Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@paraseba
Created August 24, 2011 03:40
Show Gist options
  • Save paraseba/1167254 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save paraseba/1167254 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Jorge Luis Borges on novice writers (or programmers?)
Look, I mean to say this: When I began writing, I thought that
everything should be defined by the writer. For example, to say
“the moon” was strictly forbidden; that one had to find an
adjective, an epithet for the moon. (Of course, I'm simplifying
things. I know it because many times I have written “la luna,”
but this is a kind of symbol of what I was doing.) Well, I
thought everything had to be defined and that no common turns
of phrase should be used. I would never have said, “So-and-so
came in and sat down,” because that was far too simple and far
too easy. I thought I had to find out some fancy way of saying
it. Now I find out that those things are generally annoyances to
the reader. But I think the whole root of the matter lies in the
fact that when a writer is young he feels somehow that what he
is going to say is rather silly or obvious or commonplace, and
then he tries to hide it under baroque ornament, under words
taken from the seventeenth-century writers; or, if not, and he
sets out to be modern, then he does the contrary: He's inventing
words all the time, or alluding to airplanes, railway trains, or
the telegraph and telephone because he's doing his best to be
modern. Then as time goes on, one feels that one's ideas, good or
bad, should be plainly expressed, because if you have an idea you
must try to get that idea or that feeling or that mood into the
mind of the reader. If, at the same time, you are trying to be,
let's say, Sir Thomas Browne or Ezra Pound, then it can't be done.
So that I think a writer always begins by being too complicated:
He's playing at several games at the same time. He wants to convey
a peculiar mood; at the same time he must be a contemporary and if
not a contemporary, then he's a reactionary and a classic. As to
the vocabulary, the first thing a young writer, at least in this
country, sets out to do is to show his readers that he possesses a
dictionary, that he knows all the synonyms; so we get, for example,
in one line, red, then we get scarlet, then we get other different
words, more or less, for the same color: purple.
@mausch
Copy link

mausch commented Aug 24, 2011

Cortázar: "Descender o bajar, la cuestión es que el personaje se largó escalera abajo y se acabó." (Rayuela) :-)

Copy link

ghost commented Aug 24, 2011

Yep. Same goes for music. When I began playing I thought notes / minute was the most important thing.

It was much later that I understood B.B. King, for instance; who can say A LOT with just a single note.

BTW, Borges is a perfect writer for programmers. Full of paradoxes.

@paraseba
Copy link
Author

@marcioendo Oh, I wish I understood BBK.
If you're into sciences/technology and haven't read JLB, you're loosing big moments of placer. Cortázar is great too.

@paraseba
Copy link
Author

@mausch Qué buena página! Me preparo para leerla más tranquilo esta noche, Readability en mano. Rayuela es un libro que por algún motivo nunca me sedujo, talvez por los malabares, o no sé por qué. Talvez esto elimine mi prejuicio.

@mausch
Copy link

mausch commented Aug 24, 2011

@paraseba A mí por el contrario, nunca me atrajo del todo Borges. Pero uno cambia con los años, y creo que es momento de que lo relea...

@paraseba
Copy link
Author

@mausch Borges es poco atractivo por alguna de sus ideas, sobre todo políticas y sociales. Pero su literatura y su genio, al menos para mí, están muy por encima de esas ideas.

Esto ya parece un chat...

Copy link

ghost commented Aug 24, 2011

I read JLB during my college years. The Aleph and The Book of Sand.

Though I should probably re-read them. I don't remember much. Only this:

'all beings are immortal because they don't think about death, except the human being. the real thing is to know you ARE immortal'

or something among those lines...

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment