Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@achow101
Last active June 13, 2018 00:30
Show Gist options
  • Star 0 You must be signed in to star a gist
  • Fork 0 You must be signed in to fork a gist
  • Save achow101/69b8c592a92ad285c0d832e861e7e14c to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save achow101/69b8c592a92ad285c0d832e861e7e14c to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.

All of the BnB simulation results. Some are right, others are wrong.

Results

All of the valid results for varying fee rate simulations, but readable

Type Fees file Simulation File final value mean #UTXO final #UTXO #received #spent #changes created min change max change mean change stDev of change total fees average fees total cost min input set max input set mean size of input set stdev of input set size BnB Usage
BnB+Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-repeats.csv derived-1I-2O.csv 55.88713405 19.86 17 6097 17913 11833 0.00997809 4.15153434 0.10399897 0.28233767 -0.02520509 -0.00000213 -0.02523025 1 24 1.51 1.04 27/11860
Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-repeats.csv derived-1I-2O.csv 55.88712329 27.51 22 6097 17935 11860 0.00001005 10.30069834 0.29223202 0.72740965 -0.02521585 -0.00000213 -0.02524841 1 21 1.51 1.20 N/A
BnB+Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-cycle.csv derived-1I-2O.csv 55.88713391 22.93 19 6097 17909 11831 0.00998908 9.14499834 0.10465966 0.28952080 -0.02520523 -0.00000213 -0.02523335 0 27 1.51 1.05 28/11860
Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-cycle.csv derived-1I-2O.csv 55.88712420 26.84 23 6097 17934 11860 0.00002034 10.30069834 0.28121957 0.65214921 -0.02521494 -0.00000213 -0.02524898 1 21 1.51 1.17 N/A
BnB+Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-repeats.csv derived-balanced.csv 55.88171750 27.27 21 12194 23840 11667 0.00221449 5.69999834 0.056819638 0.19930147 -0.03062164 -0.00000258 -0.03065272 1 84 2.01 1.83 193/11860
Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-repeats.csv derived-balanced.csv 55.88158139 37.74 29 12194 24025 11860 0.00030847 9.96073034 0.10688567 0.34970815 -0.03075775 -0.00000259 -0.03080067 1 32 2.03 1.74 N/A
BnB+Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-cycle.csv derived-balanced.csv 55.88173059 28.78 20 12194 23831 11657 0.00223019 5.69999834 0.056200963 0.19728515 -0.03060855 -0.00000258 -0.03063815 1 45 2.01 1.72 203/11860
Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-cycle.csv derived-balanced.csv 55.88158048 36.26 28 12194 24026 11860 0.00006546 9.91069834 0.12069723 0.41430597 -0.03075866 -0.00000259 -0.03080010 1 44 2.026 1.84 N/A
BnB+Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-repeats.csv moneypot.csv 55.87130774 131.06 33 24388 35121 10766 0.00005428 4.69999834 0.036069275 0.13266262 -0.04103140 -0.00000346 -0.04108024 1 279 2.96 4.20 1094/11860
Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-repeats.csv moneypot.csv 55.87047548 208.40 29 24388 36214 11855 0.00001333 7.99999834 0.055334876 0.25061846 -0.04186366 -0.00000353 -0.04190658 1 668 3.05 7.05 N/A
BnB+Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-cycle.csv moneypot.csv 55.87119478 64.37 29 24388 35312 10953 0.00015309 4.69999834 0.035168758 0.12918029 -0.04114436 -0.00000347 -0.04118728 1 92 2.98 2.90 907/11860
Core fees-bitcoinfees-info-cycle.csv moneypot.csv 55.87049772 218.06 49 24388 36197 11858 0.00000184 9.20999834 0.046778658 0.22037920 -0.04184142 -0.00000353 -0.04191394 1 338 3.05 5.70 N/A

Derived-1L-2O scenario

BnB+Core are wrong in these results. See the last section for correct results (note not all of the same simulatiosn were re-run).

