creativity.clj

(ns tree-search.creativity
  (:require [tree-search.concept-net :as cn]
            [com.rpl.specter :as sp]))

(def creativity
  '{produces [forms {novel? {always    P-creative
                             sometimes H-creative}
                     value? hopefully
                     by     [combining knowledge]}]

    how [interactions {between [[serendipity {requires [[novel encounters]
                                                        [pattern matching - evaluation]]}]
                                [exisiting knowledge {including [[evolved machinery]
                                                                 [what we've been told]
                                                                 [what we've learnt]]}]]}]

    [what is it for?] [[solve new problems {[why not old ones?]
                                            [[perception of C]
                                             [to explain is to explain away]
                                             [any system will become boring
                                              {unless [in new environment
                                                       [-> all the novelty comes from inspiring set]]}]]}]]

    [can be] [transformational {[but not like] [Wiggins {produces Personal-Transformation-Not-H
                                                         not-embeded in-domain
                                                         rerepresentation is-important-though}]}]})


;; FACE

;; A definition should not be circular unless we really are talking about something that really is recursive
;; Framing with Natural Language require Creativity and Empathy


;; Anna's 14 components

;; My BB does not do
;; Social interaction - requires creativity
;; - otherwise is just getting inspiring set
;; - or evaluation measures
;; - or is it doing social interaction at the REPL?

;; The BB enables
;; Intention
;; - Ventura says this is just having a goal?
;;   - But not emotional involvement
;;     - Unless it has emotional experts

;; Thinking and evaluation
;; - A search is thinking
;; - Evaluation can be done by feature extractors

;; Active involvement
;; - Yeah probably
;; - How to evaluate?

;; Variety and divergence
;; - Easy when you don't have a goal

;; Generation of results
;; - Yep

;; Progression and development
;; - We can progress towards a goal
;; - What's development?

;; Independence and freedom
;; - Stochastic search
;; - Ability to change goals

;; General intellect
;; - How do you evaluate that?

;; Spontaneity and subconscious processing
;; - BB and AI search do spontaneity all day
;; - It's all subconscious unless there is panpsychism
;;   - Does subconscious imply unplanned when people talk about it?
;; - What is spontaneity? - How do you evaluate that.

;; Dealing with uncertainty
;; - Experts need to do this
;; - How do you evaluate that?

;; Value
;; - Handled by feature extracting evaluation experts
;; - How do you evaluate that?

;; Originality
;; - If it's lucky

;; Domain competence
;; - Can have it
;; - Machine learned or hand coded





(def concept-net
  (cn/concept "creativity"))