BEWARE SPOILERS
This is for people re-watching the series.
Drink when:
- Electronics flicker
- Any reference to Sam's size
- You can read the Impala's license plate
- A hot chick dies
- They use fake IDs
- Bones are burned, demons are exorcised, monsters are ganked, angels are... angel-sworded (or exploded)
- Someone gets supernaturally pinned to a wall
- Any reference to Dean being, um, "inappropriately", um, "involved" with Sam or Castiel, if you know what I mean
- Sam gets to drive
- The brothers say the same thing at the same time
- We get Sam or Dean tears (falling, not just watery-eyed) -- double-down
- Someone says "the lore says..."
- Blood spatters
Dean:
- Says "son of a bitch!"
- Yells "Sam", worriedly
- Calls Sam "Sammy"
- Makes fun of Sam for being a nerd
- Says "Awesome"
- Calls someone a "mook"
- Hits on a girl (triple down if it's in front of her father)
- Does/says something cad-ish or makes a dirty joke / double entendre
- Eats or mentions pie
- Says "come on!"
- Dies (by playing this game you agree to not hold me responsible for any alcohol-related hospital visits while watching "Mystery Spot")
- Explicitly avoids talking about something emotional (usually by turning up the radio)
- Mentions/uses the magic fingers
- Lip syncs
Sam:
- Says "seriously?" or "dude.", yeah, double it for "dude, seriously?"
- Eats/drinks something girly
- Yells "Dean", worriedly
- Has a vision
- Drinks demon blood
- Makes that huffing noise. You know the one, like when Dean says something stupid.
- Dies
- Tries to get Dean to talk about something emotional
- Lies
Bobby:
- Calls someone "idgit"
- Says "Balls!"
- Has to do research for the boys
- Wears a suit
Castiel:
- Doesn't get a cultural reference
- Has a bromantic moment with Dean
Crowley:
- Says anything -- all his lines are drink-worthy
One-offs:
- Talking teddy bear
- Sam loses his shoe