type parameters final value mean #UTXO final #UTXO #received #spent #changes created min change max change mean change stDev of change total fees average fees fees to spend remaining UTXO total cost min input set max input set mean size of input set stdev of input set size BnB usage
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00001000 55.87655934 26.98596647546917637328078853897750377655029296875 32 6097 17925 11860 0.00001974 10.29131674 0.30048583 0.75408013 -0.03577980 -0.0000030168465 -0.00004736000000000000734363958532213700891588814556598663330078125 −0.03582716 1 24 1.511382799325463821560333599336445331573486328125 1.178462287842233724433071984094567596912384033203125 325/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00001000 55.87654898 28.122459208108256945024550077505409717559814453125 25 6097 17932 11860 0.00011634 10.30079774 0.30304566 0.71006768 -0.03579016 -0.0000030177201 -0.00003700000000000000489018547877861919914721511304378509521484375 −0.03582716 1 20 1.5119730185497470831279542835545726120471954345703125 1.2052006592284258967850973931490443646907806396484375 N/A
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00010000 55.55449734 26.089714317536337517822175868786871433258056640625 28 6097 17928 11859 0.00005561 10.29687740 0.30032770 0.71982810 -0.35784180 -0.000030172159 -0.0000414400000000000030375528481396685265281121246516704559326171875 -0.35788324 1 22 1.5116357504215851559337124854209832847118377685546875 1.19698986751473679390755933127366006374359130859375 644/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00010000 55.55436354 29.10074065823912548012231127358973026275634765625 20 6097 17937 11860 0.00024407 10.06245446 0.30415764 0.71372324 -0.35797560 -0.000030183440 -0.000029600000000000001201642951809134274299140088260173797607421875 -0.35800520 1 38 1.5123946037099493810984540687059052288532257080078125 1.2489705008609279790476875859894789755344390869140625 N/A
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00100000 52.33302714 26.04159937628779886154006817378103733062744140625 23 6097 17934 11860 0.00011400 10.30047400 0.28552710 0.67883573 -3.5793120 -0.00030179696 -0.0000340399999999999993490103211701836016800370998680591583251953125 -3.5793460 1 24 1.512141652613828046725075182621367275714874267578125 1.195222366665799285101456916891038417816162109375 941/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00100000 52.33243514 27.071559837389319369549411931075155735015869140625 19 6097 17938 11860 0.00010535 10.28757400 0.30504525 0.74629238 -3.5799040 -0.00030184688 -0.0000281200000000000018191871620221178318388410843908786773681640625 -3.5799321 1 28 1.51247892074198997391931698075495660305023193359375 1.2096651387256158738381373041193000972270965576171875 N/A
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00500000 38.01520914 24.4216739989976048263997654430568218231201171875 21 6097 17935 11859 0.00014570 10.29057000 0.30445610 0.71189306 -17.897130 -0.0015090329 -0.0000310800000000000005840987415961507167594390921294689178466796875 -17.897161 1 28 1.512225969645868417501333169639110565185546875 1.22346107662681991001818460063077509403228759765625 1616/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00500000 38.01503914 25.713816339032131708108863676898181438446044921875 22 6097 17935 11860 0.00002000 10.10057000 0.30062341 0.74949322 -17.897300 -0.0015090472 -0.0000325600000000000067428181094175698717663181014358997344970703125 -17.897333 1 21 1.512225969645868417501333169639110565185546875 1.1709164727486285340063432158785872161388397216796875 N/A
BnB+Core Repeated Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.88712998 27.311299214790889067216994590125977993011474609375 28 6097 17927 11858 0.00019834 10.26679834 0.29848546 0.70127884 -0.02520916 -0.0000021255616 -0.0000414400000000000030375528481396685265281121246516704559326171875 -0.025250600 0 24 1.5115514333895447851574544984032399952411651611328125 1.201771518003559524601087105111218988895416259765625 344/11860
Core Repeated Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.88712329 27.506097900540179779227401013486087322235107421875 22 6097 17935 11860 0.00001005 10.30069834 0.29223202 0.72740965 -0.02521585 -0.0000021261256 -0.0000325600000000000067428181094175698717663181014358997344970703125 -0.025248410 1 21 1.512225969645868417501333169639110565185546875 1.2032374476285958575516588098253123462200164794921875 N/A
BnB+Core Cyclic Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.88712420 25.80497855989307964819090557284653186798095703125 23 6097 17934 11860 0.00001491 10.29169834 0.30822553 0.72970119 -0.02521494 -0.0000021260489 -0.0000340399999999999993490103211701836016800370998680591583251953125 -0.025248980 1 24 1.512141652613828046725075182621367275714874267578125 1.1820983771402058248867206202703528106212615966796875 199/11860
Core Cyclic Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.88712420 26.8401737483989535348882782272994518280029296875 23 6097 17934 11860 0.00002034 10.30069834 0.28121957 0.65214921 -0.02521494 -0.0000021260489 -0.0000340399999999999993490103211701836016800370998680591583251953125 -0.025248980 1 21 1.512141652613828046725075182621367275714874267578125 1.1730758242556362791475521589745767414569854736328125 N/A

derived-balanced.csv

BnB+Core are wrong in these results. See the last section for correct results (note not all of the same simulatiosn were re-run).

type parameters final value mean #UTXO final #UTXO #received #spent #changes created min change max change mean change stDev of change total fees average fees fees to spend remaining UTXO total cost min input set max input set mean size of input set stdev of input set size BnB usage
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00001000 55.86752542 35.59017211274632330741951591335237026214599609375 29 12194 24022 11857 0.00000215 9.71099774 0.10588343 0.35890007 -0.04481372 -0.0000037785599 -0.0000429200000000000091962722159610876815349911339581012725830078125 -0.044856640 1 66 2.025463743676222616585391733678989112377166748046875 1.88707038897768342167182709090411663055419921875 923/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00001000 55.86752212 39.19668246445497317154149641282856464385986328125 27 12194 24026 11859 0.00002149 8.74523932 0.10870898 0.36959846 -0.04481702 -0.0000037788381 -0.000039960000000000003655097058352652084067813120782375335693359375 -0.044856980 1 51 2.0258010118043845437796335318125784397125244140625 1.8630510400609858745468727647676132619380950927734375 N/A
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00010000 55.46426454 35.07499792134364469120555440895259380340576171875 28 12194 24025 11859 0.00002982 8.74521898 0.10850152 0.36248967 -0.44807460 -0.000037780320 -0.0000414400000000000030375528481396685265281121246516704559326171875 -0.44811604 1 35 2.025716694772344173003375544794835150241851806640625 1.740747319921828850652900655404664576053619384765625 1643/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00010000 55.46419054 35.0832294005155063132406212389469146728515625 23 12194 24030 11859 0.00003200 9.91097740 0.11858778 0.38233123 -0.44814860 -0.000037786560 -0.0000340399999999999993490103211701836016800370998680591583251953125 -0.44818264 1 38 2.026138279932546470973875329946167767047882080078125 1.842291519120082821103778769611380994319915771484375 N/A
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00100000 51.43235175 35.5221169036334885049654985778033733367919921875 31 12194 24020 11857 0.00004084 9.27206431 0.11038883 0.36045124 -4.4799874 -0.00037773924 -0.000045880000000000001184920217500717853909009136259555816650390625 -4.4800333 1 38 2.025295109612141430943665909580886363983154296875 1.7907297866116194118291105041862465441226959228515625 2134/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00100000 51.43111514 37.87802444499875065275773522444069385528564453125 26 12194 24028 11860 0.00012800 9.70077400 0.11358164 0.40684568 -4.4812240 -0.00037784351 -0.00003847999999999999749637769053123292906093411147594451904296875 -4.4812625 1 33 2.02596964586846528533214950584806501865386962890625 1.7820345960584622613254168754792772233486175537109375 N/A
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00500000 33.50870001 36.51820902968321291837128228507936000823974609375 21 12194 24026 11853 0.00002322 9.98787000 0.14353057 0.48030423 -22.403639 -0.0018890083 -0.0000310800000000000005840987415961507167594390921294689178466796875 -22.403670 1 53 2.0258010118043845437796335318125784397125244140625 1.91765082261940023045099223963916301727294921875 2713/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00500000 35.10512145 40.9802935184800247725434019230306148529052734375 21 12194 24030 11857 0.00006718 8.81134658 0.13437727 0.44562374 -22.407218 -0.0018894694 -0.0000310800000000000005840987415961507167594390921294689178466796875 -22.407249 1 80 2.026309132304578763950075881439261138439178466796875 1.9456650214443909074901739586493931710720062255859375 N/A
BnB+Core Repeated Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.88157487 35.741664588010308989396435208618640899658203125 30 12194 24023 11859 0.00000275 9.98089834 0.10155991 0.34103056 -0.03076427 -0.0000025939519 -0.0000444000000000000018024644277137014114487101323902606964111328125 -0.030808670 1 34 2.02554806070826298736164972069673240184783935546875 1.7797442458699201939253953241859562695026397705078125 794/11860
Core Repeated Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.88158139 37.7370915440259437900749617256224155426025390625 29 12194 24025 11860 0.00030847 9.96073034 0.10688567 0.34970815 -0.03075775 -0.0000025934022 -0.0000429200000000000091962722159610876815349911339581012725830078125 -0.030800670 1 32 2.025716694772344173003375544794835150241851806640625 1.7385175900032934226402403510292060673236846923828125 N/A
BnB+Core Cyclic Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.88157262 36.30227820736676136448295437730848789215087890625 27 12194 24024 11857 0.00001834 9.30095665 0.10794268 0.37209381 -0.03076652 -0.0000025941417 -0.000039960000000000003655097058352652084067813120782375335693359375 -0.030806480 0 35 2.025632377740303358137907707714475691318511962890625 1.7570214448414578356505444389767944812774658203125 833/11860
Core Cyclic Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.88158048 36.26091294587178737174326670356094837188720703125 28 12194 24026 11860 0.00006546 9.91069834 0.12069723 0.41430597 -0.03075866 -0.0000025934789 -0.0000414400000000000030375528481396685265281121246516704559326171875 -0.030800100 1 44 2.0258010118043845437796335318125784397125244140625 1.8367955156429862650924178524292074143886566162109375 N/A

moneypot.csv

BnB+Core are wrong in these results. See the last section for correct results (note not all of the same simulatiosn were re-run).

type parameters final value mean #UTXO final #UTXO #received #spent #changes created min change max change mean change stDev of change total fees average fees fees to spend remaining UTXO total cost min input set max input set mean size of input set stdev of input set size BnB usage
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00001000 55.84951848 153.250165526373876900834147818386554718017578125 47 24388 36196 11855 0.00000262 4.99989478 0.045543204 0.21246908 -0.06282066 -0.0000052968516 -0.00006956000000000000485674001016178635836695320904254913330078125 -0.062890220 1 188 3.051939291736931014753508861758746206760406494140625 3.731750776560500693079802658758126199245452880859375 2627/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00001000 55.84950297 208.239654601633191077780793420970439910888671875 49 24388 36190 11851 0.00000275 8.80499774 0.052897153 0.26685217 -0.06283617 -0.0000052981594 -0.000072520000000000003621651589735819243287551216781139373779296875 -0.062908690 1 400 3.051433389544687901917541239527054131031036376953125 5.65198237497643418691950500942766666412353515625 N/A
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00010000 55.28410854 147.34928823659237195897730998694896697998046875 37 24388 36195 11844 0.00002542 5.64857740 0.047474642 0.20586621 -0.62823060 -0.000052970540 -0.0000547600000000000042559185342572192212173831649124622344970703125 -0.62828536 1 182 3.051854974704890199888041024678386747837066650390625 3.549240546499367265909086199826560914516448974609375 3713/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00010000 55.28405942 106.5413815934672214780221111141145229339599609375 43 24388 36197 11852 0.00002260 9.20997740 0.055779091 0.26602465 -0.62827972 -0.000052974681 -0.00006364000000000000732691685101372058852575719356536865234375 -0.62834336 1 92 3.0520236087689713855297668487764894962310791015625 3.277647281760728059651910371030680835247039794921875 N/A
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00100000 49.63267114 92.6900518649304814289280329830944538116455078125 34 24388 36186 11832 0.00002600 5.64837400 0.053024521 0.21690243 -6.2796680 -0.00052948297 -0.000050320000000000006108551164896169893836486153304576873779296875 -6.2797183 1 94 3.0510961214165259747232994413934648036956787109375 3.337635756349500493200821438222192227840423583984375 4111/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00100000 49.63307290 146.35864047671594789790106005966663360595703125 50 24388 36180 11842 0.00002325 9.50585100 0.069900583 0.29034538 -6.2792663 -0.00052944910 -0.0000740000000000000097803709575572383982944302260875701904296875 -6.2793403 1 286 3.050590219224283305976541669224388897418975830078125 4.2989677473115310846196734928525984287261962890625 N/A
BnB+Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00500000 25.79221870 86.052558973651542828520177863538265228271484375 22 24388 36168 11802 0.00005563 8.78387000 0.092277784 0.36701418 -31.364976 -0.0026452708 -0.0000325600000000000067428181094175698717663181014358997344970703125 -31.365009 1 155 3.0503500042169182648876812891103327274322509765625 3.72297890817267340679563858429901301860809326171875 4752/11860
Core -dustrelayfee=0 -paytxfee=0.00500000 28.75267541 109.5738998482549249047224293462932109832763671875 31 24388 36179 11822 0.00002650 9.99457000 0.090254682 0.36953598 -31.391428 -0.0026475017 -0.000045880000000000001184920217500717853909009136259555816650390625 -31.391474 1 119 3.05127772623766535531331101083196699619293212890625 3.444553377559158580112352865398861467838287353515625 N/A
BnB+Core Repeated Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.87052207 225.20704590598103322918177582323551177978515625 57 24388 36177 11846 0.00000241 7.99999834 0.044079288 0.20855531 -0.04181707 -0.0000035258912 -0.000084359999999999998681297908031950782969943247735500335693359375 -0.041901430 1 382 3.050337268128161749558557858108542859554290771484375 5.099606130292382744073620415292680263519287109375 2280/11860
