Your characters (the Priest, the Mortician, the Criminal, and the Private Eye) are visiting the small, isolated town of Bennington, Vermont. (Sorry, I didn't remember the character names.)
While passing through the area, your characters have become aware of a certain situation which has placed a teenage girl in dire peril. Jane Strong, the daughter of local business magnate Lucas Strong, has been kidnapped and held for ransom. Being compassionate, good men at heart, you've all decided to pitch in and join the posse which will hunt down her kidnappers, the villianous Sidney Harris and his gang.