Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@trust1995
trust1995 / Sherlock_Optimism_Rescope_Response.md
Last active April 25, 2024 17:35
Trust's Response to the March 2024 Optimism contest ruling on scope

After a length internal discussion and the announcement of Sherlock/Optimism decision regarding the scoping update, I'm publicizing my critique of the decision which I believe is beyond the threshold of a respectable "wrong call" and in the negligent/malicious territory.

The facts

Key snippets of the contest README (source of truth):

>FaultDisputeGame resolution logic is not included in the scope of this contest. Participants should assume that the FaultDisputeGame can resolve incorrectly (i.e.g, can resolve to DEFENDER_WINS when it should resolve to CHALLENGER_WINS or vice versa). Reports that demonstrate an incorrect resolution of the FaultDisputeGame are appreciated but will not be considered valid rewardable findings for this specific contest. However, there should be no func