Core Repeated Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.87047548 208.39872544692121891785063780844211578369140625 29 24388 36214 11855 0.00001333 7.99999834 0.055334876 0.25061846 -0.04186366 -0.0000035298196 -0.0000429200000000000091962722159610876815349911339581012725830078125 -0.041906580 1 668 3.053456998313659465082992028328590095043182373046875 7.0470460073749308094193111173808574676513671875 N/A
BnB+Core Cyclic Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.87051115 178.7087563451776759393396787345409393310546875 45 24388 36189 11846 0.00000241 5.51999834 0.043100286 0.20021529 -0.04182799 -0.0000035268120 -0.000066600000000000006091828430587753473446355201303958892822265625 -0.041894590 1 451 3.05134907251264753114128325250931084156036376953125 5.24464904178873769780011571128852665424346923828125 2295/11860
Core Cyclic Fees -dustrelayfee=0 55.87049772 218.065603619510028465811046771705150604248046875 49 24388 36197 11858 0.00000184 9.20999834 0.046778658 0.22037920 -0.04184142 -0.0000035279444 -0.000072520000000000003621651589735819243287551216781139373779296875 -0.041913940 1 338 3.0520236087689713855297668487764894962310791015625 5.70017745838109579636920898337848484516143798828125 N/A
final value total sent total deposited mean #UTXO final #UTXO #received #spent #payments sent #changes created min change max change mean change stDev of change total fees average fees fees to spend remaining UTXO total cost min input set max input set mean size of input set stdev of input set size Fees file Simulation File BnB Usage
55.88713405 -2484.3994 2540.3143409799973 19.85849529431419568936689756810665130615234375 17 6097 17913 11860 11833 0.00997809 4.15153434 0.10399897 0.28233767 -0.02520509 -0.0000021252184 -0.0000251600000000000030542755824480849469182430766522884368896484375 -0.025230250 1 24 1.510370994940978039977608204935677349567413330078125 1.0410142316722097444170458402368240058422088623046875 fees-bitcoinfees-info-repeats.csv derived-1I-2O.csv 27/11860
55.88171750 -2484.3994 2540.3143409799864 27.267855658102600813208482577465474605560302734375 21 12194 23840 11860 11667 0.00221449 5.69999834 0.056819638 0.19930147 -0.03062164 -0.0000025819258 -0.0000310800000000000005840987415961507167594390921294689178466796875 -0.030652720 1 84 2.010118043844856483559624393819831311702728271484375 1.8262218049879537229429615763365291059017181396484375 fees-bitcoinfees-info-repeats.csv derived-balanced.csv 193/11860
55.87130774 -2484.3994 2540.314340979981 131.06436217170602276382851414382457733154296875 33 24388 35121 11860 10766 0.00005428 4.69999834 0.036069275 0.13266262 -0.04103140 -0.0000034596459 -0.00004883999999999999994983179707475073882960714399814605712890625 -0.041080240 1 279 2.96129848229342318433054970228113234043121337890625 4.20967084360116938768214822630397975444793701171875 fees-bitcoinfees-info-repeats.csv moneypot.csv 1094/11860
55.88713391 -2484.3994 2540.3143409799973 22.934844350392605605293283588252961635589599609375 19 6097 17909 11860 11831 0.00998908 9.14499834 0.10465966 0.28952080 -0.02520523 -0.0000021252302 -0.0000281200000000000018191871620221178318388410843908786773681640625 -0.025233350 0 27 1.5100337268128161127833664068020880222320556640625 1.05932493680624073562057674280367791652679443359375 fees-bitcoinfees-info-cycle.csv derived-1I-2O.csv 28/11860
55.88173059 -2484.3994 2540.3143409799864 28.776419722291510794320856803096830844879150390625 20 12194 23831 11860 11657 0.00223019 5.69999834 0.056200963 0.19728515 -0.03060855 -0.0000025808221 -0.000029600000000000001201642951809134274299140088260173797607421875 -0.030638150 1 45 2.00935919055649225839488281053490936756134033203125 1.7222609388141678632422326700179837644100189208984375 fees-bitcoinfees-info-cycle.csv derived-balanced.csv 203/11860
55.87119478 -2484.3994 2540.314340979981 64.370503200176557356826378963887691497802734375 29 24388 35312 11860 10953 0.00015309 4.69999834 0.035168758 0.12918029 -0.04114436 -0.0000034691703 -0.0000429200000000000091962722159610876815349911339581012725830078125 -0.041187280 1 92 2.977403035413153542521058625425212085247039794921875 2.898949450951935347120524966157972812652587890625 fees-bitcoinfees-info-cycle.csv moneypot.csv 907/11860
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment