
    a wm:Requirement .

_:stateDiagram
    rdfs:label "Are state diagrams natively supported?" ;
    wm:importance wm:highImportance ;
    a wm:Requirement .

_:uiMock
    rdfs:label "Are UI mocks natively supported?" ;
    wm:importance wm:highImportance ;
    a wm:Requirement .

_:siteMap
    rdfs:label "Are site maps natively supported?" ;
    wm:importance wm:highImportance ;
    a wm:Requirement .


<http://drive.google.com/>
    wm:choiceScore [
        wm:req _:intuitive ;
        wm:score wm:substantiallySatisfies
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:onlineColab ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:graph ;
       wm:score wm:partlySatisfies
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:flowchart ;
       wm:score wm:substantiallySatisfies
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:sequence-diagram ;
       wm:score wm:doesNotSatisfy
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:isPretty ;
       wm:score wm:partlySatisfies
    ] ;
    a wm:Choice .


<http://www.lucidchart.com/>
    wm:choiceScore [
        wm:req _:intuitive ;
        rdfs:comment "No ellipse; Cant figure out how to connect two shapes with a line... wtf." ;
        wm:score wm:partlySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:isPretty ;
       wm:score wm:substantiallySatisfies # more than google docs
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:onlineColab ;
       wm:score wm:substantiallySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:uml ;
       wm:score wm:substantiallySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:graph ;
       rdfs:comment "I cant find a dang ellipse shape... weird..; Cant figure out how to connect two shapes with a line wtf." ;

       wm:score wm:doesNotSatisfy
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:flowchart ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:sequence-diagram ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:siteMap ;
       wm:score wm:doesNotSatisfy
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:uiMock ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:stateDiagram ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;


    a wm:Choice .


<http://www.omnigroup.com/omnigraffle/>
    rdfs:label "Omnigraffle Pro" ;
    rdfs:comment "Couldnt use it on my computer for some reason.  It kept locking up." ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:android ;
       wm:score wm:doesNotSatisfy
    ] ;


    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:intuitive ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:isPretty ;
       rdfs:comment "Line labels are nice" ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:onlineColab ;
       wm:score wm:doesNotSatisfy
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:uml ;
       wm:score wm:substantiallySatisfies
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:graph ;
       wm:score wm:partlySatisfies ;
       rdfs:comment "Graph doesnt arrange automatically but the arrows flow nicely"
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:flowchart ;
       wm:score wm:substantiallySatisfies
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:sequence-diagram ;
       wm:score wm:substantiallySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:siteMap ;
       wm:score wm:doesNotSatisfy
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:uiMock ;
       rdfs:comment "Konigi Wireframes?" ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:stateDiagram ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;


    a wm:Choice .


<http://www.gliffy.com/>
    rdfs:comment "Gliffy seems to revial Omnigraffle in functionality but is an HTML5 app.";

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:isPretty ;
       rdfs:comment "These are very really pretty diagrams. Line labels look nice" ;

       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:onlineColab ;
       rdfs:comment "There doesnt seem to be live colab, but you can share and edit the diagrams concurrently.  Unfortunately, users are not notified of a new version.  Im Sad.  I wish it was better" ;

       wm:score wm:partlySatisfies

    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:uml ;
       wm:score wm:substantiallySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:graph ;
       wm:score wm:partlySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:flowchart ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:sequence-diagram ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:siteMap ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:uiMock ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:stateDiagram ;
       wm:score wm:fullySatisfies
    ] ;


    a wm:Choice .


<http://creately.com/>
    rdfs:comment "So ugly that I dont even want to include it" ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:intuitive ;
       rdfs:comment "A big ol Meh." ;
       wm:score wm:partlySatisfies
    ] ;

    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:isPretty ;
       rdfs:comment "Meh, it isnt ugly, but it isnt that pretty either." ;
       wm:score wm:partlySatisfies
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:onlineColab ;
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:uml ;
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:graph ;
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:flowchart ;
    ] ;
    wm:choiceScore [
       wm:req _:sequence-diagram ;
    ] ;
    a wm:Choice .

Makefile

results.txt:
	arq --query weighted-matrix.rq --data weighted-matrix.ttl --data diagram-software.ttl > results.txt

clean:
	rm results.txt

results.txt

----------------------------------------------------
| choice                                  | weight |
====================================================
| <http://www.gliffy.com/>                | 79     |
| <http://www.omnigroup.com/omnigraffle/> | 73     |
| <http://www.lucidchart.com/>            | 65     |
| <http://drive.google.com/>              | 35     |
| <http://creately.com/>                  | 10     |
----------------------------------------------------

weighted-matrix.rq

PREFIX wm: <http://vocab-ld.org/vocab/weighted-matrix#> 
PREFIX xsd: <http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#>

SELECT 
?choice (SUM(xsd:integer(?scoreValue)*xsd:integer(?reqValue)) AS ?weight)

{
    ?choice a wm:Choice .
    ?choice wm:choiceScore ?cs .

    ?cs wm:req ?req .
    ?cs wm:score ?score .

    ?score wm:value ?scoreValue .

    ?req wm:importance ?importance .
    ?importance wm:value ?reqValue .
}
GROUP BY ?choice
ORDER BY DESC

weighted-matrix.ttl

@prefix wm: <http://vocab-ld.org/vocab/weighted-matrix#> .
@prefix schema: <http://schema.org/> .
@prefix rdf: <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#> .
@prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .
###===================================================================
### Document metadata
###===================================================================
<.>
    schema:citation <http://it.toolbox.com/blogs/enterprise-solutions/constructing-a-weighted-matrix-13125> .

<http://it.toolbox.com/blogs/enterprise-solutions/constructing-a-weighted-matrix-13125>
    schema:title "Constructing a Weighted Matrix".

###===================================================================
### Classes
###===================================================================

wm:Decision
    rdfs:commant "A decision that needs to be made" ;
    a rdf:Class .
    

wm:Requirement 
    rdfs:comment "A requirement of a decision" ;
    a rdf:Class .
    

wm:Choice
    rdfs:comment "A choice to make for the decision" ;
    a rdf:Class .


wm:Importance
    rdfs:comment "The importance of a requirement" ;
    a rdf:Class .
    

###===================================================================
### Properties
###===================================================================
wm:importance
    rdfs:domain wm:Requirement ;
    rdfs:range wm:Importance ;
    rdfs:comment "How important is this requirement?" ;
    a rdf:Property .

wm:score
    rdfs:comment "How fully does this choice satisfy a choice" ;
    a rdf:Property .

wm:value
    rdfs:comment "The numeric value of the score or importance" ;
    a rdf:Property .
    

wm:weight
    rdfs:comment "The calculated weight of the choice" ;
    a rdf:Property .


###===================================================================
### Objects
###===================================================================
wm:veryHighImportance
    wm:value 5 ;
    a wm:Importance .
    

wm:highImportance
    wm:value 4 ;
    a wm:Importance .

    
wm:mediumImportance
    wm:value 3 ;
    a wm:Importance .


wm:LowImportance
    wm:value 2 ;
    a wm:Importance .


wm:veryLowImportance
    wm:value 1 ;
    a wm:Importance .

    
wm:notImportant
    wm:value 0 ;
    a wm:Importance .

    
wm:fullySatisfies
    wm:value 3 ;
    a wm:Score .


wm:substantiallySatisfies
    a wm:Score ;
    wm:value 2 ;
    rdfs:label "Substantially Satisfies"@en .        


wm:partlySatisfies
    a wm:Score ;
    wm:value 1 ;
    rdfs:label "Partly Satisfies"@en .        


wm:doesNotSatisfy
    a wm:Score ;
    wm:value 0 ;
    rdfs:comment "This is the default score" ;
    rdfs:label "Does Not Satisfy"@en .