Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@getify
Last active October 29, 2021 16:25
Show Gist options
  • Save getify/5253319 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save getify/5253319 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
exploring what a `currentThis` might look like in JS
// This is a theoretical exploration of something that could
// be added to JS. It borrows from JS events which have both a
// `target` and `currentTarget` element, which distinguish between
// the direct target of an event and the delegated parent handling
// the event, respectively.
// The idea is to distinguish between `this` and `currentThis`,
// respectively, as...
//
// `this`: the initial containing object for a call that initiates a
// traversal of the [[Prototype]] chain (just as it currently does)
//
// `currentThis`: the actual link in the [[Prototype]] chain where the
// traversal resolution is completed.
// Notice below that with `bar1` for example, `this` will point to
// `bar1` even when using the delegated `identify()` function found
// on `Foo`, but `currentThis` will point to `Foo`, since that's
// where `identify()` was found in the chain.
// So... what if:
var Foo = Object.create(null);
Foo.me = "Foo";
Foo.identify = function() {
// whenever Foo#identify() is called, `currentThis` will
// always be `Foo`, but `this` will continue to follow the
// established rules for determining a `this` binding.
console.log("Me: " + this.me + "; Current: " + currentThis.me);
};
var Bar = Object.create(Foo);
Bar.me = "Bar";
Bar.another = function() {
console.log("Current: " + currentThis.me);
}
var bar1 = Object.create(Bar);
bar1.me = "bar1";
var bar2 = Object.create(Bar);
bar2.me = "bar2";
Foo.identify(); // "Me: Foo; Current: Foo"
Bar.identify(); // "Me: Bar; Current: Foo"
Bar.another(); // "Current: Bar"
bar1.identify(); // "Me: bar1; Current: Foo"
bar2.identify(); // "Me: bar2; Current: Foo"
bar1.another(); // "Current: Bar"
bar2.another(); // "Current: Bar"
@allenwb
Copy link

allenwb commented Mar 28, 2013

Yes, I was referring to __proto__ tampering that might take place after the call but before the reference to super. An arbitrary large amount of code might execute between those two points include code that does loading, code-generation, dynamic mix-ins, etc.

It's not always obvious what the best semantics are in situations like this. However, in general JS property accesses are defined to reflect the state of objects at the point when the access is made. This allows for the possibility that object structure is dynamically highly mutable. It is probably best to minimize exceptions to that principle.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment