Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@janeknowsbest77
Created July 28, 2024 17:15
Show Gist options
  • Save janeknowsbest77/1f3b01addc8dbd6b06cf7e4379469e10 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save janeknowsbest77/1f3b01addc8dbd6b06cf7e4379469e10 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Unleash Your Lashes - The Top 32 Over The Counter Mascaras for Volume and Color
title
Unleash Your Lashes - The Top 32 Over The Counter Mascaras for Volume and Color

Unleash Your Lashes: The Top 32 Over The Counter Mascaras for Volume and Color

Over-The-Counter-Mascara-1

Welcome to the world of over-the-counter mascaras! In this roundup article, we'll be exploring a range of products designed to enhance your lashes and make you look your best. We'll dive into the features and benefits of each mascara, so you can make an informed decision when it comes to choosing the right one for your needs. Get ready to discover the best over-the-counter mascara for you!

As an Amazon Affiliate, we earn through qualified purchases at no cost to you!

Reviews

sephora-collection-big-by-definition-ultra-black-mascara-1

The Sephora Collection Big by Definition Ultra Black Mascara offers a buildable formula to instantly define and separate every lash with its multidimensional brush. This mascara is long-lasting yet easy to remove, and it doesn't clump, run, or flake.

The formula is enriched with plant-based proteins and vegetable-derived waxes to smooth and condition lashes. Users appreciate the quality brush, easy application, and removal, while some report issues with smudging, flaking, and clumping.

Overall, this mascara provides volume and length, maintaining a natural look, and won't dry out easily.

armani-beauty-eyes-to-kill-mini-mascara-1

Armani Beauty's Eyes to Kill Mini Mascara delivers the glamour of a high-end mascara in a convenient travel size. Its lengthening and volumizing formula enhances lashes, leaving them with enhanced definition and thickness. The mini mascara wand is easy to apply and smudge-free, providing a natural false eyelash effect for a polished, glamorous eye makeup look. The mascara is also easy to remove, making it a versatile choice for beauty enthusiasts.

Despite its many positive attributes, the mascara does have some drawbacks. Some users have reported issues with flaking and drying out quickly, which may affect the overall performance and comfort of the product. Additionally, it does not have lash-growing ingredients, which might be a disappointment for those who want to enhance the growth and health of their lashes.

Overall, the Eyes to Kill Mini Mascara is a high-quality and luxurious choice for those seeking a convenient, glamorous option for their beauty routine. Its lengthening and volumizing formula, as well as the ease of application, make it a favorite among users. While it may not be perfect for everyone, its versatility and performance make it a worthwhile addition to any makeup collection.

maybelline-great-lash-mascara-very-black-101-0-43-fl-oz-tube-1

Maybelline's Great Lash Mascara is a timeless favorite, offering a blend of quality and affordability. With a smooth, lash-doubling formula, this mascara glides on effortlessly, creating full, attractive lashes that are safe for contact lens wearers. The lash-building brush makes it simple to achieve a full-lash look, while hypoallergenic properties ensure gentle application for all users.

However, some users may experience minor drawbacks like clumping or smudging after long wear. The mascara's formula has undergone some changes, resulting in a tweaked consistency compared to the original version. Nevertheless, this mascara remains a beloved staple in many makeup collections, thanks to its buildable, long-lasting application and versatility in creating an everyday, natural look.

sephora-collection-love-the-lift-curling-volumizing-mascara-ultra-black-1

As a dedicated mascara enthusiast, I was intrigued by the promise of the Love The Lift Curling + Volumizing Mascara Ultra Black. The concept of using a brush specifically designed to impart lift and curl seemed like a game-changer in my makeup routine, especially considering my naturally straight lashes.

Upon application, I was instantly drawn to the unique silicone brush, which boasted both short and long bristles. Its clever dual-sided design allowed me to alternate between the two, seamlessly loading lashes with color while simultaneously stretching them for a dramatic curl. The result was a captivating "lift" that elevated my lashes like no other mascara I've tried.

The mascara itself was a delightful balance of form and function. Its lightweight, highly pigmented formula not only delivered a striking black hue but also seemed to defy gravity, providing a lasting 12-hour lift without clumping or flaking. Additionally, the absence of harsh chemicals made removal a breeze, with no need for aggressive scrubbing or the use of a makeup remover.

However, with all products, there are pros and cons. A minor drawback was the mascara's tendency to smudge slightly throughout the day, particularly if my eyes became teary or oily. Despite this, the overall impact of the Love The Lift mascara was nothing short of spectacular.

In conclusion, the Love The Lift Curling + Volumizing Mascara Ultra Black is an impressive offering that delivers on its promises and offers a unique blend of lift, curl, and volume in a single stroke. While not perfect, it certainly deserves a spot in any mascara aficionado's collection.

maybelline-the-colossal-big-shot-volum-express-mascara-washable-blackest-black-223-0-33-fl-oz-1

Get ready for bold lashes with Maybelline's Volum' Express The Colossal Big Shot Mascara. This easy-to-apply mascara features a collagen formula that adds volume and prevents flaking. The unique, wavy brush applicator evenly coats each lash, delivering a smooth finish without clumping.

Suitable for contact lens wearers and free of oil, this washable mascara is a favorite for those wanting a long-lasting, smudge-proof look.

essence-mascara-gel-lash-brow-0-3-fl-oz-1

I recently used the Essence Lash & Brow Gel Mascara in my daily life, and I have to say, it's a game-changer for those of us with unruly brows and lashes. The gel mascara pampers your brows as well as your lashes, helping them to stay in shape and looking perfect.

One of the highlights of this product is the spoolie brush applicator. It provides an even and precise application, making it easy to apply the mascara to your lashes and brows. The gel formula is gel-like, not too runny or too liquidy, which I found to be a positive feature.

However, there were a couple of downsides to using the Essence Lash & Brow Gel Mascara. It doesn't have much color or volumizing effect, and you might need to reapply it throughout the day for better hold. Also, I found that it dries out too quickly and can sometimes cause irritation around the eyes.

Overall, I give this product 4 out of 10 stars. It's a decent option for those looking for a clear mascara to style their lashes and brows, but there are better alternatives out there for those looking for a product that provides more hold and color.

essence-lash-princess-false-lash-effect-mascara-black-brown-1

Elevate your lashes with the Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara, available in both Black and Brown shades. This mascara features a conically shaped fiber wand, giving you the perfect combination of length and dramatic volume. Designed with a false lash effect, it provides mesmerizing results for your natural lashes, and is ophthalmologically tested for stunning, standout lashes.

Perfect for those looking for a more natural look with no clumps or flakes, and is easy to apply, remove, and maintain. Enjoy the texture and comfort it provides for a visually appealing and comfortable experience.

no7-age-defying-all-in-one-serum-mascara-0-23-fl-oz-1

I recently tried the No7 Age Defying Mascara and was pleasantly surprised by its performance. As someone with sensitive eyes, I usually avoid trying new mascaras but this one seemed promising. When I opened the tube, I noticed the oversized brush, which I found was a great feature as it allowed me to easily sweep the mascara across my lashes for volume and length.

The first thing I noticed when I applied the mascara was the wetness, but with a bit of care, I was able to work with it. I appreciated that it created an instant false lash effect without any clumping or smudging. However, I noticed that it took a good minute or so for the mascara to dry completely and I had to be mindful of blinking and stray hair during that time.

One of the biggest highlights for me was how gentle the mascara was on my eyes, even though they are prone to watering. It came off easily with my chosen makeup remover and I didn't experience any flaking or drooping throughout the day. Overall, I was quite impressed with the results and would recommend this mascara for anyone looking for easy application and longer, fuller lashes.

e-l-f-cosmetics-lash-xtndr-mascara-soft-black-1

After struggling with flakes and smudges from my previous tubing mascara, I was ready to give Lash XTNDR Mascara a try, especially for its unique blend of jojoba seed oil. As I unscrewed the cap, I was amazed by how soft and silky the brush felt on my lashes.

The first swipe of the mascara coated my lashes evenly, starting from the roots and reaching all the way to the tips. It felt light, without any clumping or dragging, making for a smooth application process. The "Soft Black" shade added an intensity and sophistication that I had never experienced with a tubing mascara before.

Throughout the day, it held its shape and enhanced the look of my lashes without any smudging or transfer to my upper eyelids. I even tried this mascara during a hot day, and it remained crease-free and flake-free, a huge improvement compared to my previous tubing mascara experiences.

When it was time to remove the mascara, it came off effortlessly with just warm water, leaving my lashes untouched and my eyes feeling as if nothing was on them. The jojoba seed oil formula didn't disappoint, as my lashes didn't dry out after a few uses.

Overall, Lash XTNDR Mascara proved to be a game-changer for my everyday beauty routine. Not only did it provide buildable length and enhanced lash definition, but it did so without the irritation, flaking, or smudging that I had experienced with other tubing mascaras. At such an affordable price, I'm thrilled to have found a mascara that not only lasts but provides a natural-looking, full, and volumizing finish.

loreal-voluminous-original-straight-brush-mascara-black-305-0-28-fl-oz-tube-1

I've been using the L'Oreal Voluminous Original Straight Brush Mascara for quite some time now, and it has become a staple in my daily makeup routine. The brush is designed to maximize volume and provide a smooth, even application that doesn't leave any flakes or clumps behind.

One of the major positives of this mascara is its gentle formula - it's suitable for people with sensitive eyes and even those who wear contact lenses. Another highlight is it's fragrance-free, which is great for people with allergies or sensitivities to certain scents.

But, there were a few cons I found with this product. The first issue is that it occasionally flakes, which can be quite disappointing after a long day. Additionally, it can be a bit tricky to remove, especially if you've applied multiple coats.

Despite those downsides, overall, the L'Oreal Voluminous Mascara has consistently delivered on its promise to give my lashes a fuller, more dramatic look. It's become a trusted part of my makeup routine, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a high-quality mascara that adds volume and length to their lashes.

florence-by-mills-up-a-notch-volumizing-mascara-black-1

I was thrilled to try Florence by Mills Up A Notch Volumizing Mascara in black, and I must say it did not disappoint! The wand picked up just the right amount of product, easily gliding over each lash, coating them with a blend of rice bran, carnauba, and candelilla waxes. The mascara added a beautiful length to my lashes without making them look clumpy or messy. As I built up the mascara, my lashes became fuller and more defined.

One of the features I appreciated the most is that this mascara didn't smudge throughout the day, which is something I often struggle with in other mascaras. It also didn't flake or create any noticeable fallout on my face. In fact, I found it to be quite gentle on my eyes, as it was easy to remove at the end of the day without causing any irritation.

My only complaint would be that it's not waterproof, so it's not the best choice for those who work around water or have watery eyes. Aside from that, I'd highly recommend this mascara to anyone looking for a versatile, long-lasting, and gentle volumizing mascara. If you like the idea of a natural, yet eye-catching look, be sure to give Florence by Mills Up A Notch Volumizing Mascara a try. You won't be disappointed!

charlotte-tilbury-pillow-talk-push-up-lashes-mascara-travel-size-1

For a luscious eye-popping look, the Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes mascara from Charlotte Tilbury is your best bet. This travel size mascara offers a rich, deep black tint that gives intense definition to your lashes. With its special formula containing lash-lifting polymers, carnauba wax, and microcrystalline wax, this mascara lifts and holds your lashes in place for a fuller, more voluminous look. Its keratin-reinforced formula conditions the hair fibers, making your lashes feel thicker and healthier.

The precision paddle brush, equipped with diamond-shaped bristles, glides effortlessly through your lashes, giving them a natural-looking uplift. Its "Load, Comb, and Lift" technology ensures even application and minimizes clumping, providing a smooth, smudge-free finish. The stretch effect formula with L-tree ingredients ensures all-day comfort and support, without the need for eyelash curlers.

Although some users have reported issues with smudging and clumping, the Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes mascara is still a popular choice among beauty enthusiasts, thanks to its ease of application, longevity, and overall visual appeal. The unique oval brush design makes it a standout product for those seeking a more natural-looking result. If you're in the market for a high-quality mascara that adds length, volume, and an eye-catching glam, this travel-sized Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes mascara might just be the one for you.

wet-n-wild-mega-protein-mascara-very-black-c149a-0-21-fl-oz-1

This Wet N Wild Mega Protein Mascara is a versatile and dramatic mascara that instantly defines and extends lashes. Infused with nourishing acai oil and soy protein, the high-performance formula promotes healthy-looking lashes with maximum impact. Its innovative wand applicator offers easy and quick application, ensuring every single lash is coated.

The soft helix brush allows for quick layering of the formula, while the mascara's ability to sweep away clumps ensures high-impact glam. The mascara is great for all genders and comes in a universal black shade that's easy to apply. The wand applicator and the soy protein infusion make this a great choice for those who want to enhance their lashes with a touch of drama.

maybelline-great-lash-waterproof-mascara-brownish-black-112-0-43-fl-oz-tube-1

I recently gave Maybelline's Great Lash Waterproof Mascara a try, and it didn't disappoint. The formula is hypoallergenic, so it doesn't irritate my lashes or cause any discomfort. The unique lash-building brush allowed me to easily achieve a voluminous, full-lash look in just one application. I especially appreciated that it was suitable for contact lens wearers and had been ophthalmologist tested.

I found the mascara to be waterproof, which is great for hot summer days or when I need long-lasting wear. The formula didn't clump or smudge, so it kept my lashes looking smooth and well-defined all day. Applying it was a breeze, thanks to the easy-to-use brush that evenly distributed the mascara along each lash.

However, there were a few downsides to using this mascara. Firstly, I noticed that it sometimes started to flake by the end of the day, which wasn't very appealing. Additionally, if I had a particularly wet day or if any tears occurred in my eyes, the mascara would start to come off in small flakes, which was less than ideal.

In summary, I quite enjoyed using the Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara. It provided a natural look with great-looking lashes, was easy to apply, and suitable for contact lens wearers. While it did flake slightly by the end of the day and had some issues with removing it, overall, it was a pretty decent product that delivered good results.

loreal-voluminous-lash-paradise-mascara-black-201-0-28-fl-oz-1

Introducing L'Oréal Paris Lash Paradise mascara, the ultimate tool for enhancing your lashes and giving them a voluptuous, thick appearance. Despite the occasional complaints about it drying out quickly and the need for frequent tube replacements, the majority of users appreciate the mascara's ability to provide noticeable volume and length with a soft, flattering application.

The key highlight of this mascara is its rich pigment, which delivers impressive color in just one stroke, making it perfect for those who want a truly dramatic look for their lashes. The wavy bristle brush offers an even and precise application, ensuring that each lash is coated with the formula and contributing to its ability to add voluminous volume and length.

However, some users have reported irritation due to its synthetic fragrance and the potential presence of certain chemicals, like parabens, which may affect skin texture and cause breakouts. Despite these concerns, the majority of customers find the overall benefits of the Lash Paradise mascara to be well worth the investment, and many have even found it to be a budget-friendly alternative to more expensive designer brands.

With a flattering, lightweight texture, this mascara can help curls lashes and make them appear longer and more voluminous. However, it's essential to remember that the formula needs to be replaced frequently to ensure it remains smudge-free and to avoid potential flaking issues. Overall, the L'Oréal Paris Lash Paradise mascara is a popular option for those looking for a product that will provide intense color and noticeable enhancement to their lashes, but it's crucial to consider the individual user's preferences and potential sensitivities to the formula.

covergirl-last-blast-volume-blasting-mascara-black-805-0-44-fl-oz-tube-1

In my experience, the CoverGirl Last Blast Volume Blasting Mascara truly delivers on volume and fullness. The specially designed brush helps maximize each lash, giving me a bold and dramatic look that lasts all day. One of the standout features is the mascara's hypoallergenic formula, which is perfect for contact lens wearers like myself.

However, there were a few drawbacks to my experience. The wet formula can sometimes weigh down my lashes, making them appear shorter instead of longer. Additionally, the mascara's removal can be a bit of a challenge – it doesn't come off easily, even with makeup remover.

Overall, the CoverGirl Lashblast Volume Mascara provides a great balance of volume and length, but it may not be the best option for those with straight or short lashes. The mascara's hypoallergenic formula and ease of removal are definitely pluses, but the wet formula and stubborn removal process could deter some users.

clio-kill-lash-superproof-mascara-03-sleek-volume-1

I recently gave the Clio Kill Lash Superproof Mascara a try, and I must say it was quite a delightful experience. The slim curve brush made it incredibly easy to apply the mascara on my lashes, ensuring I covered all the hidden and inner ones without the fear of clumping.

One of the standout features for me was how the mascara added volume and length without making my lashes appear clumpy or heavy. It held the lashes perfectly curled all day, giving a natural and effortless look.

However, the one aspect I'd like to point out is the product's drying time. It seemed to dry out a bit faster than I would have preferred, which made it tricky to remove at the end of the day. Otherwise, it was a great experience, and I'll definitely consider repurchasing this mascara in the future.

maybelline-lash-sensational-mascara-sky-high-waterproof-very-black-802-0-2-fl-oz-1

Recently, I've been using the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High mascara in the Very Black shade. The first thing that stands out about this product is its exclusive Flex Tower brush, which really does deliver full volume and limitless length. I found that it's pretty easy to apply and doesn't clump too much, unlike some other mascaras I've tried.

One of the things I appreciate about this product is that it doesn't smudge or flake throughout the day. It's also comforting to know that it's ophthalmologist tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. However, I do find the washable formula a bit difficult to remove, leaving my lashes somewhat challenging to clean, especially if I'm in a rush to remove it.

Overall, I would say my experience with the Lash Sensational Sky High mascara has been quite positive. It does provide the volume and length I'm looking for in a mascara, and its unique Flex Tower brush makes a difference. If you're looking for a high-quality mascara offering comfort and durability, this might be the one for you. Just be prepared for a slightly challenging removal process.

wet-n-wild-mega-volume-mascara-very-black-c156a-0-21-fl-oz-1

Imagine having lashes so bold and voluminous that they draw attention and make a statement. Well, that's exactly what you get with the Wet N Wild Mega Volume Mascara. Featuring a full spiral fiber brush, this mascara not only applies smoothly but also hugs each lash, making it appear rich and deep, thanks to the very black pigment it's infused with.

One of the standout features of this mascara is its waterproof formula, making it perfect for those who live in humid climates or enjoy swimming without having to constantly worry about their mascara running. The Vitamin E infusion is another notable highlight, as it helps in promoting the growth of voluminous eyelashes while keeping them protected and luminous.

However, as with any product, there are pros and cons. While the mascara does provide a long-lasting impact and adds both volume and length to your lashes, it might not be the best choice for those looking for a product that offers a more natural finish. Additionally, some users have reported that the mascara can clump together if not applied correctly or allowed to dry; this can be easily fixed by using a lash separation brush right after application.

In conclusion, if you're in search of a mascara that provides maximum volume and length to your lashes while withstanding various environmental factors, the Wet N Wild Mega Volume Mascara is definitely worth considering. Just make sure to apply it correctly and take note of the potential clumping issue.

e-l-f-cosmetics-lash-n-roll-curling-mascara-black-1

A few weeks ago, I decided to give the e. l. f. Cosmetics Lash 'n Roll Curling Mascara in Pitch Black shade a try. I'm a fan of cruelty-free makeup, so I appreciated that this mascara is free from animal testing, parabens, and phthalates. With 9 grams of liquid mascara inside, this isn't the biggest travel-friendly container, but I found that it's quite long-lasting, so I don't need much of it.

The applicator brush of this mascara is unique and double-sided, with both short and long bristles. The long bristles help separate and lift each individual lash, while the short ones hold onto the formula for better control. This gives my lashes a dramatic and striking look that I can't get enough of.

However, I have noticed that this mascara doesn't hold the curl for as long as I'd like. Regardless of this, the overall performance of the e. l. f. Cosmetics Lash 'n Roll Curling Mascara in Pitch Black shade exceeded my expectations. The product is easy to apply, doesn't clump or smudge, and is relatively easy to remove at the end of the day.

judy-doll-mascara-judy-doll-iron-strong-mascara-3d-curling-eyelash-iron-mascara-non-clumping-smudge--1

The Judy Doll Iron Strong Mascara stands out for its ability to provide 3D curling effects while being smudge-proof, flake-proof, and long-lasting. This mascara features a gentle, hypoallergenic formula that is perfect for those with sensitive eyes.

It effortlessly lengthens and thickens lashes, avoiding clumping even with multiple coats. The secret lies in its soft and flexible applicator, which ensures natural curling without causing eyelashes to stick. The mascara also boasts a waterproof formula, making it suitable for those with short and straight lashes that require extra help to stay in place throughout the day.

too-faced-better-than-sex-mini-mascara-black-0-17-oz-tube-1

The Too Faced Better Than Sex mascara is a luxurious product that promises to enhance your lashes, making them visibly longer, fuller, and more voluminous. The mascara comes in a sleek, hourglass-shaped tube, featuring a unique, collagen-fueled formula that is infused with acacia extract to nourish and strengthen your lashes. This mascara's application is smooth and easy, as it is equipped with a precision brush that hugs the lashes, delivering an even, clump-free finish.

The film-forming polymers in the formula create a smudge-proof and waterproof layer that locks your lashes in place, providing an all-day wear for 14+ hours without flaking. This mascara is free of parabens, gluten, and is cruelty-free, making it a great choice for those who care about their skin's health and the environment. It is also widely considered as the #1-selling prestige mascara in the U. S. , giving you the peace of mind in its quality and performance.

tarte-travel-size-tartelette-tubing-mascara-brown-1

Imagine lash extensions but available in a tube, and you have Tarte's Travel-Size Tartelette Tubing Mascara. This innovative mascara promises to extend, volumize, and condition your lashes for a stunning appearance.

The first-ever tubing mascara uses micro-tubing technology that wraps each lash individually, ensuring lasting coverage without the weight of thick layers of pigment. It is available in an array of shades, including the popular Brown option, making it the perfect addition to your makeup routine.

However, it is crucial to note that this mascara may not be for everyone. Some users have reported issues with flaking and the mascara smudging or transferring to other areas of the face. Additionally, individuals with sensitive eyes or skin might find the formula to be irritating.

Despite these minor drawbacks, many users rave about this mascara, complimenting its ease of application and the impressive lash extension it provides. Those who have become loyal fans of the Travel-Size Tartelette Tubing Mascara often say that they can't go back to traditional mascaras once they have tried its unique formula.

In conclusion, if you're in the market for a new tubing mascara that delivers on its promises of extending, volumizing, and conditioning your lashes, the Tarte Travel-Size Tartelette Tubing Mascara in Brown might be the perfect choice for you. Just be prepared for some possible flaking and potential irritation, especially for those with sensitive eyes or skin.

burts-bees-mascara-nourishing-classic-black-1305-0-40-oz-1

I've tried Burts Bees Nourishing Mascara in Classic Black, and I have to say, it's been a game changer for me. The convenient applicator made it easy to apply, and the classic black color was perfect for my eye color. I loved that the brush and formula worked together to give me long-lasting definition and nourished my lashes.

As someone with sensitive eyes, I appreciated that this mascara was safe for me to use and free of parabens, phthalates, and synthetic fragrances. It also applied smoothly and was gentle on my delicate eye area. The nourishing ingredients, like Jojoba Oil and Glycerin, made a big difference in the health of my lashes. I noticed they looked more lush and voluminous than ever before.

However, there were a couple of downsides for me. Sometimes the mascara would smudge a bit, especially when I got home from a long day. It also took a bit longer to dry than some other mascaras I've tried. On the plus side, it was easy to remove at the end of the day.

Overall, I would highly recommend Burts Bees Nourishing Mascara to anyone looking for a natural, long-lasting mascara that nourishes lashes and doesn't irritate sensitive eyes.

tower-28-beauty-mini-makewaves-lengthening-volumizing-mascara-jet-0-17-oz-5-ml-1

This vegan mascara offers a safe and gentle experience for sensitive eyes while delivering visibly volumized and lengthened lashes, perfect for those seeking a natural-looking amplification. The key selling point is its ability to separate, not clump, lashes, creating a fluffy texture that can be easily built upon for added volume without causing crunchiness. Unfortunately, some users complain of smudging and flaking, as well as the quick drying out of the product.

Fortunately, this mascara comes off easily with an oil cleanser, making it a gentle option for those with delicate skin.

benefit-theyre-real-lengthening-mascara-black-0-14-fl-oz-tube-1

Just the other day, I was getting ready for a party and found myself reaching for this mascara - They're Real! Lengthening Mascara. The formula is long-wearing and super glossy, making my lashes appear dramatically longer and even fuller. It was love at first use!

The brush makes all the difference, with its ability to apply the mascara horizontally or vertically for a perfectly applied coat. And let's not forget, the tube is small enough to fit into my on-the-go makeup bag, making it super convenient to bring with me wherever I go.

But there were a few downsides. Despite how well it worked, it was a bit of a pain to remove at the end of the day. A good deal of time and patience were required to get it off without irritating my eyes. And while it didn't clump or smudge, it had a tendency to flake off throughout the day, leaving my lashes looking a bit lackluster.

Overall, I'd say this mascara was quite the mixed bag. It had plenty of great features, like the long-wearing formula and convenience, but came with a few drawbacks. I'd definitely recommend it to others, but with the caveat that it might not be the perfect fit for everyone.

maybelline-lash-sensational-mascara-sky-high-blackest-black-800-0-24-fl-oz-1

Experience the sensation of lash-lifting with the incredible Maybelline Lash Sensational mascara! Designed to give you sky high lashes with unparalleled length, this mascara is ophthalmologist tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Its exclusive flex tower brush gently bends to volumize and extend each lash, creating a natural yet dramatic look. The washable, waterproof formula infused with bamboo extract and fibers ensures long-lasting full lashes without weighing them down.

Available in two shades, choose between Very Black and Blackest Black to enhance your lash game. This mascara is allergy tested, easy to remove, and perfect for adding volume and length to your lashes.

Say goodbye to flaking, clumping, and smudging - Lash Sensational is the ultimate mascara for all your needs!

tower-28-makewaves-mascara-jet-black-1

MakeWaves Mascara is a gentle, safe option for those with sensitive eyes. Its vegan formula is free from gluten and cruelty, making it a great choice for those who prioritize the environment and animal welfare. The mascara is infused with Aquaflex Technology, which helps to lengthen, define, and hold a curl.

It's also designed with a breakthrough Triple-Wave Wand that features three flexible suspended bands, perfect for those seeking a natural look. While it might not be the best option for those seeking extreme volume, it offers a clean, lightweight feel that doesn’t flake or smudge, keeping irritation and breakage at bay.

essence-mascara-lash-princess-0-4-fl-oz-1

Elevate your lashes to new heights with Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect mascara, making your eyes mesmerizing and alluring. This magical product harnesses the power of enchanting volume, alluring length, and captivating intensity for a regal gaze that is sure to catch everyone's attention.

The mascara's unique conic-shaped fiber brush captures every lash, transforming them into an army of lashes that are voluminous, lifted, and beautifully fanned-out. This innovative design ensures that every lash gets the right amount of attention for a glamorous and flawless finish. With a long-lasting, clump-free formula that coats each lash from root to tip, you can experience the magic of dramatic volume, length, and intense black pigment all day long.

For those seeking cruelty-free beauty, the Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect mascara promises regal beauty without harming a single creature. This means you can indulge in the pleasure of enchanting lashes knowing that you made a compassionate choice.

Elevate your everyday makeup routine with this must-have beauty essential and become the envy of all as you flutter your lashes in the mirror, ready to conquer the day ahead.

maybelline-lash-sensational-mascara-waterproof-very-black-257-0-3-fl-oz-1

The Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara, Waterproof, Very Black, is a popular choice for those seeking an eye-catching, lengthening mascara. Its fanning brush with ten layers of bristles captures even the tiniest lashes, providing a full-fan effect. The buildable liquid ink formula coats lashes without clumping, while its waterproof formula ensures longevity.

While users appreciate the mascara's ability to add length and volume, some find the applicator difficult to work with, leading to clumpy results and a risk of "spider leg" lashes. The mascara's dry nature can also pose a challenge in achieving a separation of lashes for an impressive and well-defined look. However, it is praised for its smudge-resistance during the day and being easy to remove at night.

The Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara is suitable for users with sensitive eyes or wearing contacts. Despite its shortcomings, it remains a sought-after product for those seeking a vibrant, long-lasting mascara to enhance their eyes.

maybelline-lash-sensational-mascara-blackest-black-253-0-32-fl-oz-1

Embrace the sensational lash effects with the Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara, a blackest black formulation that adds volume and length to your lashes. Featuring a flexible fan brush with ten layers of bristles, this mascara is perfect for revealing the full potential of your lashes. Thanks to the liquid ink formula, your lashes are coated from root to tip, revealing a dramatic, voluminous effect. Infused with precious oils, the mascara not only lengthens and volumizes your lashes but also nourishes them.

A comfortable to wear product, it doesn't clump, smudge, or flake throughout the day. Ideal for contact lens wearers and ophthalmologist-tested, this mascara is suitable for sensitive eyes as well. It dries out quickly, making it easier for an on-the-go touch-up. The visual appeal of this mascara is impressive, with a blend of colors that truly pop on your lashes. The scent is light and refreshing, providing a gentle and pleasant experience throughout the day.

Overall, Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara in Blackest Black delivers on its promises, providing impressive volume and length to lashes. It is a high-quality product that is easy to apply and remove, making it a must-have for makeup enthusiasts.

lor-al-paris-telescopic-original-lengthening-mascara-carbon-black-0-27-fl-oz-1

I've been using the L'Oréal Telescopic Lengthening Mascara for quite some time now, and I can say it has become a reliable addition to my makeup routine. The mascara seems to provide a bit more length than other products I've tried, lengthening my lashes without causing them to look clumpy or overdone. The brush is flexible and easy to maneuver, which comes in handy for those of us with smaller eyes and hard-to-reach lashes.

One of my favorite features of this mascara is that it applies smoothly, providing a clean and defined look to the lashes. The formula is lightweight and stays in place throughout the day, without causing flaking or smudging. However, on the downside, I've found that the product tends to dry out relatively quickly, necessitating more frequent replacement.

Overall, the L'Oréal Telescopic Lengthening Mascara is a great choice if you're looking to add some length to your lashes without weighing them down or causing them to clump together. Just be prepared to replace the product more often than some other mascaras on the market.

Buyer's Guide

When it comes to choosing the perfect over the counter mascara, there are several essential factors to consider. Understanding these features and considerations will help you make an informed decision and find the right product for your needs. In this buyer's guide, we will discuss general features, tips, and advice to guide you in selecting the perfect over the counter mascara for your eyes.

Important Features to Consider

  1. Type of brush: Over the counter mascaras come in various brush types, such as hourglass, curved, or comb. You should choose a brush type that allows you to easily apply the mascara to your lashes, separating them and creating a natural look. Consider your eyelashes' length, thickness, and curl when selecting the perfect mascara brush.

Considerations When Choosing OTC Mascara

  1. Formula: The formula of a mascara is crucial in determining its performance. Consider the type of formula you prefer, such as waterproof, long-wear, or moisturizing. Waterproof mascaras are ideal for those with oily skin or those living in humid climates. Long-wear mascaras provide extended wear with minimal smudging or flaking. Moisturizing mascaras help condition your lashes and prevent breakage.

Application Techniques and Tips

  1. Wiggle the brush: Instead of sweeping the brush from root to tip, wiggle the mascara wand to lift and separate your lashes, giving them a fuller appearance. This technique also prevents clumping and ensures even distribution of mascara throughout your lashes. Wiggling the brush also helps to minimize smudging and keeps the mascara on your lashes for longer.

Advice for Choosing Over The Counter Mascara

  1. Test before purchasing: Always test a mascara before buying it to ensure it suits your skin type and preferences. Apply a small amount to the inside of your wrist or the back of your hand, and let it dry for a few minutes. Observe for any adverse reactions, such as itching, redness, or irritation. If the mascara passes the test, you can proceed with applying it to your eyelashes for a more accurate assessment of its performance.

FAQ

What is Over The Counter Mascara?

Over the counter (OTC) mascara refers to makeup products that are available for purchase without a prescription. These mascaras are safe to use and can be found in various department stores and online retailers. They come in a wide range of formulas, colors, and volumes, catering to different preferences and needs.

OTC mascaras are generally more affordable than luxury brands and are popular for their easy accessibility. They often have easy-to-remove formulas, preventing eye irritation and making it simple to maintain the user's lashes. There are various options, including those that provide a natural look and others that deliver dramatic volume and length.

What benefits can Over The Counter Mascara provide?

There are several benefits that over the counter mascaras offer, including:

  1. Enhancing eyelash appearance: Mascaras can add length, volume, and curl to lashes, giving them a more dramatic and fuller appearance. 2) Improving visual appeal: Mascara can help to define the eyes, making them appear more open, awake, and youthful. 3) Amplifying facial features: By drawing attention to the eyes, mascara can make a person's overall facial features appear more prominent and attractive. 4) Protecting lashes: Many mascaras contain ingredients designed to nourish and protect lashes, promoting a healthier and more vibrant appearance.

OTC mascaras often come with applicators that are easy to use, allowing users to apply the product to their lashes with precision. Additionally, the wide range of colors available ensures that there is a suitable mascara to complement every outfit and occasion. OTC mascaras are a versatile and affordable option for those looking to enhance their daily makeup routine or make a statement with bold, dramatic lashes.

What are the ingredients in Over The Counter Mascara?

Over the counter mascaras contain various ingredients, depending on the manufacturer's formulation. Some common components include:

  1. Waxes: Provides a base for the formula and helps to form a smooth, creamy consistency. 2) Pigments: Determines the color of the mascara. 3) Oils: Provides lubrication and helps to make the mascara easy to spread and remove. 4) Polymeric resins: Acts as a binder and helps to coat the lashes, providing volume and adhesion.

Many over the counter mascaras also contain ingredients that nourish and condition lashes, such as vitamins, minerals, and proteins. It is essential to review the ingredient list on the product label to ensure that you are not allergic to any specific ingredients and to choose a product that aligns with your preferences.

How do I apply Over The Counter Mascara?

Applying over the counter mascara is simple and straightforward. Here is a step-by-step guide:

  1. Start by choosing a clean and dry eyelash area. 2) Use the wand applicator to apply a thin coat of mascara from base to tip, focusing on the roots of the lashes for more volume. 3) Allow the mascara to fully dry before adding additional coats, if desired. 4) Gently wiggle the wand applicator to separate lashes, ensuring they are not clumped together. 5) Blot any excess mascara with a tissue before finalizing your makeup look.

It is crucial to clean the wand applicator after each use to prevent the buildup of bacteria and to ensure a smooth and consistent application. Additionally, avoid applying mascara near the inner corner of the eye or on the eyebrows, as this may cause irritation and give an unnatural appearance. Practice makes perfect, and as you become more comfortable with the application process, you can experiment with different techniques and volume levels to achieve the desired look.

What precautions should I take when using Over The Counter Mascara?

To ensure a safe and comfortable experience when using over the counter mascara, it is essential to follow these precautions:

  1. Keep the product clean: Make sure the wand applicator and product are clean and free of bacteria to prevent eye irritation. 2) Avoid getting mascara into your eyes: Close your eyes tightly when applying mascara, and use a mirror to achieve the best results. If you accidentally get mascara in your eye, rinse it out immediately with water.

  2. Remove mascara carefully: Choose a mascara remover specially formulated for the eyes and gently wipe away the product. Be careful not to rub your eyes aggressively, as this may lead to irritation or injury. 4) Discard mascara after a certain period: Check the expiration date on the product and discard it after three to six months of use, as the formula may become contaminated and could cause infections. 5) Consider your skin type: If you have sensitive skin, choose hypoallergenic or dermatologist-tested mascaras to minimize the risk of irritation or allergic reactions.

What are some popular Over The Counter Mascara brands?

There are numerous popular over the counter mascara brands available on the market, including:

  1. Maybelline: Known for their Great Lash and Lash Sensational mascaras, Maybelline offers a wide range of colors and formulas suitable for various preferences. 2) L'Oreal: This luxury brand offers a variety of mascaras, such as the Voluminous and False Fiber lines, which deliver volume, length, and curl. 3) CoverGirl: A popular line of affordable mascaras, CoverGirl provides various options, including those for sensitive eyes and those with waterproof formulas for all-day wear.

  2. Rimmel: Offering an excellent variety of shades and formulas, Rimmel mascaras are designed to last all day without smudging or smearing. 5) Wet n Wild: Known for their low-cost, high-quality mascaras, Wet n Wild provides a range of options for those looking for dramatic and affordable eyelashes. 6) Milani: A more affordable luxury brand, Milani offers mascaras with a smooth application and long-lasting formula, making them a popular choice for those seeking a professional look.

As an Amazon Affiliate, we earn through qualified purchases at no cost to you!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment