BZ: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1784165
I publish a Content View (pulp 2 repository) and use conservative dependency solving. The content view has this repo synced https://inecas.fedorapeople.org/fakerepos/zoo3 and we are trying to filter out specific walrus versions
The metadata from https://inecas.fedorapeople.org/fakerepos/zoo/repodata/be20ece13e6c21b132667ddcaa4d7ad0b32e470b9917aba51979e0707116280d-primary.xml.gz shows that chimpanzee requires walrus (see under rpm:requires) and it doesn't have a specific version requirement.
In satellite 6.6:
I can filter both walrus 0.71 and walrus 5.21 and they will stay filtered even with dependency solving turned on, since only one is needed to fufill the dependency
versions in 6.6:
[vagrant@sat-6-6-qa-rhel7 ~]$ rpm -qa | grep pulp-server
pulp-server-2.19.1.1-1.el7sat.noarch
[vagrant@sat-6-6-qa-rhel7 ~]$ rpm -qa | grep pulp-rpm
python-pulp-rpm-common-2.19.1.1-2.el7sat.noarch
pulp-rpm-plugins-2.19.1.1-2.el7sat.noarch
In upstream and 6.7 builds:
When "walrus-5.21" is filtered, "walrus-5.21" is pulled in, despite "walrus-0.71" existing in the content view. "walrus-0.71" should have been enough to fill the requirement.
However, when "walrus-0.71" is filtered, it stays filtered. So it appears that the latest version of the required package is pulled into the content view despite using conservative dep solving
The API calls to pulp show 'recursive_conservative' still being passed:
2020-01-10T15:09:49 [D|kat|aa52bf7e] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-cv2-v4_0-54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331","criteria":{"type_ids":["rpm"],"filters":{"unit":{"$and":[{"is_modular":false},{"filename":{"$exists":true}}]}},"fields":{"unit":["name","epoch","version","release","arch","checksumtype","checksum"]}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservative":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T15:09:49 [D|kat|aa52bf7e] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-cv2-v4_0-54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331","criteria":{"type_ids":["modulemd"],"filters":{}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservative":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T15:13:06 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-cv2-v5_0-54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331","criteria":{"type_ids":["rpm"],"filters":{"unit":{"$and":[{"is_modular":false},{"filename":{"$exists":true}}]}},"fields":{"unit":["name","epoch","version","release","arch","checksumtype","checksum"]}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservative":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T15:31:09 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-cv2-v5_0-54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331","criteria":{"type_ids":["rpm"],"filters":{"unit":{"$and":[{"is_modular":false},{"filename":{"$exists":true}}]}},"fields":{"unit":["name","epoch","version","release","arch","checksumtype","checksum"]}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservative":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T15:31:09 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-cv2-v5_0-54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331","criteria":{"type_ids":["modulemd"],"filters":{}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservative":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T15:33:20 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-cv2-v6_0-54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331","criteria":{"type_ids":["rpm"],"filters":{"unit":{"$and":[{"is_modular":false},{"filename":{"$exists":true}}]}},"fields":{"unit":["name","epoch","version","release","arch","checksumtype","checksum"]}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservative":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T15:33:20 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-cv2-v6_0-54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"54477311-33ef-4ae4-8fd8-ffb684dcc331","criteria":{"type_ids":["modulemd"],"filters":{}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservative":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
versions used in upstream:
[vagrant@centos7-katello-devel-stable foreman{develop}]$ rpm -qa | grep pulp-server
pulp-server-2.21.0-1.el7.noarch
[vagrant@centos7-katello-devel-stable foreman{develop}]$ rpm -qa | grep pulp-rpm
pulp-rpm-plugins-2.21.0-1.el7.noarch
python-pulp-rpm-common-2.21.0-1.el7.noarch
pulp-rpm-admin-extensions-2.21.0-1.el7.noarch
Some more detailed logs:
Filtering walrus-0.71 (is successfully filtered)
[vagrant@centos7-katello-devel-stable foreman{develop}]$ tail -n 1000 log/development.log | grep associate
2020-01-10T17:59:05 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v3_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source
_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["rpm"],"filters":{"unit":{"$and":[{"is_modular":false},{"$and":[{"filename":{"$exists":true}},{"$nor":[{"$or":[{"
filename":{"$in":["walrus-0.71-1.noarch.rpm"]}}]}]}]}]}},"fields":{"unit":["name","epoch","version","release","arch","checksumtype","checksum"]}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservati
ve":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T17:59:05 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v3_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/unassociate/: {"crit
eria":{"type_ids":["rpm"],"filters":{"unit":{"filters":{"unit":{"$and":[{"is_modular":false},{"$or":[{"filename":{"$in":["walrus-0.71-1.noarch.rpm"]}}]}]}}}}}}: {"content_type"=>"applica
tion/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T17:59:05 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v3_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source
_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["modulemd"],"filters":{}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservative":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_typ
e"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T17:59:05 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v3_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source
_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["srpm"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T17:59:05 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v3_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source
_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["erratum"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T17:59:05 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v3_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source
_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["package_group"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T17:59:05 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v3_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source
_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["package_environment"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T17:59:05 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v3_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source
_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["yum_repo_metadata_file"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T17:59:06 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v3_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source
_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["distribution"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T17:59:06 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v3_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source
_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["modulemd_defaults"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
Filtering walrus-5.21 (is not filtered)
2020-01-10T18:01:45 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v4_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["rpm"],"filters":{"unit":{"$and":[{"is_modular":false},{"$and":[{"filename":{"$exists":true}},{"$nor":[{"$or":[{"filename":{"$in":["walrus-5.21-1.noarch.rpm"]}}]}]}]}]}},"fields":{"unit":["name","epoch","version","release","arch","checksumtype","checksum"]}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservative":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T18:01:45 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v4_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/unassociate/: {"criteria":{"type_ids":["rpm"],"filters":{"unit":{"filters":{"unit":{"$and":[{"is_modular":false},{"$or":[{"filename":{"$in":["walrus-5.21-1.noarch.rpm"]}}]}]}}}}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T18:01:45 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v4_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["modulemd"],"filters":{}},"override_config":{"recursive_conservative":true,"additional_repos":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T18:01:45 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v4_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["srpm"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T18:01:45 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v4_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["erratum"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T18:01:45 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v4_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["package_group"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T18:01:45 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v4_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["package_environment"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T18:01:45 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v4_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["yum_repo_metadata_file"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T18:01:46 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v4_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["distribution"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}
2020-01-10T18:01:46 [D|kat|] POST: https://centos7-katello-devel-stable.example.com/pulp/api/v2/repositories/1-zoo3-v4_0-77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556/actions/associate/: {"source_repo_id":"77a3e7f8-9c55-4799-9580-df8583d3d556","criteria":{"type_ids":["modulemd_defaults"],"filters":{}}}: {"content_type"=>"application/json", "accept"=>"application/json"}