Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@reviewthebest
Created July 28, 2024 04:28
Show Gist options
  • Save reviewthebest/5f6701926488ce366e07ec25a4ebc5f5 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save reviewthebest/5f6701926488ce366e07ec25a4ebc5f5 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Savor the Flavor - 15 Best Cherries for Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts
title
Savor the Flavor - 15 Best Cherries for Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts

Savor the Flavor: 15 Best Cherries for Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts

Cherries-For-Old-Fashioned-1

Welcome to our roundup of the best cherries for creating the perfect Old Fashioned cocktail. Whether you're a seasoned mixologist or new to the cocktail scene, you'll find a cherry to suit your taste buds in this list. So put on your shaking shoes and dive in!

As an Amazon Associate I may earn from qualified purchases at no cost to you!

Reviews

great-value-cherries-premium-cocktail-11-oz-1

As a cocktail enthusiast, I recently tried the Great Value Premium Cocktail Cherries. The moment I opened the jar, I was hit with a burst of cherry aroma from these dark, ruby-like cherries. The texture of the syrup was velvety, and it coated each cherry perfectly. The taste was a delightful balance of sweetness, tartness, and a hint of nuttiness.

What stood out to me was the affordability of this product while still delivering top-notch quality. It's perfect for hosting events or just enjoying a relaxing drink at home. The jar itself is made of a sturdy material, making it ideal for storing and serving the cherries.

However, one downside is that the packaging doesn't specify the size of the cherries, which could be helpful for those who prefer larger or smaller cherries for their cocktails. Despite this minor issue, the Great Value Premium Cocktail Cherries are a fantastic addition to any cocktail lover's bar, providing both flavor and value.

luxardo-the-original-maraschino-cherries-1

Indulge in the delightful taste of Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries, hailed as the best cocktail cherries on the market. With a large 6.6 pound commercial-sized can, you'll have ample cherries to craft the perfect cocktail. These exceptional candied cherries are an exclusive Italian import, bringing you the rich and unbeatable flavor only Luxardo can offer.

A unique blend of 50% candied cherries and 50% Marasca syrup, these cherries are gluten-free, non-GMO, and certified vegan and kosher. Use them in cocktails, desserts, and baking for an authentic, gourmet touch to your recipes. And if you really care about your cocktails, you've got to try these authentic Italian cherries.

Made from natural ingredients, without any thickening agents or preservatives, Luxardo cherries have a shelf life of up to 3 years. This can contains approximately 480 cherries, making it a great value for your money. In addition, 12-lb cans are also available for those who love to stock up, offering around 890 cherries.

In summary, Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries offer a rich, authentic Italian flavor and a luxurious touch to your cocktails and desserts. With a long shelf life and a variety of size options, these cherries are a must-have for anyone who appreciates superior quality and exceptional taste.

luxardo-gourmet-maraschino-cocktail-cherries-400g-jar-1

I have been incorporating Luxardo Maraschino Cherries into my cocktail recipes for quite some time now, and I can confidently say that they have earned a well-deserved spot in my bartending arsenal. The first thing that struck me about these cherries was their luscious, plump, and juicy texture, which adds an enticing fresh fruitiness to any beverage it touches. Furthermore, the fact that they come pre-pitted has been a significant convenience, as it not only saves me time but also makes the preparation process a breeze.

One aspect that sets these cherries apart from others in the market is their distinct candying process that uses Marasca syrup. This unique method imparts a captivating flavor to the cherries that is rarely found in other brands. Moreover, their environmentally-friendly production is a testament to Luxardo's commitment to preserving the environment, making them an ideal choice for my eco-conscious lifestyle. Additionally, the elegant glass jar they come in not only preserves their freshness but also adds a touch of class to any bar display.

The only drawback I've discovered is their price, which is undoubtedly on the higher side compared to other cocktail cherries. However, based on my experience, the adage "you get what you pay for" certainly applies to these cherries. Their exceptional taste and premium quality are evident, making them a worthwhile investment despite their higher price point.

In conclusion, Luxardo Maraschino Cherries are the epitome of elegance and sophistication for those who appreciate the finer things in life. The combination of their delectable flavor and distinctive candying process sets them apart from their competitors. Although they may be a bit pricey, their unparalleled taste and quality make them an investment well worth making.

traverse-city-whiskey-co-cocktail-cherries-premium-450-g-1

When I first heard about these Traverse City Whiskey Co. Cocktail Cherries, my initial thought was that they'd be too sweet or too tart for my palate. I'm glad to say I was wrong. Their handmade, not-too-sweet-not-too-tart flavor makes them a perfect companion to a glass of whiskey. And as someone who enjoys eating cherries straight from the jar, I appreciate their premium quality.

Made from slow cooked balaton cherries, these cherries are grown in northern Michigan and handmade in Traverse City. The texture is thick and syrupy, making them stand out from other cherries. I've found myself reaching for these cherries instead of the traditional ice cubes in my whiskey cocktails, and I'm a big fan of that addition.

While I enjoy the cherries in combination with whiskey, I also appreciate that they're versatile. I've tried them as a snack and have enjoyed them just as much. With no high fructose corn syrup, hydrogenated fats, or synthetic compounds, these cherries are a delicious addition to any cocktail or dessert.

cherry-republic-craft-cocktail-cherries-9-oz-jar-1

Looking to add some flair to your favorite cocktails? Cherry Republic's Craft Cocktail Cherries are just the ticket. These plump, juicy cherries are sourced from the finest cherry-growing region in the world, on the east shore of Lake Michigan, and have been meticulously cultivated to perfection.

Soaked in pure sugar and spices, these cherries add an unforgettable flavor to your drinks that will stand out from the ordinary. Their blend of sweet and tart ensures that each cherry is perfectly balanced, making them a delightful addition to any cocktail.

For those with a sweet tooth, these cherries also make for a delightful dessert topper. With their luxurious taste and elegant presentation, Cherry Republic's Craft Cocktail Cherries will impress your guests and elevate your cocktail game to new heights. Enjoy them in your Old Fashioned, Manhattan, or any other cocktail you fancy, and let the good times roll!

bourbon-country-cherries-1

I recently tried some Bourbon Country Cherries and they were quite the treat. The vibrant red color of the cherries certainly caught my attention, but it was the bold, maraschino flavor that truly won me over. Flavored with real Kentucky Bourbon, these cherries offer a unique twist on the traditional maraschino cherry.

I found myself reaching for these sweet gems to garnish my cocktails and desserts. The seeds were already removed, making them incredibly convenient to use in my recipes. The only downside was the price point, which seemed a bit high compared to other maraschino cherries on the market. However, the quality and taste were well worth it. Overall, I'd highly recommend these Bourbon Country Cherries for anyone looking to add a touch of luxury to their culinary creations.

yes-cocktail-co-boozy-cherries-1

Take a delectable journey with Yes Cocktail Co's Boozy Cherries, a Bourdeaux-style delight that adds a touch of luxury to your cocktail experience. The rich syrup complements the exceptionally dark cherries, offering a perfect twist for Old Fashioneds and Manhattans.

With its handcrafted, 100% natural origins from California's farmers' markets, you can taste the true love and care that Lauren & Brandon put into creating these cherries. Enjoy them straight out of the jar or as part of your favorite cocktail for an unforgettable taste sensation.

amareisa-fabbri-amarena-wild-cherries-in-syrup-600-g-1

Experience the delight of authentic Italian cuisine with Amarena Wild Cherries in Syrup, now offered in a 600g pack. This versatile dessert topping brings you the rich flavors of Italy, with cherries hailing from the Emilia-Romagna province. The cherries are a deep dark red, offering a sweet yet slightly bitter taste, while the syrup adds a unique depth of flavor.

Perfect for garnishing cocktails or serving with ice cream, these cherries will elevate any dessert or treat. Imported from Italy, the Fabbri family has been crafting these cherries in syrup for generations, using the original recipe from 1905.

The Amarena Wild Cherries in Syrup come well-preserved in a stylish 600g crock, making them the ideal addition to your pantry.

traverse-bay-fruit-dried-cherries-4-lb-1

Traverse Bay Premium Dried Cherries offer a delightful assortment of zesty benefits, with their delicious sweet/tart flavor adding a burst of freshness to various dishes. These cherries are carefully selected from 100% Grade A Tart Montmorency Cherries, ensuring utmost quality and freshness.

One of the standout features includes the inclusion of heart-healthy benefits as part of a well-balanced diet, acting as a fantastic source of vitamin A and antioxidants. Additionally, these cherries provide a cholesterol-free experience with a minimal sodium content.

These dried cherries, despite being sugar-coated, make for a fantastic snack or a versatile addition to various recipes such as salads, trail mix, and decadent desserts. Moreover, they can be baked into muffins, cookies, cakes, or used as a topping for ice cream or cereal.

While this box of cherries might be pricier than most, it makes for a worthwhile investment for those seeking high-quality, nutritious, and versatile ingredients. The four-pound box is also a great asset for foodservice and restaurant use, ensuring amble quantities for everyday activities.

Customers' praises for these dried cherries are abundant, with many applauding the product's taste, texture, and ingredient quality. However, it's also important to note the occasional concerns regarding the higher cost and the presence of some residual sugar. Despite these minor setbacks, many enthusiasts appreciate the overall quality and culinary versatility of Traverse Bay Premium Dried Cherries.

cellar-door-cocktail-cherries-1

Savor the delightful flavors of Michigan-grown Balaton cherries, harvested at their peak season. The Cellar Door Cocktail Cherries are the perfect enhancement to your cocktails, mocktails, and dessert toppings. You'll love the deep cherry taste with a hint of spice, and appreciate the all-natural, dye and preservative-free alternative it offers to maraschino cherries. Additionally, this product is gluten-free, alcohol-free, and free of dairy, grain, and is made in the United States.

Not only are these cherries delicious, but a portion of the proceeds also goes to support Memories From Monroe, a remarkable nonprofit organization that creates memory boxes for families dealing with infant and pregnancy loss in Michigan. With these cherries, you can add a touch of sweetness to your drink, while simultaneously contributing to a good cause.

traverse-city-whiskey-premium-cocktail-cherries-1

Experience the finest cocktail experience with Traverse City Whiskey Co Premium Cocktail Cherries. Handcrafted from locally sourced cherries, these sweet treats are steeped in sugar syrup, providing just the right balance of flavor for your favorite cocktails or an indulgent snack. With only 10 calories each, these premium cherries give your beverages a rich, gourmet touch without the guilt.

Available in a generous 21.2 oz. jar, this tasty treat is a must-have for any mixologist.

Get ready to impress your friends with the perfect garnish for your classic cocktails or enjoy them on their own as a satisfying treat.

peninsula-premium-cocktail-cherries-award-winning-for-1

As the 2019 winner of the esteemed SIP Awards, these deliciously sweet and tangy cherries are the perfect addition to any cocktail or dessert. With their award-winning taste, they can easily elevate your Old Fashioned to the next level. These cherries, proudly made in the USA, boast a smooth, rich flavor that will impress even the most discerning guests.

Despite their premium quality, they are surprisingly easy on the budget. The only drawback might be their relatively small serving size, but with their intense flavor, you'll find that just a few cherries can make a noticeable difference in your drink.

Overall, the Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries offer a luxurious taste experience without breaking the bank.

woodford-reserve-bourbon-cherries-1

Introducing Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries - the perfect addition to your favorite cocktails and more! Aged in authentic oak barrels, these delectable cherries are made from natural ingredients, bringing a touch of Kentucky's finest bourbon to every recipe. Enjoy the sweetness, oaky notes, and unique bourbon flavor in drinks like Old Fashioneds and Manhattans, or elevate salads, marinades, and desserts with these ruby red gems.

With a net weight of 11 oz and a size of 2.8" x 2.8" x 4.5", this treat is not only delicious but also eye-catching. So why settle for regular maraschino cherries when you can enhance your garnish game with Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries?

It's time to upgrade your cocktail game!

traverse-city-whiskey-co-premium-cocktail-cherries-cocktails-desserts-all-american-natural-certified-1

Traverse City Whiskey Co. Premium Cocktail Cherries offer a remarkable garnishing experience for cocktails and desserts. These cherries represent the epitome of elegance and flavor, leaving other brands far behind in taste and texture. Dark, perfectly plump, and stemless, these cherries come with an all-American, natural, and certified kosher syrup, which is thick, rich, and savory.

The Traverse City Whiskey Co. cherries are a genuine delight in cocktails, as they blend well with vermouth and add the perfect bite to a bourbon, especially in a Manhattan. The cherries' delightful taste and the syrup's unbeatable flavor elevate the drinking experience. Go beyond cocktails by using these cherries to top your favorite ice cream or drizzling the syrup on your favorite sundaes. They are an absolute delight as a garnish for cheesecakes, offering an exponentially better option than canned cherry pie filling.

Harvested in Michigan, the Cherry Capital of the World, these cherries come with the authentic taste of seasonal tart cherries. They possess zero artificial colors, making them an authentic and natural choice for food enthusiasts. Traverse City Whiskey Co. cherries are not only a superior garnish, but they also make for an exquisite additive to your favorite cocktails, desserts, and even yogurt and cereal. Try these cherries - a sweet, savory, and sophisticated treat that raises the bar on your culinary creations.

fabbri-amarena-wild-cherry-in-syrup-8-1-oz-jar-1

Fabbri Amarena Wild Cherries in Syrup is a delightful, Italian-imported treat that's been satisfying tastebuds since 1905. As expected from such a long-standing and prestigious family brand, these cherries boast exceptional quality. The luscious wild cherries are combined with glucose syrup, water, and wild cherry juice for an authentic and intensely-flavored experience.

Although the cherries themselves are packed full of flavor, it's the syrup that truly sets them apart. This syrup isn't just a sweet addition to the cherries, but it's packed with the real deal - a tangy, wild cherry essence that brings a true burst of flavor to any dish or drink. It’s versatile enough to add a touch of delight to desserts, mocktails, or even used as a topping for savory dishes.

Reviews rave about these cherries, hailing them as the perfect addition to an Old Fashioned or a cherry-themed cocktail. They're praised for their intensity, texture, and the perfect balance of sweetness and tang. They're even appreciated as an aesthetically-pleasing garnish that elevates the overall presentation of a dish.

Apart from its culinary uses, the Fabbri Amarena Wild Cherries in Syrup jar is quite the showpiece too. Imported from Italy, it's a beautiful, blue-patterned, glass jar that adds style and elegance to your kitchen or bar counter.

Despite the general consensus of happiness among the reviewers, there are a few instances where the product didn't arrive as intended and one user describes the cherry taste as being similar to cough syrup, which seems to be a rather unique and unsatisfactory experience.

Fabbri Amarena Wild Cherries in Syrup, with its gluten-free, non-GMO, and kosher status, ticks all the boxes for a healthy and authentic treat. This versatile, family-made, Italian delight is sure to become a staple in any kitchen for its flavor, texture, and presentation.

Buyer's Guide

Cherries are often used to enhance the flavor profile of Old Fashioned cocktails, adding a sweet, tangy note. When selecting cherries for this purpose, it's essential to consider various factors to ensure you end up with the best quality cherries. This buyer's guide will provide you with crucial information on choosing the right cherries for your Old Fashioned cocktail.

Size of the Cherry

The size of the cherry can significantly impact the visual appeal and overall taste of your cocktail. Larger cherries tend to have a more robust flavor, while smaller cherries may be sweeter and milder. Choose cherries that are plump and well-rounded, ensuring they provide an optimal balance of flavor and texture for your drink.

Sweetness Level

Cherries can vary greatly in sweetness, which is an essential factor to consider when choosing them for your Old Fashioned. Sweeter cherries will add a more pronounced fruity flavor, while less sweet cherries will provide a more subtle taste. Opt for cherries with a moderate sweetness level, ensuring they complement the other ingredients in your cocktail without overpowering them.

Texture and Firmness

The texture and firmness of the cherries can affect their appearance and the mouthfeel of your cocktail. Look for cherries that are firm and have a glossy sheen, indicating freshness. Avoid cherries that are overly soft or mushy, as they may not hold up well in the drink and could alter the texture negatively.

Flavor Profile

When selecting cherries for your Old Fashioned, it's essential to consider their flavor profile. Choose cherries that have a rich, complex character, with a balance of sweetness, tartness, and subtle fruity notes. Avoid cherries with overwhelming flavors, as they may overpower the other ingredients in your cocktail.

FAQ

What types of cherries are used in old fashioned drinks?

Typically, Luxardo cherries or similar maraschino cherries are used in old fashioned drinks. These cherries offer a bold, sweet flavor that complements the bitterness of the whiskey and the aromatic properties of the orange and bitters in the cocktail. Luxardo cherries are known for their bright red color, plump texture, and high-quality taste, making them a popular choice for bartenders and home mixologists.

While there are various brands of maraschino cherries available, Luxardo cherries are the most popular choice for old fashioned cocktails due to their superior quality and unique taste. They can be found at most liquor stores, specialty food shops, or online retailers. It is essential to choose high-quality cherries to enhance the overall experience and flavor profile of this classic cocktail.

What is the origin of maraschino cherries?

Maraschino cherries originated in Italy, specifically in the Marasca region of Dalmatia, where they have been produced since the early 18th century. The sweet cherries are grown in this region and then harvested and processed to create the signature maraschino cherries we know and love today. The cherries are carefully selected, pitted, and preserved in a sugar syrup that gives them their characteristic bright red color and sugary taste.

Over time, the production of maraschino cherries spread to other countries, including the United States. Today, there are numerous brands and varieties of maraschino cherries available worldwide, but the most reputable and widely used are still the ones that hail from Italy's Marasca region. It is crucial to choose high-quality maraschino cherries to ensure the best taste and experience when making old fashioned cocktails.

How do I store maraschino cherries?

Maraschino cherries should be stored in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Since they are preserved in sugar syrup, they do not require refrigeration unless your home has high humidity levels. If you notice mold growth or off odors, it is advisable to discard the cherries and purchase a new bottle. It is essential to protect the cherries from extreme temperature changes, as this can affect their texture and taste. When not in use, store the cherries in an airtight container to prevent them from absorbing other flavors and smells in your pantry or refrigerator.

Additionally, if you plan to use the cherries for several weeks or months, consider transferring them to a freezer-safe container and freezing them. This will extend their shelf life and maintain their quality. Remember to thaw the cherries before using them in cocktails or recipes, as they will become too slushy when frozen.

Can I make maraschino cherries at home?

Although it is possible to make maraschino cherries at home, the process can be quite time-consuming and requires specific ingredients, tools, and expertise. Traditional maraschino cherries are made by infusing sweet cherries with a liquor such as cherry brandy or maraschino liqueur, which adds a distinct flavor and preserves the cherries. The cherries are then pitted, coated with a sugar syrup, and often dyed to achieve the deep red color.

If you are interested in making maraschino cherries at home, there are several recipes available online that can guide you through the process. However, it is essential to use high-quality sweet cherries and follow the recipe carefully to ensure a successful outcome. Alternatively, you can purchase high-quality maraschino cherries from reputable brands to save time and effort, while still enjoying the classic flavor and texture in your old fashioned cocktails.

How do I use maraschino cherries in an old fashioned cocktail?

To use maraschino cherries in an old fashioned cocktail, start by placing one or two cherries in the bottom of a rocks glass. You can then muddle the cherries with a cocktail muddler or the back of a spoon to release their juices and flavor. This will create a cherry-infused syrup that will be mixed with the other ingredients in the cocktail.

Next, add a generous dose of bourbon or whiskey to the glass, along with a splash of bitters and a twist of orange zest. Stir the ingredients well to ensure they are well-combined and the flavors have melded together. Finally, add a large ice cube or a few smaller ones, depending on your preference. Garnish the cocktail with an additional cherry on a cocktail pick, if desired, and enjoy your classic old fashioned cocktail!

Are there any cocktail variations that use cherries in place of maraschino cherries?

While maraschino cherries are the most popular choice for old fashioned cocktails, there are several cocktail variations that use different types of cherries or cherry-flavored ingredients. For example, a Manhattan variation called the "Cherry Manhattan" replaces the traditional cherry garnish with a cherry-infused whiskey or a cherry liqueur. Another variation, the "Amaretto Sour, " features a cherry liqueur as one of its primary ingredients and often serves the drink with a cherry garnish.

Additionally, there are fruit juice-based cocktails that use cherry juice or cherry-flavored syrups as a base or mixer. These cocktails can be refreshing and fruity alternatives to the more classic old fashioned, offering a different taste and experience. If you are looking to explore cherry-based cocktails beyond the traditional old fashioned, consider experimenting with different ingredients and flavor profiles to discover new and exciting combinations. Remember, the key to a great cocktail is always balance, so be sure to adjust the ingredients to suit your taste preferences and enjoy!

As an Amazon Associate I may earn from qualified purchases at no cost to you!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment