Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@nichtsfrei

nichtsfrei/htawame.md

Last active January 6, 2024 20:25
Show Gist options
  • Save nichtsfrei/3e15e2710f948223ae9abd9c3fbb83e4 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save nichtsfrei/3e15e2710f948223ae9abd9c3fbb83e4 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Download ZIP
Raw
htawame.md

HOW TO ARGUE WITH A MEAT EATER

These notes are from a workshop centered around the insightful book by Ed Winters, titled 'How to Argue with a Meat Eater (and Win Every Time)'.

If you're unfamiliar with Ed Winters, he authored two remarkable books:

  • 'This is Vegan Propaganda' (EAN: 9781473595132)
  • 'How to Argue with a Meat Eater (and Win Every Time)' (EAN: 9781529907001)

He also runs an impressive YouTube channel:

One of the most surprising things he mentioned, at least to me, is that the more meat eaters he debated, the more he understood their perspective, instead of growing angrier about it.

What Can We Do?

Validate Our Feelings and Emotions:

  • Our feelings and emotions are valid and understandable.
  • Acknowledging them is one of the most crucial aspects.
  • This issue is emotional, and we often associate it with the horrific videos and images we've seen of animal suffering.

Look After Ourselves

  • Make time for hobbies, interests, and activities we enjoy outside of veganism.
  • Engage with like-minded individuals.
  • Spend time with loved ones (even if they aren't vegan) without discussing veganism.
  • Practices like mindfulness and meditation can be incredibly beneficial.
  • Self-care is vital; we shouldn't feel guilty for prioritizing our well-being.

Rationalize and Attempt to Understand the Situation

  • Can we obtain a more objective view of the situation?
  • Why is someone behaving in a certain way or saying certain things?

Understanding the Reactions of Others

Understanding why someone behaves a certain way doesn't mean condoning their behavior. By rationalizing and comprehending their beliefs, we can challenge them more effectively.

This approach also helps us not to take things too personally, even with a strong emotional connection.

Food Is More Than Just Nutrient and Calorie Acquisition

  • It's intertwined with culture, tradition, and heritage.
  • Food brings people together and is a central part of celebrations and events.
  • It's tied to identity and our sense of belonging.

People Often Make Decisions Based on Cultural and Social Pressures

  • The fear of ostracization and peer pressure.
  • The normalization of consuming animal products and the comfort in conforming.
  • Biased messaging in the media.
  • The spread of misinformation or a general lack of education about veganism.

Cognitive Imperfections

  • Cognitive Dissonance (The Meat Paradox)
  • Bandwagon Effect
  • The Ostrich Effect
  • Confirmation Bias
  • Status Quo Bias

Tactics and Techniques

Projection Bias:

  • An example is believing we will think, feel, and act the same in the future as we do now.
    • E.g., "My father-in-law never changes."
  • Projection bias includes overestimating how much others agree with us or will react similarly.
  • We might assume our intentions are clear because veganism is crystal clear to us.
    • In a nutshell: Don't assume the best or the worst.

Optics

  • Whether justified or not, vegans often face an optics problem.
    • Stereotypes exist: militant, doctrinal, extreme...
  • By not fulfilling these stereotypes, we instantly challenge people's perceptions of veganism.
    • Build rapport.
  • Different types of activism exist, but in daily conversations, breaking stereotypes can be a simple and effective way to change minds.
    • A win is a more favorable view of veganism.

V.E.G.A.N.

  • V - Validate. Be understanding and validate others' beliefs when appropriate.
  • E - Eloquent. Use deliberate and intentional words, and be mindful of your language.
  • G - Give Attention. Listen attentively to the person you're speaking with.
  • A - Ask Questions. Challenge beliefs and arguments by asking questions.
  • N - Non-verbal Communication. Be conscious of what your body language conveys.

Debate Questions and Strategies:

  • Ask broad questions to establish a basic premise, then highlight contradictions.
    • Is animal cruelty wrong?
    • What does being cruel to an animal look like? Can you give an example?
    • Should we reduce animal suffering and death?
    • Can you be healthy on a plant-based diet?
  • Ask 'why' to delve deeper.
  • Encourage sources and research.
    • Where did you read that? Can you share your information?
  • Define language or ask for specifics.
  • Tailor your approach based on your audience.
  • Use credible sources to support your position.

Find Your Own Voice

  • Discover what feels most authentic to you.
  • Identify effective questions and language for your social circle.
  • Consider what unique perspectives you can offer.

Important Things to Note

  • It's okay not to know everything.
  • It's fine to ask for clarification.
  • Admitting ignorance is acceptable.
  • It's alright to walk away from a conversation.
  • We won't always say or do the right things.

Being an Authentic Vegan Positively Influences Perceptions

Effective communication is a practice. It's about learning and improving over time.

Remember, it's okay to make mistakes. Be patient and kind to yourself.

Don't let the pursuit of perfection hinder progress.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment