Encoding and Decoding Enums with Associated Values

Barcode.swift

// See http://proxpero.com/2017/07/11/encoding-and-decoding-custom-enums-with-associated-values-in-swift-4/
enum Barcode {
    case upc(Int, Int, Int, Int)
    case qrCode(String)
}

extension Barcode: Codable {
    init(from decoder: Decoder) throws {
        self = try Barcode.Coding.init(from: decoder).barcode()
    }
    func encode(to encoder: Encoder) throws {
        try Barcode.Coding.init(barcode: self).encode(to: encoder)
    }
}

extension Barcode {
    fileprivate struct Coding: Codable {
        private struct UPCDigits: Codable {
            let numberSystem: Int
            let manufacturer: Int
            let product: Int
            let check: Int
        }
        private enum CodingError: Error {
            case barcodeCodingError(String)
        }
        private var upc: UPCDigits?
        private var qrCode: String?
        fileprivate init(barcode: Barcode) {
            switch barcode {
            case .upc(let numberSystem, let manufacturer, let product, let check):
                self.upc = UPCDigits(numberSystem: numberSystem, manufacturer: manufacturer, product: product, check: check)
            case .qrCode(let productCode):
                self.qrCode = productCode
            }
        }
        fileprivate func barcode() throws -> Barcode {
            switch (upc, qrCode) {
            case (.some(let upcDigits), nil):
                return Barcode.upc(upcDigits.numberSystem, upcDigits.manufacturer, upcDigits.product, upcDigits.check)
            case (nil, .some(let productCode)):
                return Barcode.qrCode(productCode)
            default:
                throw CodingError.barcodeCodingError("Could not convert \(self) into either a upc or a qrCode")
            }
        }
    }
}

import Foundation

let encoder = JSONEncoder()
encoder.outputFormatting = .prettyPrinted
let decoder = JSONDecoder()
var productBarcode: Barcode
var data: Data
var json: String
var expectation: String
var result: Barcode

productBarcode = .upc(8, 85909, 51226, 3)
data = try encoder.encode(productBarcode)
json = String.init(data: data, encoding: .utf8)!
expectation = """
    {
      "upc" : {
        "check" : 3,
        "manufacturer" : 85909,
        "product" : 51226,
        "numberSystem" : 8
      }
    }
    """
result = try decoder.decode(Barcode.self, from: data)
assert(json == expectation)
//assert(result == productBarcode)


productBarcode = .qrCode("ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOP")
data = try encoder.encode(productBarcode)
json = String.init(data: data, encoding: .utf8)!
expectation = """
    {
      "qrCode" : "ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOP"
    }
    """
result = try decoder.decode(Barcode.self, from: data)
assert(json == expectation)
//assert(result == productBarcode)

@stephencelis your way would result in creating different JSON - without names for enum's associated values. so sending that to some kind of API may would result in parsing error since you've passed wrong JSON.