Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@hamelsmu
Created February 13, 2024 22:58
Show Gist options
  • Star 0 You must be signed in to star a gist
  • Fork 0 You must be signed in to fork a gist
  • Save hamelsmu/abfb14b0af4c70e8532f9d4e0ef3e54e to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save hamelsmu/abfb14b0af4c70e8532f9d4e0ef3e54e to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
The logs for SmartLLMChain for this blog post: https://hamel.dev/blog/posts/prompt/
> Entering new SmartLLMChain chain...
Prompt after formatting:
I have a 12 liter jug and a 6 liter jug.I want to measure 6 liters. How do I do it?
Idea 1:
1. Fill the 12 liter jug completely.
2. Pour the contents of the 12 liter jug into the 6 liter jug. This will leave you with 6 liters in the 12 liter jug.
3. Empty the 6 liter jug.
4. Pour the remaining 6 liters from the 12 liter jug into the now empty 6 liter jug.
5. You now have 6 liters in the 6 liter jug.
Idea 2:
1. Fill the 12 liter jug completely.
2. Pour the contents of the 12 liter jug into the 6 liter jug. This will leave you with 6 liters in the 12 liter jug.
3. Empty the 6 liter jug.
4. Pour the remaining 6 liters from the 12 liter jug into the now empty 6 liter jug.
5. You now have 6 liters in the 6 liter jug.
Critique:
Flaws and faulty logic in Idea 1:
1. The first step of filling the 12 liter jug completely assumes that the jug can hold exactly 12 liters without any overflow or measurement errors. This assumption may not be accurate in reality.
2. Pouring the contents of the 12 liter jug into the 6 liter jug assumes that the 6 liter jug can hold all 12 liters without any spillage or measurement errors. Again, this assumption may not be accurate.
3. Emptying the 6 liter jug assumes that it can be emptied completely without any residue or measurement errors. This assumption may not be accurate.
4. Pouring the remaining 6 liters from the 12 liter jug into the now empty 6 liter jug assumes that the remaining 6 liters can be accurately measured and transferred without any spillage or measurement errors. This assumption may not be accurate.
5. The conclusion that you now have 6 liters in the 6 liter jug assumes that all the measurements and transfers were accurate and error-free, which may not be the case.
Flaws and faulty logic in Idea 2:
1. The first step of filling the 12 liter jug completely assumes that the jug can hold exactly 12 liters without any overflow or measurement errors. This assumption may not be accurate in reality.
2. Pouring the contents of the 12 liter jug into the 6 liter jug assumes that the 6 liter jug can hold all 12 liters without any spillage or measurement errors. Again, this assumption may not be accurate.
3. Emptying the 6 liter jug assumes that it can be emptied completely without any residue or measurement errors. This assumption may not be accurate.
4. Pouring the remaining 6 liters from the 12 liter jug into the now empty 6 liter jug assumes that the remaining 6 liters can be accurately measured and transferred without any spillage or measurement errors. This assumption may not be accurate.
5. The conclusion that you now have 6 liters in the 6 liter jug assumes that all the measurements and transfers were accurate and error-free, which may not be the case.
In both ideas, there are several assumptions made about the accuracy and precision of the measurements and transfers, which may not hold true in practice. Additionally, there is no consideration given to the possibility of spillage or measurement errors, which can significantly affect the final result.
Resolution:
Idea 1: 1. Fill the 12 liter jug completely.
2. Pour the contents of the 12 liter jug into the 6 liter jug. This will leave you with 6 liters in the 12 liter jug.
3. Empty the 6 liter jug.
4. Pour the remaining 6 liters from the 12 liter jug into the now empty 6 liter jug.
5. You now have 6 liters in the 6 liter jug.
Idea 2: 1. Fill the 12 liter jug completely.
2. Pour the contents of the 12 liter jug into the 6 liter jug. This will leave you with 6 liters in the 12 liter jug.
3. Empty the 6 liter jug.
4. Pour the remaining 6 liters from the 12 liter jug into the now empty 6 liter jug.
5. You now have 6 liters in the 6 liter jug.
Improved Answer:
1. Fill the 12 liter jug completely.
2. Pour the contents of the 12 liter jug into the 6 liter jug until the 6 liter jug is full. This will leave you with 6 liters in the 12 liter jug and the 6 liter jug completely filled.
3. Empty the 6 liter jug.
4. Pour the remaining 6 liters from the 12 liter jug into the now empty 6 liter jug.
5. You now have 6 liters in the 6 liter jug.
Full Answer:
To measure 6 liters using a 12 liter jug and a 6 liter jug, follow these steps:
1. Fill the 12 liter jug completely.
2. Pour the contents of the 12 liter jug into the 6 liter jug until the 6 liter jug is full. This will leave you with 6 liters in the 12 liter jug and the 6 liter jug completely filled.
3. Empty the 6 liter jug.
4. Pour the remaining 6 liters from the 12 liter jug into the now empty 6 liter jug.
5. You now have 6 liters in the 6 liter jug.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment