Created
July 26, 2017 21:47
-
-
Save jbarnett-r7/1b8fdbd1fc9b4b3def7f08456deddd22 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Windows Inspec Test Results - First Run
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Profile: tests from 7zip.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;41m ✔ 7zip: Check 7zip[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\ProgramData\chocolatey\bin\7z.exe should exist[0m | |
Profile: tests from apache_struts.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;208m ∅ apache-struts: Check if apache struts is running (3 failed 1 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\Program Files\Apache Software Foundation\tomcat\apache-tomcat-8.5.12\conf\tomcat-users.xml should exist | |
expected File C:\Program Files\Apache Software Foundation\tomcat\apache-tomcat-8.5.12\conf\tomcat-users.xml to exist[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\Program Files\Apache Software Foundation\tomcat\apache-tomcat-8.5.12\conf\server.xml should exist | |
expected File C:\Program Files\Apache Software Foundation\tomcat\apache-tomcat-8.5.12\conf\server.xml to exist[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\Program Files\Apache Software Foundation\tomcat\apache-tomcat-8.5.12\webapps\struts2-rest-showcase.war should exist | |
expected File C:\Program Files\Apache Software Foundation\tomcat\apache-tomcat-8.5.12\webapps\struts2-rest-showcase.war to exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from axis2.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;208m ∅ axis2: Axis 2 (1 failed 1 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\axis2 should not exist[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\Program Files\Apache Software Foundation\tomcat\apache-tomcat-8.5.12\webapps\axis2 should exist | |
expected File C:\Program Files\Apache Software Foundation\tomcat\apache-tomcat-8.5.12\webapps\axis2 to exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from backdoors.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;208m ∅ backdoors: Backdoors (1 failed)[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\caidao.asp should exist | |
expected File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\caidao.asp to exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\wamp\www\mma.php should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\wamp\www\meterpreter.php should exist[0m | |
Profile: tests from boxstarter.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;41m ✔ boxstarter: Check BoxStarter[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Users\vagrant\AppData\Roaming\Boxstarter should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Users\vagrant\AppData\Roaming\Boxstarter\BoxstarterShell.ps1 should exist[0m | |
Profile: tests from choco.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;41m ✔ choco: Check chocolatey[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command choco --version exit_status should eq 0[0m | |
Profile: tests from create_users.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ check-accounts: Check user accounts (18 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `user` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ reg-user-add: Check user registry entries[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `registry_key` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from devkit.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ devkit: Rails Server - DevKit (1 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\Rails_Server should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\Rails_Server\devkit should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from disable_auto_logon.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;41m ✔ disable-auto-logon: Disable Auto Logon[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command reg query "HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows NT\CurrentVersion\Winlogon" /v AutoAdminLogon stdout should match "AutoAdminLogon REG_SZ 0"[0m | |
Profile: tests from disable_firewall.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;208m ∅ disable-firewall: Diable firewall (expected "\r\nDomain Profile Settings: \r\n-------------------------------------------------------------------...----------------------------------------\r\nState ON\r\nOk.\r\n\r\n" not to match "ON" | |
Diff: | |
@@ -1,2 +1,15 @@ | |
-ON | |
+ | |
+Domain Profile Settings: | |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------- | |
+State ON | |
+ | |
+Private Profile Settings: | |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------- | |
+State ON | |
+ | |
+Public Profile Settings: | |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------- | |
+State ON | |
+Ok. | |
+ | |
)[0m | |
[38;5;208m × Command netsh advfirewall show allprofiles state stdout should not match "ON" | |
expected "\r\nDomain Profile Settings: \r\n-------------------------------------------------------------------...----------------------------------------\r\nState ON\r\nOk.\r\n\r\n" not to match "ON" | |
Diff: | |
@@ -1,2 +1,15 @@ | |
-ON | |
+ | |
+Domain Profile Settings: | |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------- | |
+State ON | |
+ | |
+Private Profile Settings: | |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------- | |
+State ON | |
+ | |
+Public Profile Settings: | |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------- | |
+State ON | |
+Ok. | |
+ | |
[0m | |
Profile: tests from elasticsearch.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ elasticsearch: ElasticSearch (2 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\elasticsearch-1.1.1 should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from enable_rdp.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ enable-rdp: Enable RDP (2 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 3389" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `registry_key` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from firewall.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;41m ✔ firewall: Configure Firewall[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 8484 for Jenkins" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 8282 for Apache Struts" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 80 for IIS" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 4848 for GlassFish" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 8080 for GlassFish" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 8585 for Wordpress and phpMyAdmin" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Java 1.6 java.exe" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 3000 for Rails Server" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 8020 for ManageEngine Desktop Central" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 8383 for ManageEngine Desktop Central" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 8022 for ManageEngine Desktop Central" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 9200 for ElasticSearch" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Open Port 161 for SNMP" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Closed port 445 for SMB" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Closed port 139 for NetBIOS" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Closed port 135 for NetBIOS" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Closed Port 3389 for Remote Desktop" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command netsh advfirewall firewall show rule name="Closed Port 3306 for MySQL" stdout should match "Enabled: Yes"[0m | |
Profile: tests from flag_check.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;208m ∅ flags-check: Check flag locations (4 failed)[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\six_of_diamonds.zip should exist | |
expected File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\six_of_diamonds.zip to exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\WINDOWS\System32\jack_of_clubs.png should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Windows\three_of_spades.png should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Windows\System32\kingofclubs.exe should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Users\Public\Music\four_of_clubs.wav should exist[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\index.html should exist | |
expected File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\index.html to exist[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\hahaha.jpg should exist | |
expected File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\hahaha.jpg to exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\iisstart.htm should not exist[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\seven_of_hearts.html should exist | |
expected File C:\inetpub\wwwroot\seven_of_hearts.html to exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Users\Public\Documents\jack_of_hearts.docx should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Users\Public\Documents\seven_of_spades.pdf should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Users\Public\Pictures\ace_of_hearts.jpg should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Users\Public\Pictures\ten_of_diamonds.png should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\jack_of_diamonds.png should exist[0m | |
Profile: tests from ftp_site.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ setup-ftp-site: Setup FTP Site (1 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Windows\System32\inetsrv\config\applicationHost.config should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from glassfish.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ glassfish: Check GlassFish (4 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\glassfish should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\glassfish\glassfish4\glassfish\domains\domain1\config\admin-keyfile should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\glassfish\glassfish4\glassfish\domains\domain1\config\domain.xml should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from iis.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ iis: IIS HTTP[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from java.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;208m ∅ java: Check Java installation (2 failed)[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\Program Files\Java\jre1.8.0_131\bin\java.exe should exist | |
expected File C:\Program Files\Java\jre1.8.0_131\bin\java.exe to exist[0m | |
[38;5;208m × File C:\Program Files\Java\jdk1.8.0_131\bin\java.exe should exist | |
expected File C:\Program Files\Java\jdk1.8.0_131\bin\java.exe to exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command java -showversion exit_status should eq 1[0m | |
Profile: tests from jenkins.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ jenkins: Check jenkins (2 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\jenkins should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\jenkins\jenkins.war should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\jenkins\jenkins.exe should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from jmx.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ jmx: Check JMX installation (2 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\jmx should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\jmx\Hello.class should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\jmx\HelloMBean.class should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\jmx\SimpleAgent.class should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\jmx\jmx.exe should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\jmx\start_jmx.bat should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from manageengine.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ manageengine: ManageEngine (4 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from mysql.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ mysql: MySQL (2 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from openjdk6.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;208m ∅ openjdk6: Check OpenJDK 6 (1 failed)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\openjdk6\openjdk-1.6.0-unofficial-b27-windows-amd64 should exist[0m | |
[38;5;208m × Command C:\openjdk6\openjdk-1.6.0-unofficial-b27-windows-amd64\jre\bin\java.exe -version stdout should match "openjdk version \"1.6.0-unofficial\"" | |
expected "" to match "openjdk version \"1.6.0-unofficial\""[0m | |
Profile: tests from password_settings.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;41m ✔ password-settings: Password settings[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command secedit /analyze /db %windir%\securitynew.sdb /cfg C:\vagrant\resources\security_settings\secconfig.cfg /areas SECURITYPOLICY exit_status should eq 1[0m | |
Profile: tests from psexec.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ psexec: PxExec (2 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from rails_service.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ rails_service: Rails Service (2 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\Rails_Server\Gemfile should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\Rails_Server\start_rails_server.bat should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `windows_task` resource is not supported on your OS.[0m | |
Profile: tests from ruby.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;41m ✔ ruby: Ruby[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\tools\ruby23 should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ Command ruby -v exit_status should eq 0[0m | |
Profile: tests from snmp.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ snmp: Setup SNMP (3 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `registry_key` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `registry_key` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from tomcat.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ tomcat: Check tomcat installation (2 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\Apache Software Foundation\tomcat should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from wamp.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ wamp: Check WAMP installation (4 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\wamp\bin\apache\Apache2.2.21\conf\httpd.conf should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\wamp\alias\phpmyadmin.conf should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from webdav.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ webdav: WebDAV (2 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\wamp\www\uploads should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\wamp\alias\httpd-dav.conf should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `service` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from winrm.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ winrm: WinRM[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile: tests from wordpress.rb | |
Version: (not specified) | |
Target: ssh://vagrant@192.168.1.117:22 | |
[38;5;247m ↺ wordpress: Check WordPress Installation (1 skipped)[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\wordpress should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\Program Files\wordpress\update_ip.ps1 should exist[0m | |
[38;5;41m ✔ File C:\wamp\www\wordpress should exist[0m | |
[38;5;247m ↺ The `port` resource is not supported on your OS yet.[0m | |
Profile Summary: [38;5;41m7 successful[0m, [38;5;9m7 failures[0m, [38;5;247m20 skipped[0m | |
Test Summary: [38;5;41m68 successful[0m, [38;5;9m13 failures[0m, [38;5;247m59 skipped[0m |
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment