$$$$. Steak House. where we went on our wedding night. On resy, but hard to get into. Could try emailing contact@nycprimerib.com.
$$$$. Traditional Italian. Expensive but really good. I'm sure we've talked about it. Also hard to get into but worth it if you can.
$$. Italian / American (lots of options). Chef Danny Kluger. Haven't been yet but sounds good.
$$$. Good italian, haven't been yet but highly recommended by our former culinary director.
$$. Italian. Also a former culinary director pick, and looks great on foursquare.
$$. Really nice little wine bar across the st from Lederhosen. Might be a good before or after dinner spot, not much food.